Blog

Waterfront resilience and sea-level rise

What the Port's Waterfront Resilience Program and the Army Corps flood study propose for San Francisco's bayfront, their cost and the debate.

The postcard views are the most exposed ones. The Ferry Building, the Embarcadero promenade, Oracle Park, Mission Bay and the old industrial blocks of Dogpatch all stand at the edge of San Francisco Bay, much of it on land that used to be shallow water or tidal flat. The Port of San Francisco, which manages the waterfront, now describes the shoreline as facing two threats at once: flooding from a rising bay, and an earthquake that could shake apart ground and structures already known to be weak. Its answer is the Waterfront Resilience Program, and the biggest piece of that is a plan worked out with the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers. Here the problem is widely accepted. The fight is over the price, the order of work and who pays.

What the program is

The Waterfront Resilience Program is the Port's umbrella effort to make the waterfront, and the regional and citywide assets that depend on it, resilient to hazards while also opening the shoreline up to the public. The Port says coastal flooding threatens buildings, small businesses, jobs and services, including BART and Muni lines that run close to the water, and that earthquake risk is urgent today, not a problem for the next century.

The Port is a city department with its own commission, and its waterfront runs along the eastern edge of the city, from Fisherman's Wharf south into the Bayview. It has done waterfront work for decades. What is new is the scale of the sea-level planning, which treats a long stretch of shoreline as one system rather than a string of separate piers (Port of San Francisco).

The numbers that frame the problem

The program starts from a projection: the Port cites 3 to 7 feet of sea-level rise expected by 2100, and says the shoreline must be adapted to meet it. Three to seven feet is a wide range because it hangs on how much ice melts and how fast, which no one can forecast with precision. Many Bay Area planning documents use the same range, which lets the Port, the county and regional agencies plan to a common scale.

What makes San Francisco vulnerable is physical. The Embarcadero seawall is more than a century old, and the land behind much of it is fill laid over bay mud. A strong earthquake can liquefy that kind of ground. The 1989 Loma Prieta earthquake made the point in the Marina District, where filled land failed while neighboring blocks on bedrock came through with little damage (The 1989 Loma Prieta earthquake, The Marina: a district built on a world's fair). The Embarcadero Freeway, which ran along this same waterfront, came down after that quake (The Embarcadero Freeway, 1968 to 1991). Voters in 2018 approved a $425 million bond for Embarcadero seawall earthquake safety work, which is why the seawall keeps turning up in Port plans.

The Army Corps flood study

The biggest piece of the program is the San Francisco Waterfront Flood Study, a partnership between the Port and the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers that ran close to eight years. The partners have finalized the study and produced a Recommended Plan, building on a Draft Plan released for public review in 2024. The study area covers about 7.5 miles of bayfront shoreline.

The Port's published figures show the scale:

  • The Recommended Plan carries a cost estimate of about $14.7 billion in 2026 dollars. That is $14.6 billion for design and construction plus about $100 million for real estate. The 2024 Draft Plan was estimated at $13.5 billion in 2024 dollars.
  • The Corps characterizes the estimate as a conditionally certified Class 3 cost estimate at about 20 percent design maturity. In plain terms, the number is a planning estimate built on early design work, and it will move as engineers draw actual solutions.
  • If Congress authorizes the project, the federal government could pay up to 65 percent of the cost, with the local sponsor responsible for the rest.
  • The Corps will not take the project to Congress for funding without actual designs for at least 35 percent of the plan. Pre-construction engineering and design is slated for roughly 2026 to 2030, and the work would be built in phases, not as one construction project.

Other estimates have circulated. A 2024 news report put the cost of implementing the study's measures at more than $17 billion over three decades. The gaps come from dollar year, scope and what gets counted as part of the program.

