Blog
The Raker Act and Hetch Hetchy
Congress allowed San Francisco to dam a Yosemite valley on December 19, 1913. The fight over Hetch Hetchy, both sides, and the water that arrived in 1934.
Turn on a tap in San Francisco and the water in the glass probably started out as Sierra snow, in a valley inside Yosemite National Park that the city dammed under a federal law passed in 1913. The law is the Raker Act. It was among the most contested environmental decisions in American history, and the Senate settled it by a vote of 43 to 25, with 27 senators not voting. Both sides argued in earnest, and the story of the fight is also the story of how San Francisco came to own its water.
Water before Hetch Hetchy
In the 1850s San Francisco drank water sold by a private outfit, the Spring Valley Water Company, which began supplying the city in 1858. Disputes over price soon sent the city looking for water rights it could own outright. In 1876 and 1877 an engineer, George H. Mendell, surveyed possible sources and recommended a project on the Mokelumne River. In 1899 the state engineer William Ham Hall recommended reservoir sites in the Sierra, and a U.S. Geological Survey report identified Hetch Hetchy Valley, on the Tuolumne River, as a possible reservoir. That same year Mayor James D. Phelan hired an engineer, J. B. Lippincott, who estimated that a Hetch Hetchy reservoir would cost $39,531,000.
The valley lay inside Yosemite National Park, so the city needed federal permission. A law of 1901, the Right of Way Act, let the Secretary of the Interior grant land rights to local governments without a vote of Congress, and on October 16, 1901 Phelan filed an application with the Stockton Land Office.
Three refusals
The Interior Secretary of the day, Ethan Allen Hitchcock, said no. He denied the city's request on January 20, 1903, again on December 22, 1903, and a third time on February 20, 1905, citing the duty to keep Yosemite for recreation. In 1905 the Chief Forester, Gifford Pinchot, recommended that San Francisco be granted the rights.
The city itself was divided. On February 3, 1906, the Board of Supervisors passed Resolution No. 6949, asking officials to abandon Hetch Hetchy and look for other sources. Seventy-four days later, on April 18, 1906, the earthquake and fire destroyed much of the city. The broken water supply during the fire is described in the 1906 earthquake and fire. In the days after the disaster the Board solicited offers to buy existing water systems, and on May 18, 1906, Pinchot wrote to the city's water advocate, Marsden Manson, offering help in acquiring the Hetch Hetchy rights.
A permit, then a fight
A new Interior Secretary, James R. Garfield, took office in March 1907, and on May 11, 1908 he granted San Francisco a permit for reservoir rights, on the condition that the city use Lake Eleanor, another Sierra site, to its full capacity before Hetch Hetchy. The city asked Congress for immediate access to Hetch Hetchy, and Congress declined.
Opposition was organizing. In November 1907 the Sierra Club urged members to write to President Theodore Roosevelt in opposition, and John Muir endorsed the letter. In April 1909 William Colby founded the Society for the Preservation of National Parks, with Muir as president. In October 1909 Muir gave President William Howard Taft a tour of Yosemite Valley and gave Secretary Richard Ballinger a tour of Hetch Hetchy. On February 18, 1910 the Sierra Club, after a poll of members, officially supported preservation by a vote of 581 to 161.
San Francisco's voters, meanwhile, had put their own money behind the project. By October 1934 they had authorized seven bond issues totaling nearly $102 million for the Hetch Hetchy work.
1913: the bill
A decision in Washington came in 1913. On February 19, 1913 the Army Corps of Engineers reported that other adequate water sources existed but that Hetch Hetchy would cost about $20 million less than other feasible projects. On March 1, Interior Secretary Walter Fisher rejected the city's justification and said congressional approval was required. On April 7, Representative John E. Raker of California introduced H.R. 112. That bill and three compromise bills did not pass.
The turning point was a compromise between the city and two Central Valley irrigation districts, the Modesto and Turlock districts, reached in Washington in June 1913. It protected the districts' water rights and allowed for a system of 2,350 to 4,000 cubic feet per second. Another clause, added to quiet the Spring Valley Water Company, provided that water from sources near San Francisco be used before water from the Tuolumne could be diverted. The resulting bill, H.R. 7207, introduced August 1 and called the Hetch Hetchy Act but known popularly as the Raker Act, was adopted by the House on September 3, 1913, by a vote of 183 to 43.
The Senate, December 1913
In the Senate the debate ran to hundreds of pages of the Congressional Record, and newspapers across the country took editorial sides. Supporters included the California legislature, every major California city and the neighboring Bay Area communities, the War Secretary's Board of Army Engineers and, critically, the publisher William Randolph Hearst, whose San Francisco Examiner published a 16-page Washington edition on December 2, 1913 and put a copy on the desk of every senator. The Senate passed the Raker Act in a night session on December 6, 1913, by 43 to 25, with 27 not voting. President Woodrow Wilson signed the act on December 19, 1913, giving San Francisco the right to build a reservoir.
