Blog
The 1906 fire and the water mains
How broken water mains left firefighters with little to pump in 1906, and the separate high-pressure firefighting system San Francisco built from 1909 to 1913.
The shaking on April 18, 1906, lasted less than a minute. The fire that came after it lasted four days and nights. Historians who have picked over the disaster mostly agree that the fire did the real damage, somewhere between 80 and 95 percent of it by their estimates, and that it ran as far as it did because the city could not get water onto it. How that happened, and the odd and sturdy system San Francisco built in answer, make up one of the best chapters in the city's infrastructure story.
What the fire destroyed
The numbers are hard to hold in the head. The fires destroyed about 25,000 buildings on 490 blocks. Between 227,000 and 300,000 people were left homeless in a city of about 410,000, and property losses topped $400 million in 1906 dollars. Fires started in many places at once, from broken gas lines and from stoves with damaged chimneys that lit buildings across town. One of the best known, the "Ham and Eggs" fire, began on the morning of April 18 at Hayes and Gough Streets in Hayes Valley, when a woman lit a stove with a badly damaged chimney. It ate about 30 blocks, City Hall and the Hall of Records among them. The story of the replacement City Hall is in City Hall rebuilt, 1915.
A modern city has fire engines, hydrants and a water system built to feed them, and in 1906 San Francisco had all three. What broke was the link between them.
What happened to the water
The quake cracked the water system that fed the city's hydrants. Mains in the ground were severed or crushed, and the systems that carried water into the city from outside were damaged. The privately owned Spring Valley Water Company supplied San Francisco in those years, and its pipelines from the Peninsula crossed ground that sits on an active fault. When the ground moved, the pipes broke. Hydrants that should have given firefighters a steady stream gave them a trickle or nothing at all.
So the firefighters improvised. They drew water from cisterns, from the bay and from whatever else could be reached, and they used dynamite to level buildings in the fire's path, hoping to cut firebreaks. The dynamite was often in the hands of people who had never been trained to use it, and buildings that were blown up sometimes caught fire themselves. With the mains dry, there was little to do once a fire got moving.
The department also lost its leader at the outset. Fire Chief Dennis T. Sullivan was gravely injured in the first moments of the quake and died of his injuries. Three years earlier, in 1903, he had proposed a separate high-pressure water system for firefighting alone. The city had not built it in time.
Building a second water system
After the fire, San Francisco set out to make sure the same failure could never come around twice. Voters approved bonds in 1908 for what became the Auxiliary Water Supply System, usually shortened to AWSS. Work began in 1909 and ended in 1913. Marsden Manson, the city engineer, led the planning, and the design was a separate network for fire protection only, independent of the pipes that carry drinking water.
The system's parts fit together like a small hydraulic city.
- Reservoirs and tanks. The Twin Peaks Reservoir holds 10.5 million gallons at an elevation of 758 feet. The Ashbury tank holds 500,000 gallons and the Jones Street tank 750,000. Gravity supplies pressure from the higher tanks to the hydrants below, and the system's hydrants run at high pressure, up to 214 psi from the Ashbury and Jones Street tanks.
- Pumping stations. Two stations can each pump 10,000 gallons per minute of salt water from the bay at 300 psi. Station No. 2 is on the National Register of Historic Places. Salt water is not drinkable, and that is part of the design: the system draws on the bay so it does not use up the city's drinking supply.
- Cisterns. The system includes 177 underground cisterns, each holding between 75,000 and 200,000 gallons, for a total of over 11 million gallons. They are the reserve of last resort if the pipes fail.
- Hydrants. About 1,889 large white hydrants connect to the system. The color of the cap tells which pressure zone a hydrant serves: black tops for the zone west of Twin Peaks, red for the upper zone, blue for the lower zone.
- Fireboats. The Phoenix delivers 9,600 gallons per minute and the St. Francis 18,000 gallons per minute, each at 150 psi, and they can pump bay water to the shore.
