Blog
Hallidie and the first cable car, 1873
Andrew Hallidie tested the first cable car at 4 a.m. on August 2, 1873. How the system spread, survived 1906 and was saved from removal in 1947.
It ran at four o'clock in the morning, a day later than the contract allowed, and nobody standing in the dark on Clay Street was sure it would work. The date was August 2, 1873, and the man who had staked his reputation on the machine was Andrew Smith Hallidie, a wire-rope manufacturer who had watched horses die on San Francisco's hills. By the end of that decade cable cars were crossing the city's steepest streets. By the middle of the twentieth century the city's mayor wanted them gone, and the voters stopped him. The three lines that run today are what is left of one of the most closely fought transit decisions in American history.
The idea: a horse on a wet street
The SFMTA's account of cable car history traces the idea to 1869. Hallidie, who had been born in Britain, was the son of an inventor who held a British patent for wire rope. He had come to the United States in 1852 during the Gold Rush, and he used cable to haul ore from mines and to build suspension bridges. In 1869, the story goes, he watched horses straining to pull a horsecar up Jackson Street on wet cobblestones, and he decided the hills needed a better machine.
The principle was a continuous steel cable running in a slot beneath the street, driven by a steam engine in a central powerhouse. A car rides on the street and, by means of a mechanism called a grip that reaches down through the slot, holds on to the moving cable to go uphill and lets go to stop. Hallidie's background in wire rope and bridges gave him the materials, and the city's hills gave him the reason.
Building the Clay Street line
Hallidie and his partners formed the Clay Street Hill Railroad, and construction began in May 1873. The contract with the city required that the line be operating by August 1. It was not ready, and the first test took place a day late, at 4 a.m. on August 2, 1873. Public service began on September 1, 1873.
The test worked, and the Clay Street line proved that a cable could pull a car up a steep grade reliably enough to carry paying passengers.
Eight companies and 53 miles
For four years the Clay Street Hill Railroad was the only cable car company in the city. Then the idea spread. The Sutter Street Railroad, a former horsecar company, began cable service in 1877. Others followed in the next dozen years:
| Company | Cable service began |
|---|---|
| Clay Street Hill Railroad | 1873 |
| Sutter Street Railroad | 1877 |
| California Street | 1878 |
| Geary Street, Park & Ocean | 1880 |
| Presidio & Ferries | 1882 |
| Market Street | 1883 |
| Ferries & Cliff House | 1888 |
| Omnibus | 1889 |
Together the companies laid 53 miles of track. The cable car turned the city's hills from barriers into neighborhoods. The cars made life on the steepest hills practical, and Nob Hill and Russian Hill are still organized around the routes. Nob Hill, its hotels and mansions tells the Nob Hill story, and Russian Hill's stairways and the Powell-Hyde line the Russian Hill one.
The challenge from electricity
The cable car was not the last word in street transit. In 1888 Frank Sprague perfected the electric streetcar, and the SFMTA notes that it had by then become the preferred transit vehicle. It cost about half as much to build and maintain, reached more areas and was faster. A cable system required a powerhouse, a slot, a heavy cable and the labor to run them. An electric line required wire overhead and a track. The balance moved steadily toward electricity.
The cable car kept one advantage the electric streetcar lacked: it handled steep hills better. That is why some cable lines survived while others were abandoned and replaced.
April 18, 1906
The earthquake and fire of April 18, 1906 devastated the city, and the cable system took its share of the damage. Cable Car 155 was hit by falling debris at the Washington and Mason cable car house, which was rebuilt afterward. Some cable lines were rebuilt after the fire, because cable cars still handled the steep hills better. Others were converted to electricity or abandoned. The story of the disaster is told in the 1906 earthquake and fire.
The 1940s: a plan to scrap them
The system shrank steadily. The Fillmore line closed in 1941, the Sacramento line in 1942 and the Castro line in 1944. By 1947 Mayor Roger Lapham was saying that the city should get rid of all cable car lines as soon as possible. Bus operating costs were lower, and he saw no reason to keep a nineteenth-century technology.
The mayor's proposal set off the most successful public campaign in the system's history. Friedel Klussmann founded the Citizens' Committee to Save the Cable Cars. Its argument was that the cars were worth far more to the city than they cost to operate. The committee put Measure 10 on the November ballot, and it passed in what the SFMTA describes as a landslide victory. The cable car lines that remained were secure.
Muni's own history lists a further cutback in 1957, when the cable car system was reduced to three lines. Those three, California Street, Powell-Hyde and Powell-Mason, are the ones that run today. The SFMTA notes that the cable car system's continued operation, along with a minimum level of service, is now locked into the City Charter.
What runs today
The SFMTA describes two kinds of car:
- California Street cars: twelve larger, maroon, double-ended cars that turn around with a simple switch at the end of the line.
