Blog

1906 and 1989: two earthquakes compared

The 7.9 quake of 1906 and the 6.9 Loma Prieta quake of 1989 compared by timing, damage, fire and the shifting death toll, with what each changed in the city.

San Franciscans keep two earthquakes in their heads. One is the great shock of April 18, 1906, known mostly through photographs of a burned downtown and tents in Golden Gate Park. The other is the Loma Prieta quake of October 17, 1989, which plenty of living residents remember firsthand: the Bay Bridge span that fell, the fire in the Marina, the World Series game that never started. Eighty-three years and a full point of magnitude separate them, and for three decades people have set them side by side, because each says something different about how a city breaks and how it comes back.

Two moments, one fault system

The 1906 earthquake struck at 5:12 a.m. on Wednesday, April 18. The U.S. Geological Survey's moment-magnitude estimate is 7.9, though published estimates range from about 7.7 to 8.3. The rupture ran north of San Francisco as well as south into the Santa Cruz Mountains, and the shaking was strong across the whole city.

The 1989 quake hit at 5:04 p.m. on Tuesday, October 17. It was magnitude 6.9, with its epicenter in the Santa Cruz Mountains, well south of the city. The USGS counted 63 deaths, 3,757 injuries and about $6 billion in property damage across Northern California.

The gap in magnitude is bigger than it looks. Magnitude is a logarithmic scale, and one full unit means roughly 32 times more energy released. A 7.9 earthquake is therefore on the order of 30 times as energetic as a 6.9, and the rupture behind it was much longer. That is one reason the earlier quake damaged the entire region, while the later one saved its worst for places with poor ground.

What the clock did

The hour decided what happened to people. At 5:12 in the morning most San Franciscans were asleep at home, in wooden and brick buildings that fell around them. At 5:04 in the evening, most were commuting, working or on their way to Candlestick Park for Game 3 of the World Series, which was about to begin when the shaking started. Fewer than half of the more than 62,000 fans had reached their seats. Lighter rush-hour traffic, many believe, kept the toll lower than it might have been. The game was postponed for ten days.

Side by side

April 18, 1906 October 17, 1989
Time 5:12 a.m. 5:04 p.m.
Magnitude 7.9 (estimates 7.7-8.3) 6.9
Main damage in the city Fire, which burned about four days Liquefaction in the Marina; fire there; bridge and freeway damage
Buildings destroyed About 25,000 on 490 blocks Seven collapsed in the Marina; 63 judged unsafe to live in
Deaths Early counts 375 to over 500; later estimates 700 to 3,000 or more 63 across Northern California
People left homeless Between 227,000 and 300,000 of about 410,000 Not comparable in scale
Cost More than $400 million in 1906 dollars About $6 billion across the region

Fire versus ground failure

The two quakes hurt the city in different ways. In 1906 the shaking itself did serious damage, but most of the destruction came from the fires that followed. Broken gas lines and overturned stoves started fires, and the city's water supply failed. Fire Chief Dennis T. Sullivan was gravely injured in the first moments and died later, and firefighters, who were not trained to use dynamite for firebreaks, sometimes started new fires with it. One blaze, the "Ham and Eggs" fire, began on the morning of the 18th at Hayes and Gough Streets after a woman lit a stove with a damaged chimney. It destroyed about 30 blocks, including City Hall. The fires burned for roughly four days and nights.

In 1989 the trouble came from the ground. The Marina District sits on fill, land created partly with rubble dumped into the bay after the 1906 earthquake, and in 1989 that fill liquefied. Four people died in the Marina, seven buildings collapsed and 63 damaged structures were judged unsafe. Many of the collapsed buildings were older apartment houses with garages on the ground floor, the pattern engineers call soft-story construction. A ruptured natural gas main at Beach and Divisadero caused a major fire. The nearby hydrant system failed, so the fire department recruited civilians to carry hoses from a distance, and the fireboat Phoenix pumped bay water to engines on shore. the 1906 fire and the water mains tells why the city built a separate firefighting water system after 1906, and Soft-story buildings and the Marina returns to the soft-story problem.

The infrastructure test

The 1989 quake put the twentieth century's freeways and bridges through an examination. A 76-by-50-foot section of the Bay Bridge's upper deck fell onto the deck below, and a driver died when her car plunged into the gap. The bridge reopened on November 18. The Cypress Street Viaduct in Oakland collapsed, and 41 of the quake's deaths were there. In San Francisco, the Embarcadero Freeway, a double-deck structure that had stood since 1968, was damaged and closed. It was demolished in 1991, and the waterfront it had cut off became a boulevard. The Central Freeway, also double-decked, was later rebuilt as a single-deck elevated road, completed in 2005. The Embarcadero Freeway, 1968 to 1991 and Crossing the Bay Bridge cover those stories.