The system is sometimes called the largest high-pressure water distribution network for firefighting built in its time. Whatever its rank, the idea behind it is plain enough. If the main water system fails, firefighters have a second one to turn to.
The circles in the streets
Walkers in parts of the city can still spot traces of the AWSS. Brick circles set into the pavement at some intersections mark the cisterns buried beneath them. They are easy to miss, and they are one of the quieter pieces of evidence that the city planned for a fire that had already happened once. The system's hydrants are painted differently from ordinary ones, too, and local lore tells of a hydrant at 20th and Church Streets, painted gold, that helped save a part of the Mission in 1906. People tell that story often, and it has settled into the folklore of the fire.
The test in 1989
The next great test came on October 17, 1989, after the Loma Prieta earthquake. In the Marina District, a natural gas main ruptured at Beach and Divisadero Streets and set off a major fire. The nearby hydrant system failed, and the fire department had to make do, recruiting civilians to run hoses from a distance. The fireboat Phoenix pumped bay water to engines on shore, which sprayed the fire, a modern echo of 1906. The Marina itself was built on fill that included rubble from the 1906 earthquake. 1906 and 1989: two earthquakes compared compares the two earthquakes, and Soft-story buildings and the Marina follows the Marina's story.
The ownership story
The disaster fed a change in who owned San Francisco's water, too. The city had long wanted its own source, and in 1913 Congress passed the Raker Act, which allowed San Francisco to dam the Hetch Hetchy Valley in the Sierra Nevada. The water reached the Peninsula in October 1934. The private Spring Valley Water Company's local system was bought by the city in 1930. Today the San Francisco Public Utilities Commission runs the drinking water system, and the fire department's separate high-pressure system carries on in its own right. The Raker Act and Hetch Hetchy and Hetch Hetchy water and what comes out of the tap tell the story of the water that reaches the tap.
Timeline
- 1903: Fire Chief Dennis T. Sullivan proposes a separate high-pressure firefighting water system.
- April 18, 1906: the earthquake breaks the water supply; fires burn for about four days.
- 1908: voters approve bonds for the Auxiliary Water Supply System.
- 1909 to 1913: the system is built.
- December 19, 1913: the Raker Act is signed, allowing the Hetch Hetchy dam.
- 1930: the city buys the Spring Valley Water Company's local system.
- October 1934: Hetch Hetchy water reaches the Peninsula.
- October 17, 1989: the Marina fire shows the limits of the ordinary hydrant system and the value of the fireboat.
Questions people ask
Was it the earthquake or the fire that destroyed the city? The shaking did real damage, but the fires did most of the destruction, by estimates of 80 to 95 percent.
Why did the hydrants run dry? The quake broke the water mains and the pipelines that fed the city, so there was little water to deliver. The failure was in the supply, not in the hydrants themselves.
Does the AWSS still exist? Yes. The Twin Peaks Reservoir, the tanks, the pump stations, the cisterns and the fireboats are all part of the system, and pump station No. 2 is on the National Register of Historic Places.
Why salt water? The pumping stations draw from the bay, so the system does not depend on the drinking water supply that failed in 1906.
How can I see it? Look for brick circles in intersection pavement marking cisterns, and for hydrants with colored caps. The fire department's site and the city's historical walking tours are the best guides to what is still there.
What to take from it
Several lessons from 1906 still shape how the city plans.
- A single system is a single point of failure. Building a second, independent network for fire protection remains one of the city's best examples of redundancy, and a lesson that cost a great deal to learn.
- Fire follows earthquakes. Gas and water systems matter as much as buildings, which is why the city's preparedness advice tells residents to know where their gas main is. See drop, cover, hold on and the gas main.
- Infrastructure keeps its history. The pumps, tanks and cisterns of the AWSS date from 1909 to 1913 and are still part of the city's emergency capacity, quietly doing a job most residents never think about.
For the fire department's role today, see San Francisco Fire Department, and for the water agency, San Francisco Public Utilities Commission. For household preparation, Preparing for an earthquake in San Francisco is the place to start.