Blog
The Embarcadero Freeway, 1968 to 1991
The double-decked freeway that walled off the Ferry Building, how voters and an earthquake ended it, and what replaced it on the waterfront.
For about three decades a concrete viaduct stood between San Francisco and its own waterfront. The Embarcadero Freeway, a double-decked elevated road that ran past the Ferry Building, was among the most disliked pieces of infrastructure the city ever built, and for years it was also one of the busiest. Its removal is now treated as the start of the modern Embarcadero. How it came down shows how a city can change its mind, and how a disaster can force a decision that voters had declined to make.
How it got built
The freeway began as one piece of a bigger plan. After World War II, California and its cities drew up freeway networks meant to carry the growing flood of cars. In San Francisco the plan called for a series of elevated routes that would cut across neighborhoods and parks and meet at the waterfront. Construction of the Embarcadero section began in 1955, at the approach to the Bay Bridge. The first section opened on February 5, 1959, running from the bridge approach near First Street to Broadway. Ramps at Clay and Washington Streets opened in 1965, and the route was signed as State Route 480 in 1968. The years 1968 to 1991 in the title mark the period the finished freeway stood in its final form.
The structure was a double-decked viaduct, one roadway stacked on the other, running along the northeastern waterfront. The Ferry Building, the city's grand gateway since the 1890s, sat behind it. Drivers got a fast path between the Bay Bridge and the north end of downtown. Pedestrians got a dark, noisy waterfront that was closed off from the city. The great harbor-front boulevard, the Embarcadero, shrank to a service road under a roof of concrete.
The revolt that stopped the rest
The freeway was never finished. A political fight in the late 1950s, usually called the freeway revolt, turned public opinion against the larger plan. In 1959 the Board of Supervisors voted against most of the proposed freeways, and the network the planners had drawn was never built. The Embarcadero Freeway was one of the few pieces already standing, and it ended abruptly at Broadway instead of carrying on toward the Golden Gate (see US 101 through San Francisco for the highway that does cross the city to the bridge).
The unfinished stub became a symbol: a highway that led nowhere in particular and cut the city's best-known building off from the street. Over the following decades the argument over what to do with it moved from the planning meetings to the ballot.
The 1986 vote
In 1986 San Francisco voters considered a proposal to demolish the freeway, and they defeated it. That result is worth remembering because it complicates the tale of a freeway everyone hated. Many residents and commuters used it, and the cost and disruption of tearing it down were real. The freeway had defenders, too, who said that removing it would push traffic onto surface streets. The measure's defeat meant the structure would stay unless something changed.
October 17, 1989
Something did. The Loma Prieta earthquake struck on October 17, 1989, at 5:04 p.m. (see The 1989 Loma Prieta earthquake). It damaged the Embarcadero Freeway, and the structure was closed to traffic. Across the bay in Oakland, a double-decked structure of the same general kind, the Cypress Street Viaduct, collapsed, and that fact colored the debate that followed. The Embarcadero Freeway had not collapsed, but it had been weakened, and engineers had to assess whether to repair it or replace it.
A closed freeway can show a city what its absence looks like. With the Embarcadero Freeway sitting empty, the Ferry Building and the bay stood open to view from the foot of Market Street, and the traffic the freeway had carried had to find other routes. That changed the terms of the argument. People who had voted to keep the freeway in 1986 could now see what taking it away would do.
The vote and the demolition
After months of debate the Board of Supervisors voted, narrowly, six to five, for demolition. The city had a choice among retrofitting the structure, rebuilding it and taking it down. The thin margin shows how divided the board was. The decision turned on a mix of safety concerns, cost and the waterfront's potential.
Demolition began on February 27, 1991. The structure that had stood for decades came down in sections, and the city started work on what would replace it.
What replaced it
A surface boulevard replaced it. The new Embarcadero is a wide, palm-lined street with Muni tracks in the median. The F Market and Wharves historic streetcar line was extended along it, so vintage cars now run beside the water (see The F Market and Wharves historic streetcars). In front of the Ferry Building the city built Ferry Plaza, a public space that reaches toward the water. The Ferry Building itself was remodeled and reopened in 2003 as a marketplace with food vendors and shops, and ferries again run from its terminal (see ferries across the bay and The Embarcadero from the Ferry Building to Oracle Park).
