Blog

The opening of Muni, December 28, 1912

On December 28, 1912, Mayor Rolph piloted Car 1 down Geary Street to open Muni. Four elections, a conversion in seven months and a rival that lasted until 1944.

The mayor drove the first car himself. On December 28, 1912, about 50,000 San Franciscans packed Market and Geary Streets to watch James Rolph Jr., Sunny Jim to nearly everyone, climb aboard Municipal Railway Car Number 1, drop a five-cent fare into the box with one of the first nickels struck at the San Francisco Mint a few blocks away, and take the controls. Out Geary Street he went. His was the first of Muni's ten opening-day cars, the line was the A Geary, and the crowd, according to the Market Street Railway historical nonprofit, was cheering the first publicly owned streetcars in any major American city. The San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency says Muni is still the oldest publicly operated transit system in the nation.

A cable line the city wanted to keep

What Muni took over had been a private cable railway. The Geary Street cable line ran from Market and Geary Streets west to Fifth Avenue in the Richmond District. It was not part of United Railroads, the big company that by 1902 had swallowed more than ten of the city's transit systems, and it ran through valuable retail and residential ground. Its franchise ran out on November 6, 1903, which handed the city a chance to take the route for itself.

The notion was older than the franchise's end. In 1901 City Engineer C. E. Grunsky proposed converting the Geary tracks, which were in excellent condition, to electric streetcars powered through an underground conduit, with no overhead wires.

Four elections

Raising the money took four tries. Bond measures needed a two-thirds majority, and the municipal railway proposals kept coming up short:

Year Result
1902 A bond issue for the conversion fails to win a two-thirds majority
1903 A second attempt also fails
June 1909 Voters reject a municipal Geary line, narrowly
December 30, 1909 A special election approves it on the fourth attempt

The SFMTA's history records that voters, angry at the private operator's conduct, approved a bond in December 1909. United Railroads had hardened opinion against itself. The Chicago-owned company, consolidated in 1902, had refused to pay for converting the Market Street cable system to electric streetcars on an underground conduit and wanted overhead wires instead. The streetcar nonprofit's history says that after the 1906 earthquake the company won permission to string wires on Market Street temporarily, and the wires stayed.

Some bankers turned the Municipal Railway bonds down as too risky, so many were sold to local investors. San Franciscans, in other words, bought their own railway.

Seven months of construction

Construction began in June 1911. On May 5, 1912, the Geary cable stopped running and crews started replacing the cable line's infrastructure with streetcar track. In the seven months before opening they rebuilt about 6.5 miles of track between Kearny Street and Fifth Avenue, plus a spur up Tenth Avenue toward Golden Gate Park.

The railway needed cars as well. The contract went to the Holman company for 43 cars of a California design, but it had delivered only ten by December 1912 and twenty in all, and the rest came from Union Iron Works. The cars that went into service on opening day were ten locally built streetcars in gray and maroon, with "Municipal Railway" in gold leaf on their letterboards.

December 28, 1912

On the day, the mayor boarded Car 1 at Market and Geary, paid his fare and personally piloted it past Jones Street and out Geary. Rolph called the line, in the words the streetcar history records, "the people's road, built by the people and with the people's money." The SFMTA's history describes a large crowd on Geary Street near Grant Avenue and lists the opening service as the A and B lines on Geary between downtown and 33rd Avenue. Inner Richmond and Outer Richmond describe the neighborhoods the line served, and The Richmond District, inner and outer tells how they grew.

Thomas Cashin was the first general manager, from 1912 to 1917. For the next two decades the Municipal Railway sat inside the city's engineering bureaucracy: from 1912 to 1932 it fell under the Bureau of Engineering within Public Works, and from 1932 to 1994 it was a division of the San Francisco Public Utilities Commission.

Growing beside a rival

Muni started as one line and grew up next to a far bigger competitor. United Railroads stayed the larger operation after 1912 and was renamed the Market Street Railway in 1921. Muni grew by building. A bond issue of $3.5 million was approved in 1913 to expand it. The J Church line opened on August 11, 1917, and the Twin Peaks Tunnel opened in February 1918, a story told for the J Church in The J Church through Noe Valley and Glen Park.

