Blog
Ocean Beach and water monitoring
How the SFPUC's permit-required monitoring around the Oceanside plant and outfall works, what erosion means for the 3.5-mile beach, and how to read conditions.
On a summer evening Ocean Beach looks like nothing but sand, wind and fog: dogs, surfers, fire pits, the Pacific rolling in gray. It is a straight, scoured stretch about 3.5 miles long running along the Great Highway from the Cliff House at its northern end toward Fort Funston in the south. What the evening crowd does not see is the piece of public infrastructure sitting under the sand and the highway, the Oceanside wastewater system. Treated wastewater from the west side of the city goes out to the ocean, so the San Francisco Public Utilities Commission (SFPUC) is required to watch the water and the sand closely, and that monitoring is the most useful public record of how the beach is doing.
The system under the beach
The city runs two wastewater systems. The bayside system serves most of the city and is treated at the Southeast Plant. The oceanside system serves the western neighborhoods, the Richmond, the Sunset and the areas around Lake Merced, and it is treated at the Oceanside Water Pollution Control Plant near the zoo. The SFPUC says it built the Oceanside plant and the associated wastewater infrastructure in the 1980s and 1990s to protect coastal water quality and public health in response to the federal Clean Water Act (San Francisco Public Utilities Commission).
Treated water leaves the plant through the Southwest Ocean Outfall, which discharges well offshore rather than at the surf line. The regional water board issues the plant's permit under the federal discharge permit system. The current permit, Order R2-2019-0028, covers the Oceanside plant, its collection system and the Westside Recycled Water Project, and it names the Pacific Ocean off Fort Funston and Ocean Beach as the discharge point for the plant's wet-weather effluent, which receives a lower level of treatment than the dry-weather flow. The wet-weather provision exists because rainstorms push far more water into the system than the plant can fully treat at once.
What the permit makes the SFPUC measure
The permit's monitoring and reporting sections require extensive sampling to show compliance with the Clean Water Act and the California Ocean Plan. In plain terms, the SFPUC has to measure the effluent leaving the plant and the receiving water and shoreline where people swim and surf. The monitoring record includes shoreline sampling at several beaches, including Ocean Beach, Baker Beach and China Beach.
A summary of the program's first sixteen years, 1997 through 2012, found that water quality at Baker Beach, China Beach and Ocean Beach was generally very good, especially in dry weather. That phrase matters to a resident deciding whether to surf in July or after a December storm. The difference between dry and wet weather is the most useful rule of thumb on this coast, and it holds for every urban beach in California, not just this one.
Reading conditions yourself
California public health guidance, repeated by county health departments, advises people to avoid swimming and surfing in ocean water for about three days after a significant rain. Stormwater picks up animal waste, trash and chemicals from streets and carries them to the shore, and bacteria counts rise after rain even where the sewage plant is working properly. The same guidance recommends staying away from storm drain outfalls at any time and from areas where posted signs warn of poor water quality.
The city's Department of Public Health and the regional agencies post beach advisories and run their own testing, so a resident checking a beach should look at those notices and not go by appearance. Clear water is not proof of clean water. Murky water after a storm is a sign to wait (San Francisco Department of Public Health).
The ocean itself is the larger hazard. Ocean Beach has strong currents, rip currents, cold water and sneaker waves, and the National Weather Service forecast office for the Bay Area issues surf and beach hazard statements for this coast (seasons and what to pack). Many people who get into trouble are not swimmers but waders caught by a wave that runs higher up the sand than expected. Stay out of waist-deep water, and never turn your back on the surf.
The other kind of monitoring: sand
Water quality is one monitoring job. Erosion is the other, and it is the one most visible from the Great Highway. The SFPUC does an annual round of monitoring of the beach profile, which it uses under its permits to decide whether sand placement or sandbag work is needed to protect infrastructure. That monitoring is about the shoreline, not about bacteria.
It matters most at South Ocean Beach, near the Sloat Boulevard end. The Lake Merced Tunnel, a 14-foot-diameter pipe that carries wastewater, runs beneath the Great Highway there, and erosion of the bluff threatens it. The SFPUC's Ocean Beach Climate Change Adaptation Project is the long-term answer. It builds on the 2012 Ocean Beach Master Plan, published by the planning nonprofit SPUR, and carries out two of the plan's six key moves: managed retreat, which includes removing the Great Highway between Sloat and Skyline boulevards, and a coastal protection, restoration and access system in its place.
