Blog
Crossing the Bay Bridge
Two bridges in one: the 1936 western suspension span, the Yerba Buena tunnel, the 1989 collapse and the 2013 eastern span that replaced the cantilever.
The Golden Gate Bridge gets the postcards. The Bay Bridge gets the commute. It opened on November 12, 1936, about six months ahead of its better-known neighbor, and it carries Interstate 80 across the bay between downtown San Francisco and Oakland. Anyone who drives it eventually notices it is really two bridges that meet at a rocky island: a pair of suspension spans on the San Francisco side and, since 2013, a single-tower suspension span on the Oakland side that replaced the cantilever the bridge was born with. In between, the road goes through a tunnel bored through the middle of an island, the largest-bore tunnel in the world when it was cut.
The western span
The part from downtown San Francisco to Yerba Buena Island is a double suspension bridge: two suspension spans joined at a central anchorage in the middle of the water. The roadway leaves the city at Rincon Hill, in the South Beach and South of Market area, climbs on its approach ramps and passes over the Embarcadero, then rides the two suspension spans out to the island (South Beach and Rincon Hill). The western span is 10,304 feet long, or just under two miles.
The bridge has two decks. Today westbound traffic, toward San Francisco, uses the upper deck, and eastbound traffic, toward Oakland, uses the lower deck. That has been the layout since 1963. In 1936 it was different. The upper deck carried automobiles, and the lower deck carried trucks, buses and interurban trains, which ran across the bridge until the trains were removed. The switch to one-way decks in 1963 turned the lower level into an eastbound roadway.
The western span does not allow bicycles or pedestrians. The only walking and biking route is the path on the east span, which ends at Yerba Buena Island (Biking in San Francisco).
The tunnel through Yerba Buena Island
Midway across, the road enters the Yerba Buena Tunnel, bored through the central hill of the island. It is about 540 feet long, 76 feet wide and 58 feet high, and when the bridge opened in 1936 it was described as the world's largest-bore tunnel. Drivers are through it in a few seconds, but it was a serious feat of engineering, because it had to carry two decks of traffic through rock.
The island on the far side also has the exit to Treasure Island, a man-made island built beside it in 1936 and 1937 for the 1939 world's fair (Treasure Island, built for a fair). The ramps for Treasure Island leave the bridge beside the tunnel, so a driver headed for the smaller island takes an exit before crossing to the east side.
The eastern span, old and new
The original eastern span, from Yerba Buena Island to Oakland, was a cantilever bridge with five truss spans and a long truss causeway. It was a different kind of structure from the suspension spans in the west, and it was the part of the bridge that failed in 1989 and was ultimately replaced.
The new east span is a single-tower, self-anchored suspension bridge. Construction began on January 29, 2002. The span opened on September 2, 2013, at a cost reported as more than $6.5 billion. A single tower holds up the roadway with one main cable that loops under the deck and attaches to it. The new span carries traffic in both directions on a single wide deck, and it leads from the island down an inclined viaduct into Oakland. Demolition of the old span took years and finished on September 8, 2018.
The new span carries a path as well. A separated bikeway and pedestrian path on the south side of the east span opened in October 2016. It connects Oakland to Yerba Buena Island and gives a view of the bay and the city skyline that most drivers never get.
The bridge in numbers
| Feature | Figure |
|---|---|
| Opened | November 12, 1936 |
| Western span length | 10,304 feet |
| Eastern span length (new) | 10,176 feet |
| Yerba Buena Tunnel | about 540 feet long, 76 feet wide, 58 feet high |
| Upper deck | westbound, toward San Francisco |
| Lower deck | eastbound, toward Oakland |
| New eastern span opened | September 2, 2013 |
| Old eastern span fully removed | September 8, 2018 |
A little arithmetic gives the length some context. The western span alone is 10,304 feet, about 1.95 miles, since 10,304 divided by 5,280 is 1.95. At a steady 50 miles an hour a car covers that in about 2 minutes and 20 seconds. Nobody holds a steady 50 on the weekday commute, which is why the same stretch can take much longer when traffic backs up on the approaches or at the Oakland toll plaza.
