Blog

The 1906 earthquake and fire

A timeline of April 18 to 22, 1906: the 5:12 a.m. quake, three days of fire, the broken water supply and why death toll estimates run from 700 to over 3,000.

At 5:12 on a Wednesday morning, April 18, 1906, most of San Francisco was asleep. Three days later, when the last fires finally burned themselves out, a large part of the city's center was gone. Every argument about earthquake risk in the Bay Area still starts from that morning, and the hours and days that followed are worth setting down in order.

April 18, 5:12 a.m.: the shaking

The United States Geological Survey puts the magnitude at 7.8 in one of its accounts and 7.9 in another, estimates drawn from modern study of seismograms and field observations. The shaking went on for more than 40 seconds, and the rupture ran along nearly 300 miles of the San Andreas Fault. People felt it from southern Oregon to Los Angeles.

In San Francisco the shaking did its own damage to buildings, but the worst of it came afterward. It broke gas mains, and it severed the pipeline that carried water into the city. As the USGS account has it, the pipeline was cut, and fires from the broken gas mains burned out of control for three days. the 1906 fire and the water mains covers the failure of the water supply in more detail.

April 18: the first day of fire

Fires started on the day of the quake in several parts of the city. With the water supply broken, the fire department had little to fight them with, and they spread. Soldiers were in the streets. A USGS topographer who had come to San Francisco to check on a family member photographed soldiers on Van Ness Avenue, a horse-mounted "dynamite squad" and fires lighting up Union Square.

Dynamite was used to cut firebreaks, by blowing up buildings in the path of the flames. The tactic was controversial at the time and has been argued over since. The USGS's own photographs of the period show the dynamite squad at work.

April 19 and 20: the fire spreads

The fires kept going through April 19 and 20. On April 19, with their own plants destroyed or without power, several newspapers printed a combined edition on the presses of the Oakland Tribune, across the bay. Headlines in other cities reported a death toll that "may number 3,000."

By then an enormous number of residents had left their homes or lost them. In the days that followed, refugees gathered in the open spaces of the city, and major camps went up in the Presidio and in Golden Gate Park, with other camps run by the Army elsewhere in town.

April 21 and 22: the end of the fire and the start of rebuilding

The fires ended on April 21. The next day, April 22, rebuilding efforts were widely announced. In four days the city had gone from an ordinary Wednesday morning to a burned district with a stubborn will to start over.

The toll

The USGS accounts give the main figures:

  • Destruction: Shaking and fire destroyed nearly five square miles of the city's center.
  • Homelessness: About 225,000 people were left homeless.
  • Deaths: At least 3,000 people were killed, according to the USGS.

The death toll has been revised again and again. The first official count was about 700. Later estimates run three to four times higher, and the figure in the Library of Congress's collection of historical newspapers is "3,000 plus." A National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration estimate in 1972 gave 700 to 800. The spread, from about 700 to more than 3,000, reflects how hard it is to count the dead after a disaster that destroyed records and scattered a large population, which is why the number is usually given as a range.

The magnitude is an estimate too. The USGS puts it at 7.9 in its modern reanalysis, though a 2006 USGS pamphlet gave 7.8, and some earlier estimates ran as high as 8.3. Seismologists treat 7.8 to 7.9 as the current consensus.

What the fire destroyed and what it spared

The fire burned nearly five square miles at the center of the city. Some institutions were hurt, among them the cable car system, where Cable Car 155 was damaged by falling debris at the Washington and Mason cable car house, which was rebuilt afterward. hallidie and the first cable car, 1873 tells the history of the cable cars.

Many outlying neighborhoods never burned. The planning department's historic context statement notes that perimeter neighborhoods such as western Nob Hill, western Russian Hill, Pacific Heights, the Western Addition, the Mission and Noe Valley are more likely to have surviving houses from before 1906, because they missed the wholesale destruction closer to downtown. The Mission Dolores church, described in The founding of Mission Dolores and the Presidio, 1776, also came through.

Putting the area in proportion

The Geological Survey says shaking and fire destroyed nearly five square miles in the city's center. San Francisco's land area today is 46.91 square miles, so nearly five square miles is roughly a tenth of the land. Count by the people who lost their homes and the share is much bigger: about 225,000 homeless in a city whose population was then roughly 400,000, which is more than half of all residents. The two measures tell different stories because the burned area was the densest part of town, with downtown commerce, boarding houses and the crowded blocks where many people lived. Other accounts count by buildings or by developed area, and those measures give larger shares still.

