Blog

BART from the Transbay Tube to SFO

How BART went from a 1940s idea for an underwater tube to service on September 11, 1972, and what its San Francisco stations and SFO connection do today.

The train that carries a commuter from Oakland to San Francisco in a few minutes began as a planning effort in the 1940s and very nearly died of politics in the early 1960s. Bay Area Rapid Transit, known as BART, opened for service on September 11, 1972, and the Transbay Tube, the tunnel under the bay that gives the system its reason for being, carried its first passengers on September 16, 1974. A rider who taps through a fare gate at Embarcadero today is using a system that took decades to argue into existence. The story is worth knowing, because it explains why BART looks the way it does, why San Mateo County got a different deal and how the line to San Francisco International Airport came about.

An idea from the 1940s

It starts in 1946, when business and civic leaders on both sides of the bay began meeting informally about traffic congestion. The Bay Bridge, open since 1936, was crowded, and the idea of a second crossing was in the air. In 1947 a joint Army-Navy review board concluded that another link between San Francisco and Oakland would be needed, and proposed an underwater electric rail tube (Crossing the Bay Bridge).

The state legislature moved next. In 1951 it created the 26-member San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit Commission, and in 1957 the commission issued its final report. The legislature then formed the BART District with five counties: Alameda, Contra Costa, Marin, San Francisco and San Mateo. It also lowered the vote needed to approve bonds from two thirds to 60 percent, a change that proved decisive.

Counties drop out

Politics redrew the plan. In midsummer 1961 the final plan went to the five county boards of supervisors. In December 1961 San Mateo County withdrew, and in early 1962 Marin County did too. In July 1962 the supervisors of the remaining three counties, Alameda, Contra Costa and San Francisco, approved a revised plan.

The bond measure went to the voters of those three counties in November 1962 and passed with 61.2 percent, narrowly above the 60 percent it required. It funded a 71.5-mile system with 33 stations serving 17 communities. The bond issue was $792 million, and the projected total cost was about $996 million, including an estimated $133 million for the Transbay Tube and $71 million for the rolling stock. A taxpayer lawsuit then delayed work by about six months, at a cost of $12 million (BART opens, 1972).

The 1962 decisions still shape how the region works. San Mateo County was left out of the original system, which is why the airport extension arrived long after the first trains.

The tube

The Transbay Tube is the heart of the system. It is built from 57 segments, which BART says average about 330 feet in length, and it runs about 3.6 miles beneath the bay, resting on the bay floor at depths of up to 135 feet. The segments were built on shore, floated into place and sunk into a trench. Work began in 1966, and the completed structure was finished in August 1969, although trains did not run through it until 1974.

When it opened, the tube was described as the longest underwater tube of its kind in the world. Its completion made a rail trip across the bay possible without crossing the Bay Bridge, and that is why BART trains do not use the bridge. The tube and the bridge run roughly parallel across the water, one beneath and one above (Using BART and Caltrain from San Francisco).

The 1962 numbers

The figures voters saw in 1962 repay a little arithmetic. The bond issue was $792 million against a projected total of about $996 million, so the bonds were meant to cover about 80 percent of the cost, since 792 divided by 996 is about 0.795, and the other $204 million had to come from other sources. The Transbay Tube, at an estimated $133 million, was about 13 percent of the total, and the rolling stock, at $71 million, was about 7 percent. Put another way, the single tunnel under the bay was expected to cost about 17 percent of the whole bond issue, since 133 divided by 792 is about 0.168. These were 1962 estimates and not the final costs, and the project cost more than projected, as large transit projects usually do.

BART in dates

  • 1946. Civic and business leaders begin informal talks about bay crossings.
  • 1947. A joint Army-Navy review board proposes an underwater rail tube.
  • 1951. The legislature creates the Rapid Transit Commission.
  • 1957. The BART District is formed with five counties.
  • December 1961 and early 1962. San Mateo County and then Marin County withdraw.
  • November 1962. Voters in San Francisco, Alameda and Contra Costa Counties approve the $792 million bond with 61.2 percent.
  • 1966. Tube construction begins.
  • September 11, 1972. BART begins passenger service.
  • September 16, 1974. Transbay Tube service begins.
  • 2003. The airport extension opens.