The argument
The two sides made arguments that are still easy to recognize.
For the dam. Gifford Pinchot, by then a former chief forester, testified that the reservoir represented the greatest good for the greatest number. The city's case was that San Francisco needed a secure, high-quality water supply, that the fire of 1906 had shown the danger of an inadequate one, and that the existing supplier was a private company. The Army engineers' report supported the economics, finding Hetch Hetchy about $20 million cheaper than other feasible projects. Some scientists argued that the dam would restore an ancient lake that had once filled the valley.
Against the dam. John Muir led the opposition, calling the valley one of Nature's rarest and most precious mountain temples. Opponents argued that a national park should not be dammed for a city's use. The presidents of Harvard University and Radcliffe College joined their faculties in pleading with the Senate to save the valley. Much of the opposition came from outside California. Muir later conceded that the city's residents needed water, but he hoped for an alternative.
The National Park Service notes that within three years of the Raker Act, Congress passed the Organic Act, on August 25, 1916, creating the National Park Service. Muir died on December 24, 1914.
Reading the votes
The roll calls look lopsided in the House and closer in the Senate. In the House, 183 to 43 means about 81 percent of those voting favored the bill. In the Senate, 43 to 25 means about 63 percent of the 68 senators who voted were in favor, while the 27 who did not vote made up more than a quarter of the 95 senators in the tally. The act won with a clear majority of those who voted.
The cost side has its own arithmetic. J. B. Lippincott's 1899 estimate for a Hetch Hetchy reservoir was $39,531,000. By October 1934 San Francisco voters had authorized nearly $102 million in bonds for the whole Hetch Hetchy system, which included not only the dam but the tunnels, the pipelines, the power plants and the long aqueduct. The later figure covers a much larger project than the 1899 estimate described, and it was built over twenty years in which the price of labor and materials changed, so the two cannot be compared directly. But the gap shows how much of the project was still ahead when the act passed.
A timeline
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| 1858 | Spring Valley Water Company supplies the city |
| 1899 | Hetch Hetchy identified as a possible reservoir; Phelan hires an engineer |
| February 15, 1901 | Right of Way Act becomes law |
| 1903, 1905 | Interior Secretary Hitchcock denies the city's requests |
| February 3, 1906 | Supervisors pass a resolution to abandon Hetch Hetchy |
| April 18, 1906 | Earthquake and fire |
| May 11, 1908 | Interior Secretary Garfield grants a permit with conditions |
| February 18, 1910 | Sierra Club votes 581 to 161 to support preservation |
| March 1, 1913 | Interior Secretary Fisher requires congressional approval |
| September 3, 1913 | House passes the Raker Act, 183 to 43 |
| December 6, 1913 | Senate passes it, 43 to 25, with 27 not voting |
| December 19, 1913 | President Wilson signs the act |
| May 1923 | O'Shaughnessy Dam is completed |
| October 1934 | Hetch Hetchy water reaches San Francisco |
Building the system
Work on O'Shaughnessy Dam began in 1914, and the dam was completed in May 1923. The valley became the Hetch Hetchy Reservoir. The Park Service says the valley now lies under about 300 feet of water and that the reservoir supplies a community of 2.6 million people.
The rest of the system took another eleven years. The aqueduct carries Tuolumne River water more than 160 miles from the Sierra Nevada to the Bay Area. The San Francisco Public Utilities Commission's history says the effort cost 89 workers' lives, including 12 lost in the Coast Range Tunnel disaster. Hetch Hetchy water reached the Peninsula in October 1934. The arrival was celebrated on October 28, 1934 at the Pulgas Water Temple beside the Crystal Springs Reservoir, and a coast-to-coast radio broadcast on October 24 featured Interior Secretary Harold Ickes and Mayor Angelo Rossi. The city's chief engineer, Michael O'Shaughnessy, who had designed the system, died on October 12 and did not hear it.
The legacy
The decision still divides people. The reservoir supplies drinking water and power to a large population, and the loss of the valley is lasting too. Muir's argument and Pinchot's argument were both made seriously, and Congress and the president chose.
For a San Francisco resident the practical connection is the water bill. The Public Utilities Commission, which runs the system, provides water, wastewater and power, and its account services are described in Setting up water, power and garbage service in San Francisco and San Francisco Public Utilities Commission. Hetch Hetchy water and what comes out of the tap follows the water from the reservoir to the tap, and Water, sewer and power bills from SFPUC explains the bills. The National Park Service's article on the Raker Act, at nps.gov, and the SFPUC's history at sfpuc.gov give the full record.