The water question, from February to April

The Hetch Hetchy story shows how close the city came to a different water future in the weeks before the quake. On February 3, 1906, the Board of Supervisors passed a resolution asking officials to drop the Hetch Hetchy project and look for other water sources. Seventy-four days later the earthquake and fire destroyed much of the city, and within days the Board solicited offers to buy existing water systems and picked the Bay Cities Water Company from eleven offers. On May 18, 1906, Gifford Pinchot wrote to the city's water advocate Marsden Manson offering help acquiring the Hetch Hetchy reservoir rights. The disaster, in other words, reopened a question the city had been ready to shut. What followed is the subject of The Raker Act and Hetch Hetchy.

Where 1906 is visible today

The city that stands now was built on and out of the burned one, and traces of 1906 turn up all over it:

  • Perimeter neighborhoods. Western Nob Hill, western Russian Hill, Pacific Heights, the Western Addition, the Mission and Noe Valley have more surviving houses from before 1906 than downtown does, according to the planning department.
  • The Mission Dolores church, the oldest intact building in San Francisco, which stood through the fire.
  • The Presidio and Golden Gate Park, where the refugee camps stood. Presidio and Golden Gate Park's 1,017 acres describe the places today.
  • City Hall, the replacement building that opened in 1915 at the Civic Center.
  • The Palace of Fine Arts, the one surviving building of the 1915 world's fair that celebrated the recovery.
  • The cable car system, whose Washington and Mason car house was rebuilt after the fire and still houses the Cable Car Museum.

The consequences

Water. The failure of the water system during the fire strengthened the case for a new, city-owned supply from the Sierra Nevada. The Board of Supervisors had passed its resolution in February 1906, two months before the earthquake, asking officials to give up on Hetch Hetchy and seek other sources; after the quake, the city's attention swung back to water, and how that ended is told in The Raker Act and Hetch Hetchy.

Records. The loss of city records had lasting legal effects, including the loss of birth and citizenship documents that came to matter to Chinese residents under the exclusion laws. Chinese exclusion and San Francisco describes that chapter.

Rebuilding. The city rebuilt fast. Within a decade it had a new City Hall, which opened in 1915, and a world's fair to celebrate the recovery. City Hall rebuilt, 1915 and The Panama-Pacific International Exposition, 1915 tell those stories.

Preparedness. Every modern city program on earthquakes points back to 1906. The city's own earthquake page says that San Francisco's history and geography make earthquakes a significant risk. It advises residents to drop, cover and hold on, to know where their gas main is and to call PG&E at 1-800-743-5000 if unsure, and it warns that cell service will likely be unavailable. Preparing for an earthquake in San Francisco covers those steps, and Signing up for AlertSF and other emergency alerts explains the AlertSF text system, which a resident joins by texting a ZIP code to 888-777.

Comparing 1906 and 1989

The next big quake to hurt the city was Loma Prieta on October 17, 1989, a magnitude 6.9 event that struck at 5:04 p.m. and killed 63 people across the state. Liquefaction in the Marina District and the collapse of a section of the Bay Bridge were its best-known effects in San Francisco. It was smaller than 1906's and did far less damage in the city, but it is the one most living residents remember. The 1989 Loma Prieta earthquake covers it, and 1906 and 1989: two earthquakes compared sets the two side by side.

A day-by-day summary

Date in 1906 What happened
Wednesday, April 18, 5:12 a.m. Earthquake; broken gas mains and a severed water pipeline
April 18 Fires begin and spread; soldiers and dynamite squads work in the city
April 19 Fires continue; several newspapers print a combined edition on the Oakland Tribune's presses
April 20 Fires continue
April 21 The fires end
April 22 Rebuilding efforts are widely announced

The United States Geological Survey's account of the earthquake, at usgs.gov, and the Library of Congress's collection of 1906 newspapers, at loc.gov, hold the primary record, and the city's earthquake page at sf.gov lists what to do before the next one.

Related city government

Related guides

Latest on this topic