Blog

Chinese exclusion and San Francisco

The 1882 Chinese Exclusion Act, the dock detention that led to Angel Island, the 1906 records fire and the 1943 repeal, told through San Francisco's Chinatown.

For more than sixty years, a Chinese person who wanted to come into the United States had to get past San Francisco, and the law was written so that getting past would be as hard as possible. The Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882 was the first federal law to restrict immigration by race. San Francisco was its main port of entry, its enforcement played out on the city's docks and on an island in the bay, and its effects on the Chinese community shaped Chinatown for generations. Here is the story in order: the laws and ordinances, the detention, the repeal in 1943.

Before the act: a city that wrote its own rules

Chinese residents had been in San Francisco since the Gold Rush, and many of the people who built the first Chinese neighborhoods around Grant Avenue and Stockton Street arrived in 1849 and the years just after. The economic downturn of the 1870s brought unemployment and calls against low-wage Asian workers, and those calls helped drive restrictive immigration laws, as California State Parks puts it in its account of the Angel Island station.

The city had by then written local rules of its own. The planning department's historic context statement describes two. The 1870 Cubic Air Ordinance imposed fines and jail time on landlords and renters in rooming houses that did not give each person 500 cubic feet of air. It applied to the rooming houses found mostly in Chinatown, where Chinese immigrant laborers lived in crowded quarters largely because discriminatory housing practices kept them from renting or owning elsewhere. In the 1880s the city went after Chinese-owned laundries by selectively enforcing a rule that laundries be located in brick buildings, when most laundries at the time stood in wooden ones. The laundry owners took the case to the U.S. Supreme Court and won.

Those local measures matter because they show the pattern: a rule that looked neutral on paper, applied to one community.

May 6, 1882: the act

Congress passed, and President Chester Arthur signed, the Chinese Exclusion Act on May 6, 1882. It suspended the immigration of Chinese laborers for ten years. It was the first major federal law to restrict the immigration of a specific nationality, and the Library of Congress calls it the first federal law restricting an immigrant group by race.

The law did not bar every Chinese person from the country. It had exemptions, and many Chinese immigrants sought entry under them, according to the National Park Service. That turned immigration into a matter of proof. A person who claimed to be a merchant, a student, a teacher or the child of a U.S. citizen had to prove it to officials inclined to doubt it, and the proof, in the form of interviews and documents, was the center of the system.

San Francisco was where that proof was tested. It was the main port of entry for Chinese arrivals, and the inspectors, the lawyers, the interpreters and the detention facilities were all in or near the city.

Detention on the docks

Before there was an immigration station, there was detention in the city. Chinese arrivals were first held aboard ships in the bay. A judge ordered the Pacific Mail Steamship Company to hold arrivals aboard the City of Tokio, and the Angel Island Immigration Station Foundation dates that order to 1883. In 1898 the company moved detention to a second-floor loft at its dock, known as the detention shed. The Foundation describes the shed as about 100 by 50 feet, and a commissioner's report called it too small and unsanitary.

People in the shed were held while officials decided their cases. One of those detained at the Pacific Mail dock in 1904, the Foundation notes, was Sun Yat-sen.

The conditions in the shed and the sheer volume of cases were among the reasons the federal government built a dedicated station on an island in the bay. The station opened in 1910, and on January 23, 1910, officials moved 101 Chinese detainees and one South Asian detainee from the Pacific Mail dock to Angel Island. The island's story is told in The Angel Island Immigration Station, 1910 to 1940.

The act renewed and widened

When the ten years were nearly up, Congress did not let the law lapse. In 1892 it passed the Geary Act, named for a California senator, which extended exclusion another decade and required Chinese residents already in the country to carry certificates of residence. The Supreme Court later invalidated its imprisonment and forced-labor provisions in Wong Wing v. United States in 1896. In 1902 exclusion was renewed again, this time with no terminal date, which made it effectively permanent until repeal.

For a community like Chinatown's, the result was a steady squeeze. It could not grow through new arrivals, and families stayed apart because of the difficulty of bringing wives and children across the Pacific. The people who did arrive faced detention and interrogation.

April 18, 1906: records lost, claims made

The earthquake and fire of 1906 destroyed city records, including the birth and citizenship records an official might have used to check a person's claim. The California Historical Society's account of the quake, and later historians, say that the loss let many Chinese residents of California claim citizenship for themselves and for children born in China, who are often called "paper sons" and "paper daughters." The system of paper identities had its own risks: an arriving child had to memorize a detailed family history and be ready to be questioned about it, because inspectors compared the stories of different family members. the 1906 earthquake and fire describes the disaster itself.