The competition ended in 1944, when bond measures paid for a buyout and the city acquired the Market Street Railway and merged it with Muni. The cable car lines that came down from the private companies became the subject of a separate fight, described in hallidie and the first cable car, 1873.

The pace of the conversion

The speed of the work deserves a little arithmetic. The cable stopped on May 5, 1912, and the line opened on December 28, a span of 237 days. Replacing about 6.5 miles of track in that time, which is 34,320 feet, comes to roughly 145 feet of finished track for every calendar day, Sundays included, along with the spur up Tenth Avenue and the cars to run on it. The streetcar nonprofit's history calls the conversion unbelievably fast, and the numbers back it up.

The speed mattered politically as well as practically. After four elections, the city had to show that a municipal railway could be built and run. Opening on the last Saturday of the year, after seven months of work, let the mayor close out 1912 with a working line.

Following the first route

The original route is still easy to trace. Geary Street starts at Market Street, where 50,000 people stood that day, and heads west past Union Square, which the Geary, Powell, Post and Stockton Street blocks enclose. The mayor drove the car past Jones Street and on toward the Richmond District. The Mint where the nickel for the first fare had been struck stood on Fifth Street, less than three blocks from the starting point. Today the 38 Geary bus carries the route along the same street, and Union Square and Inner Richmond sit on the corridor.

The Tenth Avenue spur to Golden Gate Park shows how big the planners were thinking. A line that reached the park gave the whole district a destination, and Golden Gate Park's 1,017 acres describes the park the riders were being carried to.

Muni in the city's civic history

Muni's opening was one of several large public projects of its decade. Within three years the city would dedicate its new City Hall and host a world's fair, and by 1923 it would finish a dam in the Sierra Nevada to supply its water. City Hall rebuilt, 1915 and The Panama-Pacific International Exposition, 1915 tell the first two. Together the projects describe a city that had burned in 1906 (the 1906 earthquake and fire) and was rebuilding itself with public money and public ownership.

From a bureau to an agency

How Muni is governed has changed again and again. The sequence in the SFMTA's own history:

  • 1912 to 1932: Under the Bureau of Engineering in Public Works.
  • 1932 to 1994: A division of the Public Utilities Commission.
  • 1994 to 2000: Overseen by a Public Transportation Commission.
  • 1999: Voters approve Proposition E, combining Muni and the city's parking and traffic department under the new SFMTA. When voters created the SFMTA, 1999 tells that story.
  • March 2000: The SFMTA becomes a city department, and on July 1, 2000, it officially takes over management of Muni.
  • 2007: Proposition A expands the agency's authority and lets it issue bonds.
  • 2009: The agency takes over taxi regulation.

Other turning points include the 1973 Transit-First resolution, adopted on March 19; the 1974 introduction of the monthly Fast Pass; the start of Muni Metro service in 1980; the T Third line in 2007 and the E Embarcadero streetcar in 2015; and the Central Subway, which opened in 2023 and extends the T Third through SoMa, Union Square and Chinatown. The T Third and the Central Subway covers the last of these.

Muni today

The SFMTA calls Muni the eighth largest public transit system in the country. Its official route list had 73 entries in November 2026. They include the Muni Metro lines F Market and Wharves, J Church, K Ingleside, L Taraval, M Ocean View, N Judah and T Third, three cable car lines, and many bus and trolley routes, such as the 1 California, 5 Fulton, 14 Mission, 19 Polk, 22 Fillmore, 38 Geary and 49 Van Ness/Mission. The 38 Geary bus runs on the street where Car 1 made its first trip. The agency's board is appointed by the mayor and confirmed by the Board of Supervisors. San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency describes the agency, How to ride Muni explains how to ride, and muni's route names and what they mean decodes the route names.

Reading the numbers

Three numbers sum up the opening. Four is the number of elections it took to win approval. Seven is the months between the cable's last run on May 5, 1912, and the first streetcar on December 28, in which crews replaced about 6.5 miles of track. Ten is the number of cars ready on opening day, under a plan that called for far more. The ambitions were large and the first day was modest, and the line succeeded because it kept expanding: the 1913 bond, the J Church, the tunnel and, in the end, the purchase of its rival.

The SFMTA's history page, at sfmta.com, and the Market Street Railway's account of Muni's birth, at streetcar.org, give the sequence in more detail.

Related city government

Related guides

Related neighborhoods

Latest on this topic