Blog

The real property transfer tax and the budget

Why a tax paid on about 1 percent of San Francisco property sales supplies hundreds of millions of dollars, and what that means for the city budget.

Every time a building changes hands in San Francisco, somebody owes the city a tax on the sale, and for the priciest buildings the bill is enormous. The real property transfer tax is the city's most volatile major revenue source, and in recent years it has caused more budget heartburn than almost any other line. What follows is a set of questions and answers: what the tax is, why one slice of it matters so much and how the mayor's budget for fiscal years 2026-27 and 2027-28 handles it.

What is the real property transfer tax?

It is a tax on the transfer of real property, measured by the price. It is collected when the deed is recorded, which happens at the Assessor-Recorder's office, so the money moves through the same office that values property and records documents. It is a separate thing from the annual property tax, which is billed on assessed value. This one is paid once, at the moment of sale, not every year. Most home buyers pay a transfer tax of one kind or another at closing, and the closing statement itemizes it; this post is about the part of the schedule that applies to large transactions.

San Francisco's schedule is graduated by price, and the rates climb steeply at the top. The ballot measure that set the top rates was Proposition I, approved by voters in November 2020, which put the rates at 5.5 percent for properties valued between $10 million and under $25 million and 6 percent for properties of $25 million and more. A reduced rate of 3 percent applies for qualifying housing projects that meet specific criteria, including a share of affordable units, union labor and union pension fund financing, for transfers through December 31, 2033. The Assessor-Recorder's pages list the current schedule in full, and anyone with a transaction in view should read that schedule and not lean on a summary.

Why does a tax on a small number of sales matter so much?

Because the money is so concentrated. The mayor's budget book calls the tax highly progressive and says sales over $10 million often account for over half of the revenue each year while making up only 1 percent of transactions. One large office tower sale can bring in more than hundreds of home sales. That is wonderful when downtown buildings change hands and painful when they do not.

The numbers show the swing. The budget projects $358.8 million in real property transfer tax revenue for fiscal year 2026-27, which is $91.2 million, or 34.1 percent, more than the prior year's budget. For 2027-28 it rises another $11.6 million, or 3.2 percent, to $370.4 million. The same budget book says pandemic-era changes to the city's economy had pushed the revenue to historic lows, and that it then rebounded on lower interest rates and a reset in which building owners accepted losses on buildings bought before the pandemic and returned to the market.

How does it fit with the other taxes?

It is one of several revenue lines that behave differently, and the budget treats them as a group. The General Fund property tax is budgeted at $2,407.0 million for 2026-27, down $30.0 million from the prior year, because commercial property values are under pressure. The transfer tax is growing, though more slowly than in 2024-25 and 2025-26. The two move in opposite directions for a reason: when buildings sell below their existing assessed values, the sale produces transfer tax revenue now but also signals refunds on properties with open assessment appeals and resets assessed values downward, which holds back growth in the commercial property tax base for years. The budget's own description is that recent sale prices still tend to fall below existing assessed values.

The business tax is another sign of the shift, and the budget calls it the bright spot in the revenue outlook. The forecast for the tax overall assumes the city's commercial real estate sector continues its recovery and office value reset during the budget period, which shows up in the pairing of lower property tax and growing transfer tax forecasts. the downtown office market and the budget looks at that office story in more detail.

What could go wrong?

The budget book states the risk bluntly. It assumes high-end sales values and volumes keep growing as they have since fiscal year 2024-25, but any disturbance in this relatively small number of transactions could derail the recovery. That is the nature of a tax that hangs on a handful of very large sales: one deal falling through, one quarter without a big closing or a change in interest rates can move the annual total by tens of millions of dollars.

So the city's forecasts handle the transfer tax with care. The March 2026 Joint Report from the Mayor's Budget Office, the Board of Supervisors' Budget and Legislative Analyst and the Controller projected deficits of $168.5 million in 2026-27 and $474.3 million in 2027-28. The budget the mayor proposed and the Board approved closed a two-year gap by combining spending reductions, use of reserves and fund balance, and revenue assumptions like the ones above. how the two-year budget closed a $642 million gap explains how that package worked, and How to read the San Francisco budget book shows how to find the revenue pages yourself.

Who pays, and what does a buyer see?

The tax is paid in connection with the transfer, and by custom and by contract in a given sale the buyer or the seller may bear it; the purchase agreement allocates it. A buyer or seller of an ordinary home meets the tax in the closing statement, usually as a charge handled by the title or escrow company, which files the documents and pays the tax at recording. The very large sales that drive the revenue are negotiated with the tax in mind, and a 5.5 or 6 percent rate on a $100 million deal means the tax alone can run into the millions.

Because voters set the rates, not the Board of Supervisors, changing them takes a ballot measure. Proposals to adjust the schedule, whether to lower the rate to encourage construction or to raise it to fund programs, are therefore proposals to go to the ballot, and the Board has the power to place charter and ordinance amendments on it. how a charter amendment reaches the ballot explains that path. The arguments on each side are familiar. Supporters of higher rates say the tax falls on the most valuable transactions and funds services. Critics say a tax that high discourages sales and construction, which in turn reduces property tax and jobs. The budget's own view is that the transfer tax is a highly progressive revenue source the city is leaning on more heavily than before.

A hypothetical sale, step by step

Consider a hypothetical sale of a commercial building for $30,000,000. At the top schedule, a property valued at $25 million or more carries a rate of 6 percent, so the tax would be $1,800,000. If a $12,000,000 building sold instead, it would fall in the $10 million to under $25 million tier at 5.5 percent, and the tax would be $660,000. The figures show only how the top tiers scale; the Assessor-Recorder's schedule governs any actual transaction and has the rates for the lower tiers, the rules for partial interests and the exemptions.

Put the $1,800,000 beside the budget. The city budgets $358.8 million for 2026-27, so a single sale that size would supply about half a percent of the year's total. And since sales over $10 million supply over half the revenue and about 1 percent of the transactions, a handful of large closings can make or break the annual number. That is why forecasters watch the pipeline of big sales so closely.

What the budget does about the volatility

The budget builds some cushions around volatile revenue. It allocates $505.0 million of General Fund year-end fund balance as a source across the two budget years and withdraws $191.1 million from reserves, including $54.8 million from the Budget Stabilization One Time Reserve. Its language on the transfer tax is cautious in the same spirit: the forecast builds on the strong recovery of the last two years but assumes slower growth than in 2024-25 and 2025-26. A forecast that misses low leaves a surplus, while one that misses high leaves a hole that has to be filled during the fiscal year, and no finance office likes the second kind of surprise.

The Board of Supervisors' Budget and Appropriations Committee reviews those assumptions every spring. The Budget and Appropriations Committee describes how that review works, and The San Francisco budget year in twelve months puts it on the calendar.

Where to read more

The Assessor-Recorder's office, San Francisco Office of the Assessor-Recorder, records the deeds and applies the tax; the Treasurer and Tax Collector, Office of the Treasurer and Tax Collector, is where most other taxes are paid; and City budget and finance describes how the budget gets built. Taxes in San Francisco: sales, property and hotel places the transfer tax among the other city taxes. The mayor's budget pages at sf.gov hold the full budget book with the revenue forecasts quoted here.

This is general information about the tax and the budget, not tax or legal advice for a transaction.

Related city government

Related guides

Latest on this topic