Short-term measures have been in use for years.
- Since 2015, sand has been moved from the northern part of Ocean Beach to the south, and the total has passed 200,000 cubic yards.
- In early 2021, a partnership with the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers added 255,000 cubic yards of sand dredged from the San Francisco main ship channel and placed on the beach.
The long-term design includes recontouring the bluffs, removing the rubble and revetment rock that has piled up on the beach over decades, continued beach nourishment, a low-profile buried wall to protect the tunnel, and a coastal access trail with a public restroom and parking. The SFPUC described the design as about 95 percent complete, with construction expected to begin in late 2023 and run four years. Anyone who wants the current schedule should check the project page at sfpuc.gov/oceanbeach, since construction dates move.
The project also ties into the city's larger sea-level conversation. The bayfront has its own plan, estimated at $14.7 billion in 2026 dollars (waterfront resilience and sea-level rise), but the Pacific side's problem is different: waves, a retreating bluff and a highway built on dune.
Dunes, windmills and the Outside Lands
The beach makes more sense with the landscape behind it. Until the late nineteenth century the land west of the city's built-up core was shifting dune, which San Franciscans called the Outside Lands. Golden Gate Park was carved out of that sand beginning in 1870, and its designers, William Hammond Hall and later John McLaren, spent decades planting grasses and trees to hold it down (Golden Gate Park's 1,017 acres). The two windmills at the park's western edge, the North Windmill built in 1902 and the Murphy Windmill, were put there to pump water for the park's irrigation, and the Murphy Windmill was restored in 2011. Visitors who walk from the windmills across the Great Highway reach the beach in a few minutes, and the walk runs through the full gradient from planted park to bare sand.
Sand itself moves with the seasons. Winter storm waves tend to pull sand off a beach and carry it offshore, so the beach is narrower after a stormy December, while calmer summer swells push sand back toward shore. That seasonal rhythm is normal. What worries engineers is the long-term trend at the south end, where the bluff keeps retreating and the pipe beneath the road sits closer to the water each year. It is why the SFPUC counts the beach profile every year, and why sand has been trucked and dredged to the southern stretch since 2015.
What the permit does not cover
It helps to know the limits of this monitoring. The SFPUC's permit covers the plant, its outfall and the collection system it controls. It does not cover every source of bacteria that reaches the beach. Urban runoff from streets and storm drains, birds, dogs and the occasional broken private sewer lateral all contribute, and the city handles them through different tools: the street sweeping and litter programs run by Public Works, the rules on pet waste, and the sewer-lateral rules that apply to property owners (San Francisco Public Works). The regional water board regulates stormwater under separate permits.
The Westside Recycled Water Project, which the same permit covers, treats some wastewater to a standard high enough for irrigation of Golden Gate Park and other west-side landscapes, replacing drinking water that would otherwise go onto lawns and trees. It is one of the ways the oceanside system reduces what it sends to the Pacific.
The beach in the city's life
The Great Highway was built in the 1920s as a road along the dunes, and the Richmond and Sunset districts were built behind it, with the Outer Sunset the closer of the two to the surf (Outer Sunset, Outer Richmond). The beach's northern end at Lands End and the Cliff House is a different landscape of cliffs and trails managed by the National Park Service as part of Golden Gate National Recreation Area, and the south, beyond Sloat, leads to Fort Funston's bluffs and hang gliders (Lands End and the Outer Richmond, Ocean Beach, the western edge of San Francisco).
A resident who wants to use the beach safely and knowledgeably needs only a short routine.
- After a significant rain, wait about three days before swimming or surfing.
- Check posted advisories before entering the water, and look for warning signs at the beach entrances.
- Check the NWS surf forecast for rip current and high surf statements before a winter visit.
- Dress for wind and cold even on a clear day. The downtown normals for July show highs only in the mid-60s, and the beach is cooler still.
- Report problems you see, such as a sewage smell near a storm drain, a dead animal, litter or an erosion hazard, through 311.
San Francisco treats its wastewater at one plant that discharges miles offshore and watches the shore to make sure the practice is working. So far the record says the beach is generally good in dry weather and unpredictable after storms, which is true of most beaches near a city. The better question for the next two decades is not the plant but the bluff, and what becomes of the road and the pipes behind it as the Pacific moves in.