Blog
The Bay Bridge opens, 1936
The Bay Bridge opened November 12, 1936 with trains planned for its lower deck. How it was built, what ran on it and what changed in 1958 and 1989.
At 12:30 on the afternoon of November 12, 1936, California's governor took an acetylene torch to a set of gold chains stretched across the roadway, and the San Francisco-Oakland Bay Bridge was open. Former President Herbert Hoover and Senator William McAdoo watched. The Golden Gate Bridge was still six months from opening, so for half a year the bay's first great modern crossing was the one to the East Bay, not the one to Marin County. From the start it was meant to carry more than cars.
From an emperor's decree to a toll authority
The notion of bridging the bay is old enough to be a little eccentric. The Golden Gate Bridge's own timeline records that in 1869 Joshua Norton, the self-proclaimed emperor of San Francisco, first called publicly for bridges across the bay, and some accounts date his three decrees on the subject to 1872. The serious work came in the twentieth century. The state created the California Toll Bridge Authority in 1929. Congress approved the use of Yerba Buena Island, the natural midpoint between San Francisco and Oakland, on February 20, 1931. Federal permits followed in January 1932, and a ceremony was held on the island on February 24, 1932.
Construction began on July 9, 1933, at a groundbreaking attended by Hoover and the governor, James Rolph. President Franklin D. Roosevelt set off a blast by remote control. Rolph, who had been mayor of San Francisco from 1912 to 1931, died in office as governor on June 2, 1934, before the bridge was done. The opening of Muni, December 28, 1912 and City Hall rebuilt, 1915 describe the other projects of his years.
What was built
The National Park Service describes the Bay Bridge as about five miles long and made up of three bridges and a tunnel. Its chief engineer was Charles Henry Purcell. The structure strings together two separate crossings through Yerba Buena Island: a western section from San Francisco to the island, with a pair of suspension spans, and an eastern section from the island to Oakland, with a long cantilever span. When it was finished, the park service notes, its 1,400-foot cantilever was considered the longest in the world.
The figures in the standard account:
| Element | Figure |
|---|---|
| Western section | 10,304 feet |
| Eastern section | 10,176 feet |
| Total length, excluding approaches | 4.46 miles |
| Total cost | $77 million |
| Men who died during construction | 24 |
| Yerba Buena Tunnel | 540 feet long, 76 feet wide and 58 feet high |
The tunnel through Yerba Buena Island was hailed in 1936 as the world's largest-bore tunnel. The island itself is described in Treasure Island, and Treasure Island, built for a fair covers the artificial island attached to it.
Two decks, three kinds of traffic
The design reflected what the park service calls the commuting needs of the 1930s: rising automobile use and transit lines. The bridge was built with two decks. The upper deck carried automobiles, and the lower deck carried trucks and buses, with interurban trains running along its south side.
The trains, though, were not ready on opening day. The bridge opened in November 1936 without rail, and its first years belonged to cars. The first test train ran on September 23, 1938, and revenue service on the lower deck began on January 15, 1939, with the Key System's interurban cars crossing the bridge to a terminal in San Francisco. The service lasted less than twenty years. The last train ran in April 1958, and the Key System ended rail service on April 20 of that year; the tracks were later pulled up.
The order of events matters for the region's transit story. The bridge was built to carry rail, the rail came late and ran from 1939 to 1958, and the rail rights were turned over to road space. By the time the Bay Area built a rapid transit system, it went under the bay in a tube, described in BART opens, 1972 and BART from the Transbay Tube to SFO.
1963: one way on each deck
The bridge's traffic pattern changed on October 12, 1963, when the two decks were reconfigured to one-way traffic on each: westbound on the upper deck and eastbound on the lower. Drivers still use it that way. For anyone crossing in either direction, Crossing the Bay Bridge describes what to expect.
October 17, 1989
The Loma Prieta earthquake, which struck at 5:04 p.m. on October 17, 1989, brought down a 50-foot section of the eastern span's upper deck, which fell onto the deck below. One person died. The bridge stayed closed for just over a month and reopened on November 18, 1989. The earthquake and its effects across the city are the subject of The 1989 Loma Prieta earthquake.