What would be built

It is not one wall. It is a set of measures chosen for particular reaches of shoreline, from raised and strengthened edges to shoreline features that let water spread safely. The Port's named near-term projects show the range:

  • Living Seawall Pilot. An experiment in building the face of a seawall with textures and pockets that let marine life attach, so that hard infrastructure also works as habitat.
  • Embarcadero Resilience. Work on the seawall and the promenade along the central waterfront, where flooding and earthquake risks overlap.
  • Mission Creek and Mission Bay Resilience. Measures for the creek mouth and the filled land of Mission Bay, home to Chase Center and UCSF's Mission Bay campus (Mission Bay, Mission Bay, from rail yards to Chase Center).
  • Islais Creek and Bayview Resilience. Work on the southeast waterfront, where low-lying neighborhoods and industrial land meet the water (Bayview-Hunters Point).

South Beach, the stretch near Oracle Park, is among the places where water and fill sit closest to the surface, and the ballpark's waterfront edge is part of the public experience (South Beach and Rincon Hill, Oracle Park and McCovey Cove).

The debate, in neutral terms

Nobody at City Hall disputes that sea level is rising. The disagreements are about choices, and they run along a few lines.

Cost and priority. Supporters point out that doing nothing has a price too, and that the federal share, if Congress approves it, would bring in billions the city could not raise alone. Skeptics note that the city faces structural budget deficits and competing needs in housing, transit and public safety (The Five-Year Financial Plan and the structural deficit). A plan this large will compete for local dollars for decades, and the state and regional share, if any, is part of the negotiation. The Port itself, whose revenue comes largely from leases and fees rather than the General Fund, cannot carry the local share without some new source.

Hard edges or softer ones. Engineers describe a spectrum. Raised walls and levees are well understood and fit where land is already developed. Wetlands and gradually sloping shores absorb wave energy and provide habitat, but they take space the waterfront does not have in many places. The Living Seawall pilot is a way of testing whether hard infrastructure can do some of the habitat work.

Timing. The study sets design work for roughly 2026 to 2030 and construction in phases, so some critics ask whether the city should move faster on the most exposed reaches. Others reply that early construction without a federal commitment risks locking the city into designs the Corps will not later fund. The sequence is part of the negotiation, not a settled fact.

Who benefits first. Mission Bay and the central waterfront hold the city's highest-value property and its most visible tourism assets. The southeast waterfront, Bayview-Hunters Point and the Islais Creek area, includes neighborhoods with a long history of unequal investment and environmental burden. Whether those neighborhoods wait at the back of the line is part of the argument, and the Port's project list names Islais Creek and Bayview as a distinct project.

The ocean side

The bay shore is only half the city's shoreline. On the Pacific side, erosion at South Ocean Beach threatens the Lake Merced Tunnel, a 14-foot-diameter pipe under the Great Highway, and the SFPUC's Ocean Beach Climate Change Adaptation Project plans to remove the highway between Sloat and Skyline boulevards and replace it with coastal protection and access. Since 2015, sand has been moved from the north end of the beach to the south, more than 200,000 cubic yards in total, and in early 2021 a partnership with the Army Corps added 255,000 cubic yards of sand dredged from the ship channel (Ocean Beach and water monitoring). The two shorelines call for different tools, the bayfront for walls and fill-edge strengthening, the ocean beach for retreat and sand, but they share a planning range for sea-level rise.

How to follow it

The program publishes its Recommended Plan, project pages and public-meeting notices on the Port's website. The Port Commission meets in public, and the Board of Supervisors' budget process is where the local share would eventually appear. Congressional authorization is the step that decides whether the 65 percent federal share is available; until then, every number in this story is an estimate at an early stage of design.

Residents who live or work near the shore can also use the practical tools the city already has: ReadySF, AlertSF text alerts (text your ZIP code to 888-777), the storms and flooding guide on sf.gov and 311 for reports of flooding or sewer backups (Signing up for AlertSF and other emergency alerts). The Port's own homepage was already carrying winter-storm information for the 2026-27 El Nino season as of November 2026, a reminder that the near-term flood risk comes from storms and high tides long before the 2100 projections matter (El Nino winter 2026-27 and the Port).

Related city government

Related guides

Related neighborhoods

Latest on this topic