- Powell Street cars: smaller cars that run from one end only and need turntables at each terminal. Twenty-eight are kept on the roster at any one time.
The system is one of two National Historic Streetcar Landmarks in operation; the other is New Orleans's St. Charles line. riding the cable cars explains how to ride, and the cable car system: three lines and a museum describes how the three lines work as a system. The rebuilding of the whole system took place from 1982 to 1984, according to the Cable Car Museum.
Cable against electric: the argument in a table
The decades-long debate over the cable car was never about romance. It was an engineering and cost argument, and the SFMTA's account lets the two sides sit next to each other.
| Cable car | Electric streetcar or bus | |
|---|---|---|
| Machinery | Powerhouse, cable and a slot under the street | Overhead wire or a motor and fuel |
| Cost to build and maintain | Higher; the electric car cost about half as much | Lower |
| Reach | Fixed to routes with a cable | Reached more areas |
| Speed | Slower | Faster |
| Steep hills | Handles them better | Weaker on the steepest grades |
| Operating cost by 1947 | Higher, in the mayor's view | Bus costs were lower |
The table explains both the decline and the survival. Every line in the cost columns pointed toward replacement. The single entry for hills, together with the sentiment of the people who rode the cars, pointed the other way. The voters in 1947 chose to pay the extra cost.
A timeline
- 1869: Hallidie conceives the idea after seeing horses struggle on Jackson Street.
- May 1873: Construction of the Clay Street Hill Railroad begins.
- August 2, 1873: First test at 4 a.m.
- September 1, 1873: Public service begins.
- 1877 to 1889: Seven more companies begin cable service, and the network reaches 53 miles of track.
- 1888: The electric streetcar is perfected.
- April 18, 1906: Earthquake and fire damage the system.
- 1941, 1942, 1944: The Fillmore, Sacramento and Castro lines close.
- 1947: Mayor Lapham proposes scrapping the system; voters pass Measure 10 on the November ballot.
- 1957: The system is cut back to three lines.
- 1982 to 1984: The system is rebuilt.
What to notice on a ride
A rider sees the system's design in a few places. The cars on the Powell lines are smaller and run from one end only, so at each terminal the crew pushes the car onto a turntable and spins it around by hand, a spectacle that draws a crowd. The California Street cars are larger and double-ended, so they switch directions without a turntable. The cable itself is invisible, running in a slot between the rails, but the slot is visible in the street, and the sound of the cable carries to the sidewalk. At the Nob Hill powerhouse, the Cable Car Museum lets visitors look down on the machinery that moves the cables. How to ride Muni explains how the cable cars fit into Muni, and riding the cable cars covers boarding and where the stops are.
Questions people ask
Are the cable cars part of Muni? Yes. They are operated by the San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency as part of Muni, and are shown on the agency's route list as the California, Powell-Hyde and Powell-Mason lines.
Is the system original? The technology dates to 1873, and the three lines follow routes of the old companies. The system was rebuilt from 1982 to 1984, and its cars and equipment have been maintained and restored over the decades, so what runs today is a working restoration of the original idea.
Why are there only three lines? The others closed in stages through the first half of the twentieth century, when electric streetcars and buses cost less to run. The three that remain were protected by the 1947 vote and are now secured in the City Charter.
Can I ride for the history alone? The cars carry commuters and visitors alike, and the cars are a working part of the city's transit network.
Seeing the machinery
The best place to see how the system works is the Cable Car Museum, which occupies the Washington-Mason powerhouse and carbarn on Nob Hill at 1201 Mason Street. Admission is free. The museum houses historic cable cars, photographs and mechanical displays, and the powerhouse still turns the sheaves that move the cables under the streets. The museum's own site gives its current days and hours, and states that it is closed on Mondays. The Cable Car Museum and the cable powerhouse covers the visit in detail.
Another way to see the system is to follow the cars on foot. The Powell-Hyde line climbs Nob Hill and Russian Hill toward Lombard Street and Aquatic Park, and the California Street line runs from the Financial District up through Chinatown and over Nob Hill. Chinatown sits along the California Street route.
Reading the 1873 date
The sequence of dates is short. Construction began in May 1873. The contract required operation by August 1, and the first test ran a day late, at 4 a.m. on August 2. Public service began a month later, on September 1. The history of the cable car system opens, in other words, with a deadline missed by a day, a test before dawn and a successful opening within weeks.
The same story applies to the system's survival. Hallidie's design lasted not because it was the cheapest or the fastest, but because it solved a problem no other vehicle of its time could solve, and because, when a mayor decided it should go, enough voters disagreed. The SFMTA's cable car history is at sfmta.com, and the transit agency's own page lists the three lines and their current schedules.