Service begins: 1972 and 1974

BART began carrying passengers on September 11, 1972, on the first stretch of its system. The initial system opened in stages from 1972 to 1974, with new lines and stations added over the following decades. The Transbay Tube opened to passengers on September 16, 1974, connecting Oakland and San Francisco and giving BART its role in the city's commute.

The system kept growing. The Oakland Airport Connector opened in 2014, and in 2020 the Milpitas and Berryessa/North San Jose stations opened as part of the Silicon Valley extension.

BART in San Francisco

San Francisco has eight BART stations. In the order a train meets them heading from the East Bay, they are:

  1. Embarcadero. At the foot of Market Street, serving the Ferry Building and the Financial District.
  2. Montgomery Street. In the heart of the Financial District.
  3. Powell Street. Beside Union Square and the Powell cable car turnaround (Union Square, from plaza to shopping district).
  4. Civic Center/UN Plaza. Serving City Hall, the Main Library and the Asian Art Museum (Civic Center).
  5. 16th Street Mission. The northern gateway to the Mission District.
  6. 24th Street Mission. The heart of the Mission's Latino business district (Mission District).
  7. Glen Park. A neighborhood station on the south side (Glen Park).
  8. Balboa Park. A transfer point with the Muni Metro J, K and M lines.

The first four stations lie beneath Market Street, and they are Muni Metro stations too. A rider can use BART and Muni Metro with the same Clipper card, and one of the passes the SFMTA sells, the "A" pass at $104 in November 2026, covers both for travel within the city (muni passes versus pay-as-you-go: the arithmetic).

The line to SFO

BART's service to San Francisco International Airport is the part of the system most visitors use. A station at the airport connects the terminals to downtown and to the East Bay, so a traveler can get from a gate to the Powell Street station without a car (Getting from SFO to the city). The city operates the airport, which sits about 14 miles south of downtown in unincorporated San Mateo County and has been at its present site since May 7, 1927 (San Francisco International Airport, SFO, from Mills Field to an international airport).

The airport extension opened in 2003, a generation after the first trains. It came late because San Mateo County, which withdrew from the original district in 1961, was not part of the original plan, and the line to the airport and the Peninsula had to be added later through a separate arrangement with that county.

Paying for BART

BART is its own agency, separate from Muni, and it sets its own fares. In recent years the agency has accepted contactless payment. BART's "Tap and Ride" lets riders pay at the fare gates with a contactless card or phone, and Clipper, the regional card, works on 24 Bay Area transit systems, including Muni, BART and Caltrain. A rider arriving from BART who transfers to Muni within two hours of starting the first trip gets a discount on the Muni fare, described on the SFMTA's fare page as $2.85 off the adult Clipper fare (How Muni fares work in 2026).

For overnight and early-morning trips, Muni runs the 714 BART Early Bird bus, listed among its routes, which serves the early hours before BART starts running (muni's route names and what they mean).

What BART changed in the city

BART changed how San Francisco connects to the East Bay, and it changed the neighborhoods along its line. The Mission District's two stations anchor commercial blocks, and Glen Park's station supports a village center. The Civic Center and Powell stations feed the downtown. BART's route under Market Street was built as part of a broader plan that included the Muni Metro, and the two systems share a subway (Riding the N Judah from the ocean to the ballpark).

The system is also a reminder that regional transit decisions are made by people who may not live in the city. A district board governs BART, not the city, and its decisions on fares, schedules and extensions reflect a regional constituency. For San Francisco, that is a benefit, since it provides a fast link to the East Bay and the airport, and a limit, since the city does not control it.

A reader who wants to feel the history can ride the line from Embarcadero to the airport and watch the layers go by: the tube under the bay, the subway beneath Market, the stations in the Mission and Glen Park, and the airport at the end. Each was added at a different time, and each came out of a decision that someone had to fight to make.

Related city government

Related guides

Related neighborhoods

Latest on this topic