Blog
The Five-Year Financial Plan and the structural deficit
What San Francisco's Five-Year Financial Plan and its March Joint Report say about FY 2026-27 to 2029-30 deficits, and what the mayor's budget did about them.
Every spring San Francisco passes a budget balanced to the dollar. Every winter and spring, three city offices publish numbers showing that, without changes, the next budget would come up hundreds of millions short. Both statements are true, and the space between them is what the Five-Year Financial Plan exists to measure.
The plan is not the budget. It is a forecast. It adds up what the General Fund is expected to take in, adds up what current policies and contracts will cost and reports the difference for each of the next four or five years. When the difference is negative, that is a shortfall, and the mayor and the Board of Supervisors have to close it with cuts, new revenue or one-time money before they can adopt a budget.
Who writes it and when
A voter-approved measure, Proposition A in 2009, requires the city to plan five years at a time. It also moved San Francisco to adopting a budget every two years instead of every year, with the Municipal Transportation Agency, the Public Utilities Commission, the Airport and the Port on fixed two-year budgets and other departments on a rolling cycle (The San Francisco budget year in twelve months).
Three offices write the forecast: the Mayor's Budget Office, the Board of Supervisors' Budget and Legislative Analyst and the Controller. For the 2026 budget the sequence ran like this:
- December 19, 2025. The Five-Year Financial Plan Update covering fiscal years 2026-27 through 2029-30 was published. The mayor's policy instructions and the Controller's technical instructions to departments were issued on December 12, 2025 and revised on February 13, 2026.
- March 31, 2026. The offices published the Budget Outlook Update (March Five-Year Update), commonly called the Joint Report. San Francisco Administrative Code Section 3.6(b) requires the mayor, the Budget and Legislative Analyst and the Controller to submit regular updates to the plan.
- May 1 and June 1, 2026. The mayor proposed a budget for certain departments by May 1 and for all departments by June 1.
- By August 1. The Board of Supervisors, working through its Budget and Appropriations Committee, passed a spending plan, which the mayor signed (The Budget and Appropriations Committee).
What the March 2026 update said
The Joint Report made a deliberately plain claim in its executive summary: the shortfalls for fiscal years 2026-27 through 2029-30 were smaller than in December, "despite this improvement" still large by historical standards, and a significant structural deficit growing to more than $1 billion remained.
The report's projected General Fund shortfall by year, in millions of dollars:
| Fiscal year | Projected shortfall |
|---|---|
| 2026-27 | $168.5 |
| 2027-28 | $474.3 |
| 2028-29 | $741.7 |
| 2029-30 | $1,088.6 |
The report adds the first two figures to arrive at a two-year shortfall of $642.8 million. That is the number that counts most for the budget, because the Charter requires the city to adopt a balanced budget covering two years. It is $293.8 million less than the $936.6 million two-year shortfall the same offices projected in December 2025.
Why did the number improve? The report credits several things:
- more fund balance carried over from the current year, an additional $149.1 million assumed in the forecast;
- stronger-than-expected tax revenue, with weakness in property tax partly offset by gains in the hotel, sales and real property transfer taxes;
- growth in Department of Public Health revenue, mostly patient revenue at Laguna Honda Hospital and Zuckerberg San Francisco General Hospital;
- lower employer contributions to the retirement system, from a projected 17.06 percent of payroll to 16.7 percent, after the Retirement Board changed how it spreads the cost of supplemental cost-of-living adjustments.
What "structural" means
A one-year shortfall can come from a bad year: a tax that underperforms, a cost nobody saw coming. A structural deficit is a gap that persists because the city's costs grow faster than its revenue even when the economy behaves as expected. The March report shows how. Revenue is projected to grow, but baselines, salaries and benefits and operating costs grow faster. In the report's table, the cumulative increase in salaries and benefits climbs from $205.7 million in 2026-27 to $844.3 million by 2029-30, and baselines and reserves from $195.0 million to $243.1 million over the same period. Citywide operating costs and departmental costs climb as well, and total uses reach $1,786.6 million of cumulative growth by 2029-30.
Three of those categories need a line of explanation.
Baselines. The Charter sets minimum spending levels for services such as the Municipal Transportation Agency, the Library and the Public Education Enrichment Fund. Most baselines rise with the city's aggregate discretionary revenue. That sounds harmless, but it means a good revenue year automatically raises what must be spent on those baselines, and the report notes that neither the December forecast nor the March update assumes a pause in baseline growth.
