Blog
Soft-story buildings and the Marina
How the 1989 collapse of a Marina apartment building led to the city's mandatory soft-story retrofit program, who it covers and the arguments over its cost.
Everybody who lived through October 1989 remembers the picture: a four-story apartment building at the corner of Beach and Divisadero in the Marina, its ground floor flattened, the upper floors canted out over the street, a burned block smoking behind it. The U.S. Geological Survey keeps a photograph of that corner in its collection. The earthquake was centered about 60 miles south-southeast of San Francisco, near Loma Prieta peak in the Santa Cruz Mountains, and struck at 5:04 p.m. on October 17, 1989, with a moment magnitude of 6.9. It was nowhere near the city, and it still did serious damage here. The reason is partly the ground and partly the buildings, and the buildings are the part the city has been able to change.
The ground and the buildings
The Marina sits on filled land, much of it made for the 1915 Panama-Pacific International Exposition from bay mud, sand and rubble (The Marina: a district built on a world's fair). Shaking can turn saturated fill into something that behaves like a liquid, a process called liquefaction, and in 1989 the filled ground of the Marina shifted and lost strength while neighboring areas on firmer ground did far better. The USGS photograph of the Marina after the earthquake shows the combined result: collapsed buildings, fire and damaged streets.
Many of the buildings that failed shared a design. They were wood-frame apartment houses, three or four stories tall, built in the decades before modern seismic codes, with a wide opening on the ground floor for garages or storefronts. The opening leaves few walls at street level to resist sideways shaking, while the stories above are full of walls. Engineers call the weak level a soft story, or a weak story. When the earth moves sideways, the upper floors are heavy and stiff and the ground floor is light and open, so the ground floor can fold, dropping the building into the space below. The Marina has plenty of this type, but so do the Mission, the Richmond, the Sunset and the Tenderloin, since the form was a cheap way to put housing over parking from the early twentieth century through the 1970s.
The 2013 ordinance
It took more than two decades for the city to act citywide. The city commissioned a large study, the Community Action Plan for Seismic Safety, known by its initials CAPSS, which estimated that at least 2,800 buildings in San Francisco have a soft-story condition, housing roughly 58,000 people and some 2,000 businesses. The study's modeling suggested that after a magnitude 7.2 earthquake on the San Andreas fault, a large share of these buildings, between 43 and 85 percent, could be tagged unsafe, and about a quarter of those could collapse.
In April 2013 the Board of Supervisors passed, and Mayor Ed Lee signed, the Mandatory Soft Story Retrofit Program, signed on the 107th anniversary of the 1906 earthquake. The Department of Building Inspection administers it (Department of Building Inspection and the Permit Center). The ordinance's main rules:
- Which buildings. Wood-frame buildings with three or more stories, or two stories over a basement or underfloor area, containing five or more dwelling units, for which the original building permit application was filed before January 1, 1978.
- Notification. The city sent notices to the owners of every building meeting those criteria beginning September 15, 2013.
- Screening and evaluation. An owner has to have the building evaluated, by a licensed engineer or architect, to confirm whether it has a soft or weak story.
- The work. The ordinance requires retrofitting of the weak or "target" story only, not of the whole building. In practice that means adding steel frames, braced walls or shear panels at ground level so that the floor can resist sideways movement. The retrofit has to meet a standard set by the city's administrative bulletin.
- Phased deadlines. The program sorted buildings into four tiers by risk, with the highest-risk tier, which included buildings with schools, daycares and senior centers, going first, beginning in 2015, and the others over the following years. DBI's program page and its database show each building's tier and status.
It is one of the largest seismic-retrofit mandates for housing in the United States, and it rests on a belief that a bounded fix for one type of building does more good than a general call for safer housing. A strengthened ground floor leaves apartments in place, and a retrofitted building is less likely to collapse in a quake. The department's own measure of success is whether buildings stay standing.
What an owner and a tenant should know
Start with the Department of Building Inspection's soft-story page and its building database. A resident can look up a building by address to see whether it was on the notification list, what tier it fell in and whether the retrofit permit was filed, completed or still open. An owner who received a notice needs to hire an engineer, apply for permits through the city's permit system and complete the work by the deadline for the tier.
