Blog

The 1989 Loma Prieta earthquake

The 5:04 p.m. quake of October 17, 1989: what happened in the Marina, on the Bay Bridge and along the Embarcadero, and what changed afterward.

It was 5:04 on a Tuesday afternoon, October 17, 1989, when the ground in the Santa Cruz Mountains let go, and within seconds the shaking was in San Francisco, 60 miles to the north. The earthquake measured magnitude 6.9. It killed 63 people across the Bay Area and Monterey Bay region, injured 3,757 and did an estimated $5.6 to $6 billion in damage. In San Francisco it left a burning block in the Marina, a closed Bay Bridge and a waterfront freeway the city would never reopen.

A gap on the fault

The quake was centered in what is now the Forest of Nisene Marks State Park in Santa Cruz County, roughly ten miles northeast of the city of Santa Cruz. The stretch of fault that moved had been relatively quiet since the 1906 San Francisco earthquake, and seismologists called it a seismic gap, a segment that had gone a long time without slipping. There had been warnings: two moderate foreshocks, in 1988 and 1989. Nobody could say when the bigger one would come.

The timing was odd, and lucky. The Bay Area was settling in for Game 3 of the 1989 World Series, the Giants against the Athletics, and the game was about to start at Candlestick Park when the shaking began. A lot of people who would ordinarily have been on the freeways at that hour were home or at the game, watching on television. Seismologists and officials have said more than once that this probably kept the death toll down. The game was postponed. Candlestick Park, the Giants' home from April 12, 1960 until the end of the 1999 season, was shaken but stayed up, and the stadium television viewers watched sway that evening was in use for another decade. The broadcast itself carried the first news of the quake to much of the country, with announcers on the air as the picture failed.

The Marina: ground that moves

Inside the city, the worst damage was in the Marina District, a neighborhood of apartments and single-family houses along the bay. It sits on fill, much of it material dumped on the tidal flats for the 1915 Panama-Pacific International Exposition (The Marina: a district built on a world's fair). During the shaking, saturated sand and silt in the fill lost its strength and behaved like a liquid, a process called liquefaction. Buildings tilted and sank, streets cracked and gas and water mains broke.

Fires broke out in the Marina, fed by ruptured gas lines, and the broken water mains hobbled the response. Four people died in the Marina. The fireboat Phoenix, which could draw water from the bay, was brought in, and crews fought blazes on streets the broken mains had left dry. The picture of the burning block, in a neighborhood of Mediterranean-style apartment buildings with garages at street level, became the image of the quake in San Francisco. Many of the buildings that failed were wood-frame structures with big openings on the ground floor, a design later called "soft-story" (Soft-story buildings and the Marina).

The Bay Bridge and the Oakland freeway

The most dramatic damage was on the bridges and freeways. On the San Francisco-Oakland Bay Bridge, a section of the upper deck dropped onto the lower deck, and one driver died. The bridge, which had opened in 1936, stayed closed for about a month while crews repaired it, and the closure cut the main road link between San Francisco and the East Bay.

The deadliest single failure was across the bay in Oakland. The double-deck Cypress Street Viaduct on Interstate 880 collapsed, and 42 people died there, the largest share of the quake's casualties. In Santa Cruz, debris falling from buildings on the historic Pacific Garden Mall and collapsed structures killed several others.

While the Bay Bridge was out, the Transbay Tube, built to carry BART trains under the bay, stayed in service and carried commuters. Ferries began running more often. For several weeks, the closed bridge made it plain how much the region depended on a handful of crossings.

The Embarcadero Freeway

San Francisco's most visible casualty was the Embarcadero Freeway, the elevated double-deck road along the waterfront that had been open since 1968. The earthquake damaged it, and it was closed. Once shut, it never reopened. Neighbors and planners argued over whether to restore or remove a structure many had long disliked, and the argument ended in a decision to demolish it. It came down in the years that followed (The Embarcadero Freeway, 1968 to 1991).

Its removal changed the waterfront. With the freeway gone, the Ferry Building and the Embarcadero were visible from Market Street again, and the street along the bay became a boulevard with a promenade. It is one of those cases where an earthquake handed the city a chance to make a change it had never managed to make on its own.

What the city learned

Loma Prieta was a moderate earthquake, and the damage piled up where the ground was soft and the structures were vulnerable. That made it a clear lesson for planners and engineers.