The result is a waterfront that people can walk, bike and ride along, from the Ferry Building to Oracle Park and beyond. The stretch between the Ferry Building and the ballpark has become one of the city's best-known promenades. The Port of San Francisco, which owns and manages much of the waterfront, has been central to its upkeep and to the question of how it will adapt to rising seas (see Port of San Francisco).
The arguments on each side
The early-1990s decision was not one-sided, and the record shows a real argument.
For keeping or repairing it: the freeway carried heavy traffic between the Bay Bridge and the north end of downtown, and it saved commuters time. Repair was possible in principle, and demolition meant years of disruption on the waterfront. Some people living and working near the route worried that traffic would spill onto neighborhood streets once the freeway was gone, and that the city's rebuilt road would have to absorb it.
For taking it down: the freeway had darkened and divided the waterfront, and the earthquake damage showed the structure to be a safety concern. Removing it offered a chance to reconnect the city to the bay and restore the Ferry Building's setting. The empty months after the earthquake had also given the public a preview, and the closed road had not produced the traffic collapse opponents feared.
The six-to-five vote carries both views. The outcome, a boulevard in place of a viaduct, is now widely seen as a success, but it was a close call at the time.
The Ferry Building, uncovered
The building that gained most from the removal was the Ferry Building, which opened in 1898 and was for decades the city's main entrance from the water. Before the bridges, people reached San Francisco by ferry from across the bay, and the clock tower was among the first things they saw. The tower, modeled on a Spanish bell tower, stands at the foot of Market Street, and the building came through both the 1906 and 1989 earthquakes. The freeway had cut its public face off from the city. When the freeway came down, the facade at the end of Market Street could be seen again. The building's 2003 reopening as a marketplace, with vendors and a regular farmers market outside, completed the change (see The Hayes Valley farmers market and Shared Spaces for how another market uses city streets).
The F line's tracks run past its doors. The ferry terminals behind it carry commuters and visitors over the same water the building was first built to serve.
Why it still matters
The Embarcadero Freeway matters for reasons beyond the waterfront.
- It is a case study in reversing a decision. A city built a freeway, voted to keep it, then voted to remove it after an earthquake. The sequence shows how a disaster can change what seems politically possible.
- It shaped how San Franciscans think about highways. The earlier freeway revolt and the removal of this structure belong to the city's identity as a place that turned down some of the road projects other cities accepted.
- It linked transportation and land use. The Embarcadero's new boulevard made possible the development of the blocks nearby, and the neighboring Financial District and South Beach changed along with it (see Financial District and South Beach and Rincon Hill).
Timeline
- 1955: Construction begins at the Bay Bridge approach.
- February 5, 1959: The first section opens, from the bridge approach to Broadway.
- 1959: The Board of Supervisors votes against most of the planned freeway network.
- 1965: Ramps at Clay and Washington Streets open.
- 1968: The route is signed as State Route 480.
- 1986: Voters defeat a proposal to demolish the freeway.
- October 17, 1989: The Loma Prieta earthquake damages the structure and the freeway is closed.
- After the earthquake: The Board of Supervisors votes six to five for demolition.
- February 27, 1991: Demolition begins.
- 2003: The Ferry Building reopens as a marketplace.
Walking where the freeway was
The best way to take in the freeway is to walk the street that replaced it. From the Ferry Building, the Embarcadero runs north and south along the water. South of the Ferry Building the road passes under the Bay Bridge's approach and continues toward Oracle Park. North, it heads for Pier 39 and Fisherman's Wharf (see Fisherman's Wharf). In either direction the median carries the F line's tracks, and the sidewalk beside the bay is wide enough for walkers, runners and cyclists to share.
Stand at the Ferry Building, face the street and picture a concrete deck above it. The scale of what was removed is the point. The freeway did not merely pass the building. It stood between the building and everything around it. Taking it down, after one vote that kept it and one earthquake that changed minds, restored the line of sight from the Market Street corridor to the bay.
What came after in the planning of other roads
The Embarcadero Freeway was not the only one to go after the 1989 earthquake. Part of the Central Freeway, the elevated route that carried 101 traffic near Hayes Valley, was also damaged and later replaced with Octavia Boulevard. Both changes swapped elevated highways for ground-level streets, and both now get cited in discussions of urban freeway removal elsewhere. The pattern in San Francisco was that long-controversial structures, once damaged, were not rebuilt in the old form.