Salaries and benefits. In years when labor contracts are open, the forecast assumes pay rises with the consumer price index. The March report used 3.35 percent for 2026-27, 3.12 percent for 2027-28, 2.94 percent for 2028-29 and 2.86 percent for 2029-30. It also assumed active-employee health costs grow 9.5 percent, up from 9 percent, citing high-cost claims and specialty drugs among the drivers (labor contracts and the budget).
State and federal policy. The report treats funding changes from H.R. 1, the 2025 federal budget law, as a separate line. It estimates the revenue impact at a two-year total of $306.3 million, just under half the $642.8 million shortfall. That is why the report stresses uncertainty: federal and state decisions could change the picture quickly.
The tax pieces the forecast watches
A handful of taxes carry most of the forecasting risk, and the report is specific about each.
- Property tax. The report assumed annual secured roll growth at 2 percent, the maximum Proposition 13 allows. It expected lower property tax revenue because of the money that must be set aside to pay refunds after Assessment Appeals Board decisions. Many commercial properties that have not sold since 2020 remain valued below their most recent sale price.
- Business taxes. Proposition M, approved in November 2024, restructured the gross receipts tax: it changed the calculations and rates, raised the small business exemption and reorganized the business activity categories. The first filings under it were for tax year 2025. By the March 2 filing deadline only about 60 percent of the tax base had filed, rather than the 75 percent assumed, which pushed revenue out of FY 2025-26 and into FY 2026-27. The report notes that Prop M required the Controller to issue a review of the new tax system by September 1, 2026 (The gross receipts tax and the other San Francisco business taxes).
- Real property transfer tax. Projected to reach about $400 million by FY 2029-30. After two historically weak years, the report said, the city was more confident of a recovery (the real property transfer tax and the budget).
- Hotel tax. The General Fund share was projected at $282.8 million for FY 2025-26 and $289.4 million for 2026-27, helped by strong Moscone Center attendance and demand around Super Bowl LX, which was played in Santa Clara in early February 2026 (The hotel tax and the Moscone Center).
- Litigation. The forecast also holds a reserve for tax refund lawsuits; the report said the projected reserve fell from $394 million to $384 million after settlements with large taxpayers.
Reading the table yourself
The report's main table shows how the first-year number is built. For fiscal year 2026-27, revenue and spending changes combined to a subtotal shortfall of $83.9 million. State and federal policy impacts added $84.5 million, for a total of $168.5 million. Over the next years the subtotal grows to $252.5 million, $515.8 million and $883.8 million, and the state and federal line, $84.5 million in the first year, jumps to $221.8 million in the second and stays between about $205 million and $226 million after that.
Two things follow. The early years are small next to the late ones: the gap more than doubles between the first year and the second and keeps climbing. And a large part of the first year is outside the city's control. If federal funding shifted, the forecast would move with it.
What could move the numbers
The report says plainly that "heightened levels of uncertainty exist." The offices point to federal policy changes that could constrain federal and state funding to local governments and change inflation, labor markets and consumer sentiment, all of which feed back into local tax revenue and costs. Smaller assumptions matter too: a forecast that assumes 2 percent growth in the property tax roll, 9.5 percent growth in employee health costs and about 3 percent annual wage growth is only as good as those three guesses. When an actual number lands a few points off, a later year's shortfall can move by tens of millions of dollars.
The report also leaves some decisions deliberately open. It does not assume a pause in the growth of any charter baseline, and it does not assume cuts the mayor has not yet proposed. That is the point of the exercise: the forecast shows the gap that would exist if nothing were done, and the budget shows what was done about it.
What the mayor did with it
The mayor's office reported that the budget signed after the Board's unanimous vote was a balanced $16.9 billion plan for fiscal year 2026-27, with $17.2 billion proposed for 2027-28. The proposed 2026-27 figure was up $861.3 million, or 5.4 percent, over the current year, and the mayor's office said the plan closed the $642 million two-year deficit while protecting the social safety net. The city's budget book describes the approach in its own words; the section on how the gap was closed is worth reading (how the two-year budget closed a $642 million gap).
Closing the first two years did not erase the later ones. The same report projected shortfalls of $741.7 million in 2028-29 and $1,088.6 million in 2029-30, and the city will update its projections in the next December plan and again in March. That is the point of a rolling five-year view: a balanced budget this summer is followed by a forecast this winter showing how large the next gap is.
How a resident can follow it
The documents are public. The Budget Outlook Update and the December plan are posted on sf.gov's budget pages, the Board's budget pages and the Controller's page. The Controller also publishes six-month and nine-month status reports on the current year, and the Board's Budget and Legislative Analyst publishes reports on specific questions. For the short version, look at three things in the Joint Report: the two-year total, the year-by-year table and the list of risks to the forecast.