The new eastern span
The collapse, and the earthquake risks it exposed, led to the replacement of the eastern span. Construction on the new span began on January 29, 2002. The old eastern span closed on August 28, 2013, the new one opened on September 2, 2013, at a reported cost of more than $6.5 billion, and demolition of the old span was finished on September 8, 2018. The original cost estimate for a seismic retrofit, by comparison, was $250 million. The western section, between the city and Yerba Buena Island, is the part of the 1936 structure still in service.
The bridge was listed on the National Register of Historic Places in 2001. The Metropolitan Transportation Commission manages it as a toll bridge, and the current westbound toll is posted on the commission's site, since tolls change.
Two bridges, six months apart
The Bay Bridge and the Golden Gate Bridge usually get told as separate stories, but the dates put them side by side. The Bay Bridge opened on November 12, 1936. The Golden Gate Bridge opened to pedestrians on May 27, 1937, which is 196 days later, a little over six months. Construction on the Bay Bridge began on July 9, 1933, and on the Golden Gate on January 5, 1933, so the two projects were under way at once.
| Bay Bridge | Golden Gate Bridge | |
|---|---|---|
| Construction began | July 9, 1933 | January 5, 1933 |
| Opened | November 12, 1936 | May 27, 1937 (pedestrians); May 28 (vehicles) |
| Cost | $77 million | $35 million bond issue |
| Deaths during construction | 24 | 11 |
The Golden Gate's figure is the bond issue that voters approved on November 4, 1930, by 145,657 votes to 46,954, and the Golden Gate Bridge District says the bridge opened ahead of schedule and under budget. The two cost figures do not compare cleanly, one being a final cost and the other a bond authorization, but the Bay Bridge cost more than twice the bond that financed its neighbor. Building the Golden Gate Bridge, 1933 to 1937 tells the other story.
A little arithmetic
The total cost of $77 million over a length of 4.46 miles, excluding approaches, works out to about $17 million for each mile of bridge in 1936 dollars. The 24 men who died during construction are the human cost recorded beside it; on the Golden Gate Bridge, a safety net installed on August 31, 1936 was in place when a scaffold fell into it on February 17, 1937.
Questions drivers ask
Which deck goes which way? Since October 12, 1963, the upper deck has carried westbound traffic toward San Francisco and the lower deck eastbound traffic toward Oakland. The two decks were originally laid out for traffic in both directions by vehicle type, with cars above and trucks and buses below.
Does BART use the bridge? No. BART runs through a tube under the bay. The rail service that used the Bay Bridge was the Key System's, and it ended in 1958. BART's own opening on September 11, 1972, and the start of Transbay Tube service on September 16, 1974, are described in BART opens, 1972. Using BART and Caltrain from San Francisco explains how to ride it today.
Where is the bridge's midpoint? Yerba Buena Island, which is also the landing for the tunnel that carries the roadway through the island. The eastern half of the crossing runs from the island to Oakland.
Is the 1936 bridge still there? The western section, from San Francisco to Yerba Buena Island, is. The eastern section was replaced by the new span that opened on September 2, 2013.
A timeline
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| 1869 | Joshua Norton first calls publicly for bridges across the bay |
| 1929 | California Toll Bridge Authority created |
| February 20, 1931 | Congress approves use of Yerba Buena Island |
| July 9, 1933 | Construction begins |
| November 12, 1936 | Bridge opens at 12:30 p.m. |
| September 23, 1938 | First test train |
| January 15, 1939 | Rail service begins on the lower deck |
| April 1958 | The last train runs |
| October 12, 1963 | Traffic made one-way on each deck |
| October 17, 1989 | A section of the eastern span collapses |
| September 2, 2013 | The new eastern span opens |
| 2018 | Demolition of the old eastern span completed |
The bridge in the city
On the San Francisco side the bridge rises near the southern waterfront, where South Beach and Rincon Hill sits beside the ballpark. The Embarcadero Freeway, which stood from 1968 to 1991, is described in The Embarcadero Freeway, 1968 to 1991. The Salesforce Transit Center, which replaced the older Transbay Terminal, serves buses that cross the bridge, as covered in The Salesforce Transit Center.
The state transportation department's history of the 1930s at dot.ca.gov and the National Park Service's page on the bridge at nps.gov cover its construction.