A timeline
- November 12, 1936. The bridge opens, about six months before the Golden Gate Bridge.
- 1936 and 1937. Treasure Island is built beside it.
- 1963. The decks are set to one-way traffic, westbound above and eastbound below.
- October 17, 1989. An upper-deck section of the eastern span falls, and the bridge reopens on November 18.
- January 29, 2002. Construction of the new eastern span begins.
- September 2, 2013. The new eastern span opens.
- October 2016. The east span bikeway and pedestrian path opens.
- September 8, 2018. Demolition of the old eastern span is finished.
What happened on October 17, 1989
The eastern span was replaced because of the Loma Prieta earthquake. The magnitude 6.9 quake struck on October 17, 1989, at 5:04 p.m., and a 50-foot section of the upper deck of the old eastern truss collapsed onto the deck below at a pier called E9. One person died on the bridge. The bridge was closed for just over a month and reopened on November 18, 1989.
The collapse was the most dramatic image from the quake in the Bay Area and set off a long process of seismic retrofit and replacement. The state, which owns and operates the bridge through Caltrans, decided to replace the old cantilever rather than retrofit it, a choice that took years of debate over cost, design and timing. The earlier quake in the city's story, 1906, came before the bridge existed, but the 1989 event is the one that shaped its present form (The 1989 Loma Prieta earthquake).
For anyone who lives in the area, the lesson is practical. The Bay Bridge is a lifeline, and when it closes, traffic across the region reroutes to other crossings and to BART. The city's emergency alert system lets residents sign up for messages by texting a ZIP code to 888-777 (Department of Emergency Management, Signing up for AlertSF and other emergency alerts).
Paying the toll
The Bay Bridge is a toll bridge, but the toll is collected in only one direction and at the Oakland end. Drivers pay when traveling westbound, toward San Francisco, at the toll plaza on the Oakland side. The toll is collected electronically, with FasTrak or by license plate, and cash is not accepted. Carpools qualify for a discount during weekday peak hours with the proper FasTrak device. The Bay Area Toll Authority sets the rates and posts them on its website, and they have changed over time, so a driver should check the current figure.
Because the toll plaza is on the Oakland side, trips between San Francisco and Treasure Island do not pass through it.
Getting across without a car
Plenty more people cross the bay under the bridge than over it. BART does not use the bridge. Trains cross in the Transbay Tube, which opened to passengers on September 16, 1974, after the system began running on September 11, 1972 (BART from the Transbay Tube to SFO). The tube and the bridge run roughly parallel across the bay, and the choice between them comes down to mode and time of day (Using BART and Caltrain from San Francisco).
Buses use the bridge, and the Muni 25 Treasure Island line crosses it to reach the island. Regional buses that run across the bay terminate at the Salesforce Transit Center, which opened in 2018 and replaced the older Transbay Terminal (The Salesforce Transit Center). Ferries cross the bay too, a quieter alternative (ferries across the bay).
Reading the bridge from the shore
The bridge looks different from different places.
- Rincon Park and the Embarcadero. From the waterfront near South Beach, the western approach rises overhead, and the cables and the roadway are visible from below.
- Yerba Buena Island. The tunnel's portals and the junction with the Treasure Island ramps show how the bridge threads through the rock.
- The east span path. From the path, the self-anchored suspension span and the single tower dominate the view toward Oakland.
- The city's skyline. From the island or the bridge itself, the Financial District's towers and Salesforce Tower mark the downtown (The Financial District and Montgomery Street).
The Golden Gate Bridge makes a useful comparison. The Golden Gate is a single suspension bridge, painted a bright color and open to walkers. The Bay Bridge is a composite of different structures, built in two different eras, silver-gray in color and closed to pedestrians on its west side (The Golden Gate Bridge on foot and by car). One is a symbol, and the other is the infrastructure that keeps the region moving. Its western span alone, at about 1.95 miles, is longer than the entire Golden Gate Bridge.