Cost is the center of the argument. Retrofits vary with the size and layout of the building and are substantial for any owner. The Rent Ordinance includes provisions that govern whether and how an owner can pass part of the cost of a capital improvement to tenants, and those rules are set by the Rent Board, not by the soft-story program (Rent Board and housing agencies, Renters' rights and rent control in San Francisco). The Rent Board counsels by phone at 415-252-4600 and its pages give the current rules; tenants who want to know their situation should ask there.
Tenants also live with the construction. Retrofit work happens at ground level, often in the garage or storefront area, and can take weeks. Owners have to follow the city's rules for tenant notification and for working in occupied buildings, and the permit record on DBI's site shows when work was approved and finished.
The arguments
The program has drawn support and criticism, and a fair account includes both.
Supporters argue that the risk is large and concentrated. The CAPSS findings put thousands of buildings at risk of significant damage, and the 1989 collapse showed what the failure looks like. Retrofits protect residents' lives, preserve housing that would otherwise be lost after a quake and reduce the strain on emergency services in the first hours. They note that the work is limited to the weak story and that the program phased its deadlines so the riskiest buildings went first.
Critics, including some small-property owners, point to cost. A retrofit is a large expense for an owner of an older building with a few units, especially if rents are regulated and the owner's ability to recover the cost is limited. They also point to a demanding evaluation process and to the fact that some owners missed deadlines. Tenant advocates have raised the opposite worry: that costs passed through to tenants raise rents, and that construction can disrupt residents.
The middle position is that the city should keep the mandate and pair it with financing help, clear rules on pass-throughs and good tenant protections. In San Francisco, the debate about how to pay has run alongside the debate about the housing supply, since every unit lost in a quake is a unit that has to be rebuilt in a city that already faces high housing costs.
How to check a building, step by step
Say a renter in a four-story, twelve-unit building above a ground-floor garage wants to know whether it is covered. The path is short.
- Compare the building to the criteria. Wood frame, three or more stories (or two over a basement or garage level), five or more units, and a permit applied for before January 1, 1978. A building with a garage under apartments and a 1920s or 1960s construction date is a candidate.
- Look the address up in DBI's soft-story database. The Department of Building Inspection's program page links to the lookup, which lists the building's tier and where it stands: screening, evaluation, permit filed, work done.
- Check the permit record. The permit tracking system shows when the retrofit permit was applied for, issued and finalized. A final inspection sign-off marks the end of the work.
- Ask the property manager or owner what was done, and when. Owners have the engineer's report and the plans.
- Call 311 or DBI at 628-652-3200 if the building appears to be on the list but shows no activity. Complaints about building conditions go to DBI.
For a tenant, finding the work complete is reassuring but not a guarantee; a retrofit raises the odds that a building stays upright in a strong quake, and it does not make a building immune to damage. The other precautions, supplies, alerts and a plan for the first hours, still apply.
Other buildings and other risks
Soft-story wood-frame apartments are only one category. Older unreinforced masonry buildings, concrete buildings from the mid-twentieth century and tall steel buildings with a certain type of connection each have their own risks, and the city's seismic-safety efforts address them separately. DBI also administers earthquake-related programs for owners of other building types, and the Planning Department includes seismic safety in its plans (San Francisco Planning).
For an individual, the soft-story story points to practical steps. Find out whether your building has a ground-floor opening and, if it is covered, whether the retrofit is complete. Learn where your gas shutoff is. Sign up for AlertSF by texting your ZIP code to 888-777. If you live in a filled-land neighborhood, know that the ground matters as well as the building (Preparing for an earthquake in San Francisco, Neighborhood disaster training and Map Your Block).
The Marina today
The Marina was repaired and rebuilt after 1989, and the city now knows a good deal more about where its soft ground is. The program that grew out of the Marina's worst afternoon covers the whole city, and its results are written into the permit records of thousands of buildings. Walk past the corner of Beach and Divisadero today and you pass new construction and renovated buildings, and the strengthened ground floors of the kind of building that failed there (Marina).