Blog

The Marina: a district built on a world's fair

How the 1915 Panama-Pacific Exposition left the Marina its Palace of Fine Arts and its ground, and why the filled land liquefied in the 1989 earthquake.

San Francisco was still sweeping up after the 1906 fire when it decided to throw the world a party. Nine years on, the Panama-Pacific International Exposition of 1915 marked the opening of the Panama Canal and, not incidentally, announced that the city was back. It needed a place big enough for palaces, courts and a midway, and the city picked its northern waterfront, a stretch of tidal flats, dunes and marsh, and buried it under fill. When the fair closed on December 4, 1915, nearly everything built for it came down. What stayed was the ground, a few relics and the plan for a neighborhood.

The fair and its attendance

The Exposition drew more than 18 million visits over 1915, with a record 450,000 people through the gates on closing day, according to the National Park Service. It took in more than $27 million against costs above $25 million, for a profit of roughly $1.3 million. For a city that had been rubble nine years before, the arithmetic counted for less than the point it made: San Francisco could host an international fair.

The fair left useful things behind. The Stockton Street Tunnel, the Van Ness Avenue median and parts of the Muni system were built or developed to get people there. Muni grew to nine lines for the Exposition, and the Stockton Street Tunnel opened to streetcars in December 1914, in time for the first visitors (The opening of Muni, December 28, 1912). The Legion of Honor museum in the Richmond replicates the fair's French pavilion, built with money from Alma and Adolph Spreckels, and the Bill Graham Civic Auditorium in Civic Center dates from the same years.

What the fair left on the waterfront

The famous survivor is the Palace of Fine Arts, the work of the architect Bernard Maybeck. It was the one building preservationists rescued once the fair shut, and by the 1960s the original plaster and wood had rotted so badly that the city rebuilt it. The rotunda and colonnade now stand beside a lagoon, and the Palace is the only exposition structure still on its original site. The Exploratorium lived in it until 2013, when the museum moved to the waterfront.

Other leftovers are easier to miss. The Marina Green, that long strip of lawn along the bay, began as part of the fair's landscape. The yacht harbor, home to hundreds of boats, sits on the old passenger and freight slips of the fair's waterfront. The streets themselves, laid out when the site was graded and subdivided, record the plan for the first houses. After the Exposition closed, crews re-graded the site, developers knocked down almost every building and houses filled in the district through the 1920s.

Ground made of bay mud and rubble

What the neighborhood stands on matters as much as what the fair put up. Much of the Marina is former landfill, much of it dredged bay mud and sand with some rubble from the 1906 earthquake mixed in. Land made that way settles unevenly and behaves in a quake nothing like bedrock. Saturated sand and silt can lose strength under hard shaking and flow like a liquid, which engineers call liquefaction.

The 1989 Loma Prieta earthquake, a magnitude 6.9 event that struck at 5:04 p.m. on October 17, put it on display. The Marina suffered severe liquefaction and a small firestorm. With the water mains broken, firefighters pumped water straight from the bay to fight the flames, something they could do only because the neighborhood sits on the water. The USGS image series on the quake includes photographs of the district's damaged buildings, and the neighborhood was rebuilt fast (The 1989 Loma Prieta earthquake).

That is why the Marina so often comes up first in talk about seismic risk in the city's housing. Many older buildings there put living space over a ground-floor garage, which leaves the lowest floor weaker than the ones above, and the city has a program for retrofitting such "soft-story" buildings (Soft-story buildings and the Marina). Permit questions on a retrofit go to the Department of Building Inspection (Department of Building Inspection and the Permit Center), and the city's earthquake guidance spells out what to do before and during a quake (Preparing for an earthquake in San Francisco).

Why filled land shakes differently

The physics explains which parts of the city carry the risk. Bedrock carries an earthquake's energy efficiently but stays solid. Loose, water-saturated sediment amplifies the shaking and can lose its strength when the pore water pressure rises. A building on such ground can tilt or sink even when its frame is sound, and underground pipes break where the soil moves. The Marina's fill held dredged bay mud and sand, exactly the stuff that behaves that way.