In 1906 there was no such infrastructure to fail. The Golden Gate Bridge, the Bay Bridge and the freeways had not been built. The city moved by streetcar, horse-drawn wagon and ferry. What broke in the city's physical systems was water pipes, gas lines and masonry buildings.

The shifting death toll

The 1906 death toll is one of the most revised numbers in San Francisco history. Early counts ran from 375 to more than 500. Chinatown's deaths were largely unrecorded, and later estimates rose to 700 and then to 3,000 or more, a figure the city's Board of Supervisors officially adopted in 2005. Records of the poorest and most marginal residents were incomplete in 1906, and the revisions reflect decades of work by historians to count the missing.

In 1989 the count was sharper. The USGS lists 63 deaths, and the Cypress Street Viaduct in Oakland accounted for 41. In San Francisco, deaths occurred in the Marina and on Sixth Street, where five people died when a brick facade fell between Bluxome and Townsend Streets, and on the Bay Bridge.

The two days in order

April 18, 1906

  • 5:12 a.m.: the earthquake strikes; Fire Chief Dennis T. Sullivan is gravely injured.
  • Morning: fires start across the city from broken gas lines and stoves; the Ham and Eggs fire begins at Hayes and Gough Streets.
  • The same day and after: the water supply fails; dynamite is used to create firebreaks, sometimes starting new fires.
  • Four days and nights: the fires burn about 490 blocks and some 25,000 buildings.

October 17, 1989

  • 5:04 p.m.: the earthquake strikes as Game 3 of the World Series is about to begin at Candlestick Park.
  • Evening: a gas main ruptures at Beach and Divisadero in the Marina and a major fire starts; the fireboat Phoenix supplies bay water.
  • That night: the collapsed span of the Bay Bridge and the damage to the Embarcadero Freeway become the central images of the disaster.
  • November 18: the Bay Bridge reopens.

Remembering both

San Francisco marks 1906 more formally than 1989. Each year on April 18, people gather at dawn at Lotta's Fountain, at Market, Geary and Kearny Streets, at the minute of the quake, a tradition that survivors began and later generations have kept. The 1989 anniversary lives more in memory: many residents can say where they were at 5:04 p.m. on October 17. The city's historical record and its disaster-preparedness messages draw on both.

For a visitor or a newcomer, a few places make the comparison concrete.

  • The Marina, with its flat streets on fill, is the best place to see what liquefaction means. See Marina and The Marina: a district built on a world's fair, which explains that the district was built on fill for the 1915 exposition.
  • The Embarcadero, where the freeway once stood, now an open waterfront boulevard.
  • City Hall, rebuilt after the 1906 fire destroyed its predecessor and dedicated on December 28, 1915.
  • The cistern circles and hydrants of the firefighting water system built after 1906.

Questions people ask

Which earthquake was worse? By any measure of size and total damage, 1906. By the standards of a modern city with far more people and more expensive buildings, the 1989 quake cost more in dollars, because the economy it hit was much larger.

Could 1906 happen again? The city's own preparedness page states that San Francisco's history and geography make earthquakes a significant risk. It asks residents to plan for the possibility that cell service will be unavailable.

Was 1989 the Big One? It was a magnitude 6.9 earthquake on a segment well south of the city. It was a serious event that damaged the city, but the 1906 rupture was much longer.

What each earthquake changed

After 1906 the city rebuilt quickly, as The Panama-Pacific International Exposition, 1915 and City Hall rebuilt, 1915 describe. It also built a high-pressure water system for firefighting, begun in 1909 and finished in 1913.

After 1989 the lessons were structural. Retrofit programs for freeways and bridges followed, and the Embarcadero Freeway came down. The city and its engineers focused on liquefaction zones and soft-story buildings. The Marina became a symbol for both.

Both quakes remain part of how the city plans. The city's guidance, covered in drop, cover, hold on and the gas main, opens with the point that San Francisco's history and geography make earthquakes a significant risk. The Department of Emergency Management runs the AlertSF text system, described in AlertSF, WEA and the emergency radio stations, and the official preparedness guide is Preparing for an earthquake in San Francisco.

What the comparison teaches

Three lessons come out of the pairing.

  1. The magnitude is only part of the story. A smaller earthquake on bad ground can do more harm per block than a larger one on firm rock. The Marina in 1989 is the proof.
  2. Fire follows shaking. Gas lines and water mains matter as much as walls. In both quakes the failure of a gas or water system turned a shock into a fire.
  3. The numbers keep changing. The 1906 toll was revised for a century, a reminder that early counts after a disaster are provisional.

Anyone living in the city can put the comparison to use. Know where your gas main is, keep a plan that does not depend on cell service, and learn what the ground under your block is made of. Both earthquakes ended in the same place: a city that rebuilt, and rebuilt with some new knowledge.

Related city government

Related guides

Related neighborhoods

Latest on this topic