The fire destroyed Chinatown too, and it was rebuilt afterward on the same site.

1910 to 1940: Angel Island

On January 21, 1910, the Angel Island Immigration Station opened as the main West Coast port of entry for Asian immigrants. It was designed to process Chinese immigrants. California State Parks says that over the thirty years the station operated, it was the entry point for most of the approximately 175,000 Chinese immigrants who came to the United States, and that more than 80 countries were represented among the people processed. Most detainees were held anywhere from a couple of days to a couple of months, though a few stayed up to two years.

The poems carved into the barracks walls are the station's best-known record of how it felt. A fire destroyed the administration building in August 1940, and on November 5, 1940, the last group of about 200 immigrants, about 150 of them Chinese, moved to temporary quarters in San Francisco.

1943: repeal

On December 17, 1943, Congress passed the Magnuson Act, which repealed the Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882 and the laws that had followed it. The timing was wartime politics: China was a key ally in the war against Japan, and the exclusion laws were an irritant in the relationship. The repeal allowed 105 Chinese immigrants to enter each year (a few sources give 100), so the change was largely symbolic in numbers, even though it ended a law that had defined Chinese immigration for sixty-one years.

How an arrival was processed

The National Park Service describes the path a person took at the Angel Island station, and it shows how the exemptions in the law became a daily test.

  1. Arrival and separation. Officials separated detainees by race and sex. Children under 12 could stay with their mothers.
  2. A medical exam. Each detainee received one.
  3. Waiting for a hearing. Immigrants with questionable documents were held for examination. Hearings could last days, months or several years.
  4. The questioning. Applicants claiming an exemption, such as merchant status or citizenship through a parent, were questioned about their families and villages. Officials then compared the answers with those of relatives and witnesses already in the United States.
  5. A decision. Those admitted went into the city, and those who were not were sent back.

The park service's own estimate is that the station processed up to one million immigrants between 1910 and 1940, including about 250,000 Chinese; California State Parks, counting those who came to the United States as immigrants over the same thirty years, puts the Chinese figure at approximately 175,000. The two numbers measure different things, one the people processed through the station (some more than once, some turned back) and the other the immigrants who entered, and the range is a reminder that these totals are estimates.

The law in a timeline

Date Event
1849 and after Chinese arrivals during the Gold Rush settle around Grant Avenue and Stockton Street
1870 The city's Cubic Air Ordinance penalizes crowded rooming houses, mostly in Chinatown
1870s Economic downturn; calls against low-wage Asian workers
1880s Selective enforcement of a brick-building rule on Chinese-owned laundries; the owners win in the Supreme Court
May 6, 1882 Chinese Exclusion Act suspends Chinese labor immigration for ten years
1892 Geary Act extends exclusion and requires certificates of residence
1896 Wong Wing v. United States strikes the act's imprisonment and forced-labor provisions
1898 Detention moves to a shed at the Pacific Mail dock
1902 Exclusion renewed with no end date
April 18, 1906 Earthquake and fire destroy records; "paper" identities become common
January 21, 1910 Angel Island Immigration Station opens
August 12, 1940 Fire destroys the administration building
December 17, 1943 Magnuson Act repeals exclusion

What the numbers do and do not say

A reader meeting these dates and figures for the first time may find the contrast striking. The law aimed at a small share of the population, but its reach was long: sixty-one years from the 1882 act to the 1943 repeal. In San Francisco the practical effect landed at three places, the Pacific Mail dock, the island and Chinatown itself, where families split by the law tried to rebuild.

There was a legal side as well. The Supreme Court's decision on the laundry rule, which grew out of San Francisco's enforcement against Chinese-owned laundries, and its 1896 ruling on the penalties in the Geary Act are part of the American legal record.

What the history left in the city

The act is part of San Francisco's built environment as well as its legal history. The Angel Island station is a National Historic Landmark, and its barracks have been restored with recreated bunk rooms. Chinatown, called the oldest Chinatown in North America, remains a living neighborhood. Chinatown describes it today, A walk up Grant Avenue through Chinatown walks its main street, and Lunar New Year foods and the parade describes the largest public celebration it hosts. A more recent chapter of the same story, the 1942 removal of Japanese Americans, is covered in Executive Order 9066 and Japantown.

For the primary documents, the Library of Congress's immigration pages and the National Park Service's pages on the Angel Island Immigration Station, at nps.gov, give the legal text and the record of the station.

Related city government

Related guides

Related neighborhoods

Latest on this topic