  • Ground matters. The Marina's liquefaction showed how fill can amplify damage, and it led to attention to the city's liquefaction zones in building review. The Department of Building Inspection and the Planning Department use hazard maps when they review projects (Department of Building Inspection and the Permit Center).
  • Soft-story buildings are a known weakness. Buildings with large openings at street level, often garages, did badly. San Francisco later adopted a mandatory program for retrofitting wood-frame soft-story apartment buildings, a program that grew out of this experience.
  • Lifelines need backup. The broken water mains in the Marina showed why a firefighting water source independent of the main system matters. The city has since added to its supplemental firefighting water system.
  • Bridges and viaducts could be fixed. Older double-deck structures were replaced or strengthened. The Bay Bridge's eastern span was eventually rebuilt entirely.
  • Emergency preparedness is a civic habit. The Department of Emergency Management runs the city's alert system and its preparedness programs (Department of Emergency Management).

If it happens again

What the city tells residents today follows from what 1989 showed. San Francisco's official earthquake page says the city's history and geography make earthquakes a significant risk, and its guidance comes in three stages.

Before. Make an emergency plan and assume that cell service will be unreliable or unavailable. Keep supplies where they are easy to reach, and anchor heavy furniture and televisions. Fit cabinets with latches so that glass does not spill out. Find the gas main and its shutoff valve and keep a wrench next to it; a tenant who does not know where it is can ask the landlord, and anyone can call PG&E at 1-800-743-5000. The Marina fires of 1989 are the reason the gas valve matters.

During. Indoors, drop to the ground, get under a sturdy table or desk and hold on until the shaking stops. With no cover, protect the head and neck with the arms and move to an interior corner, away from windows, glass and anything that could fall. Do not run outside during the shaking. Outdoors, move away from buildings, streetlights and utility wires. In a car, stop when it is safe, stay inside and avoid stopping under buildings, trees, overpasses and wires; the collapse of the Cypress Viaduct is the reason for that last instruction. Expect aftershocks and drop, cover and hold on again when they come.

After. Check for injuries, then for leaking gas or water and downed power lines. Shut off the gas main if there is a smell of gas, a hissing sound or a broken line. If the building looks unsafe, leave carefully for an open area with a Go Bag and do not go back in. Post a note with a new location if you leave. Tune to local radio for official updates, KCBS at 740 AM and 106.9 FM, KQED at 88.5 FM or KALW at 91.7 FM, and on the coast watch for tsunami warnings. The city posts updates during a major emergency at sf.gov/ReadySF, and AlertSF, the city's text alert system, is reached by texting a ZIP code to 888-777 or signing up at AlertSF.org (Preparing for an earthquake in San Francisco; Signing up for AlertSF and other emergency alerts).

The toll in perspective

The casualty figures break down. Of the 63 deaths, 42 were at the collapsed Cypress Street Viaduct in Oakland, one was on the Bay Bridge and four were in San Francisco's Marina, which accounts for 47 of the total. The remaining 16 occurred elsewhere in the region, including in Santa Cruz, where falling debris and collapsed buildings on the Pacific Garden Mall killed several people. Put another way, nearly three of every four deaths came from the failure of one elevated structure. That pattern shaped the response: engineers turned their attention to older double-deck viaducts and to buildings with weak ground floors, the two kinds of structure that had failed most severely.

Timeline

Time Event
1988 and early 1989 Two moderate foreshocks
October 17, 1989, 5:04 p.m. The magnitude 6.9 earthquake; Game 3 of the World Series is about to begin
Within minutes Fires in the Marina; part of the Bay Bridge's upper deck falls; the Cypress Viaduct collapses in Oakland
That evening The Marina fires are fought with water drawn from the bay
Following weeks The Bay Bridge is repaired and reopened; the Embarcadero Freeway stays closed
1991 The Embarcadero Freeway, closed since the quake, is demolished

The numbers in perspective

The 1906 earthquake was estimated at magnitude 7.9 and was followed by three days of fire that destroyed about a quarter of the city. Loma Prieta, at magnitude 6.9, was much smaller. On the logarithmic scale seismologists use, one point of magnitude represents about thirty times as much energy, so the 1906 quake released on the order of thirty times more energy than the 1989 event, in a city whose wood and brick buildings stood closer together and whose fire department's water supply was far weaker. That comparison is one reason experts call 1989 a warning and not the feared "big one." The Marina, the bridges and the freeways showed what a moderate shock could do to a modern region.

Related city government

Related guides

Related neighborhoods

Latest on this topic