Broken water mains are why the firefighters of 1989 had to turn to the bay. The neighborhood built beside the water was also the one whose water system failed first. The city's guidance tells residents to drop, cover and hold on, to know where the gas main is and to call PG&E at 1-800-743-5000 if unsure, and to expect that cell service may be out (Preparing for an earthquake in San Francisco).

Living on the fill, today

For people who live in the Marina the practical tools are preparation and communication. The city's AlertSF system sends emergency text alerts to anyone who texts a ZIP code to 888-777, and the Department of Emergency Management runs it along with the ReadySF program (Signing up for AlertSF and other emergency alerts, Department of Emergency Management). The bayfront falls inside the city's tsunami guidance too, which says that strong shaking of twenty seconds or more, a loud roar from the ocean or a sudden retreat of the sea means leaving at once for higher ground. Whether a particular address sits in a mapped zone is a question for the city's tsunami page, not for guesswork.

Property owners face a different set of questions. A soft-story retrofit is a construction project that needs a permit, and the Department of Building Inspection reviews it (Department of Building Inspection and the Permit Center). Buyers and tenants who want a building's history can look up its permit record on the city's permit portal. None of this is peculiar to the Marina, but the Marina is where the stakes showed in 1989.

The neighborhood on the map

The Marina runs from Van Ness Avenue and Fort Mason on the east to Lyon Street and the Presidio on the west, with Cow Hollow and Lombard Street on the south. Its northern half lies along the bay shoreline. Chestnut Street, from Fillmore to Lyon, is the commercial strip, a long run of shops, cafes and restaurants. Lombard Street, on the south edge, was widened after the Golden Gate Bridge opened in 1937 and became a corridor of roadside motels, carrying US 101 traffic toward the bridge (Marina).

The 30 Stockton and the 30X Marina Express serve the district, and the 22 Fillmore and 45 Union/Stockton run along its southern edge. With the Presidio next door, the walk from the Marina Green to the Golden Gate Bridge along Crissy Field is among the best-known shoreline walks in the city (Crissy Field and the Presidio shoreline). South of it, Cow Hollow has its own commercial street on Union Street (Cow Hollow).

A walk from the Palace to the harbor

A short walk lays out the history in order.

  1. Begin at the Palace of Fine Arts. The rotunda, lagoon and colonnade are what remains of the fair's most celebrated structure, and the rebuilt version stands where the first one did.
  2. Head north along the shoreline to the Marina Green. The lawn runs along the bay and the harbor opens to the west. This was the fair's waterfront, and now it belongs to kites, joggers and sailors.
  3. Follow the harbor and Marina Boulevard east toward Fort Mason, and look inland. The streets run in a regular grid across level ground that was once marsh.
  4. Cut back along Chestnut Street. The shops sit in two- and three-story buildings with housing above, the pattern of the 1920s build-out.

The grid and the flatness are the evidence. A district laid out after the fair is regular in a city of hills, and the regularity says somebody graded it first. The same flat ground that makes the neighborhood so walkable is the ground that shook in 1989, so everything about the Marina, from the Palace to the garages, goes back to a decision made in 1915 to build a fair on the bay.

The Presidio next door

At its western edge the Marina meets the Presidio, which has its own chapter from the same era. The Army post had been a military base since the 1840s, and Crissy Field was a pioneering military aviation field from 1920 to 1932. Crissy Field is now a restored tidal marsh and shoreline park, and the Presidio itself joined the national park system in 1994 (The Presidio, from army post to national park site). The Marina Green, the harbor and the Crissy Field promenade make one continuous stretch of bayfront, so a walk that starts at the Palace of Fine Arts can end at the foot of the Golden Gate Bridge without leaving the water.

What it means for residents and visitors

For residents the fair's lasting effect is practical. Marina property owners wrestle with geotechnical questions that owners on rock hills never meet, and the state and city map liquefaction zones. For visitors the effect is scenic. The Palace, the harbor and the views of the Golden Gate Bridge and Alcatraz from the Marina Green are all here because a fair needed a waterfront and a city needed to prove it had recovered. The neighborhood is, in the plainest sense, what the fair did next.

Related city government

Related guides

Related neighborhoods

Latest on this topic