Blog

How the two-year budget closed a $642 million gap

From the December 2025 forecast to the unanimous Board vote: the steps, the tools and the deficits still projected after the 2026 budget was balanced.

The state constitution says the budget must balance. The city charter says it must balance two years at a time. In the spring of 2026 those two sentences ran into a forecast. The city's own analysts said the General Fund would come up short by hundreds of millions of dollars in each of the next two years. By August the Board of Supervisors had passed a $16.9 billion budget for fiscal year 2026-27 and $17.2 billion for 2027-28 without a deficit, and the mayor had signed it. How that happened is a useful case study, because every number in it is public and the steps follow a pattern the city repeats every budget season.

The forecast: December 2025

The cycle starts with a forecast. On December 19, 2025 the Mayor's Office, the Controller's Office and the Board of Supervisors' Budget and Legislative Analyst released an update to the Five-Year Financial Plan, known as the Joint Report. It projected a General Fund deficit of $296.3 million in fiscal year 2026-27 and $640.3 million in FY 2027-28, a two-year total of $936.6 million (296.3 plus 640.3). It also projected the shortfall growing to $1.17 billion by the end of the forecast period, which runs through FY 2029-30.

The budget book names the drivers: projected losses of federal revenue from the federal budget reconciliation law H.R. 1, rising city workforce and operating costs, weakness in property tax revenue tied to lower office and commercial values, and heightened economic and policy uncertainty at the federal level. Put plainly, costs were rising faster than revenue, and some of the revenue was shaky.

The instruction: $400 million in permanent cuts

Because the projected deficit passed $1 billion by the end of the forecast, the mayor told departments to propose ongoing, permanent spending reductions totaling $400 million, starting in FY 2026-27. Departments were also discouraged from proposing new revenue as a way of meeting their targets. The instruction matters because it shaped what came back: departments were asked to identify cuts that would both balance the two budget years and significantly reduce the out-year shortfalls, by nearly $300 million over the five-year horizon.

Departments submit their requests to the Controller by mid-February, and the Controller sends them to the mayor's budget staff in early March. From March through June the Mayor's Office analyzes each proposal and holds budget workshops and office hours with community groups. The calendar is covered in The San Francisco budget year in twelve months.

The update: March 2026

On March 31, 2026 the same three offices published the March Update to the Joint Report. The two-year deficit was now $642.8 million: $168.5 million in FY 2026-27 and $474.3 million in FY 2027-28 (168.5 plus 474.3 equals 642.8). That was $293.8 million better than December's two-year figure of $936.6 million.

The book attributes the improvement to higher current-year fund balance from slowed hiring and spending, higher General Fund revenue projections in FY 2026-27 because of Proposition M (the 2024 business tax measure), ongoing public health revenue increases and lower employer retirement contributions. But the trend underneath had not changed: cost growth was still outpacing revenue growth, and the March Update projected the structural shortfall growing to $741.7 million in FY 2028-29 and $1.09 billion in FY 2029-30.

The toolkit: how the gap was closed

The budget book lists the tools used to close the two-year gap. Taken together, they are the answer to the question "where did the money come from?"

Spending reductions.

  • A reduction of more than $100 million in personnel spending in FY 2026-27, achieved through a combination of vacant position deletions, labor contract negotiations, reassignments and some workforce reductions. The mayor's letter adds that the administration saved $100 million by slowing hiring and focusing on roles that provide core services.
  • The elimination of more than 550 vacant positions across the two-year budget, while the book says it protects frontline service delivery.
  • Realigning grant portfolios to prioritize direct services for San Francisco residents, and decreasing expected contracting costs.
  • Reduced citywide operating expenses such as real estate, information technology and fleet management.
  • An assumed $81.5 million reduction to salaries and benefits in the second year, designed to push departments to reorganize. The mayor's letter describes it as a plan to save another $80 million through reorganization and attrition. In practical terms, departments must develop plans to limit management layers, improve workflow and explore shared services.

Consolidation.

  • The budget finalizes the merger of two departments into a new Agency for Human Rights (the Human Rights Commission and the Department on the Status of Women), and moves Film SF and Grants for the Arts under the Arts Commission.

Revenue.

  • Fee increases across departments that charge for services, so they keep pace with the cost of those services.
  • Business tax revenue improvements since the December report and March update.
  • Investment in the state benefit eligibility workflow, to draw additional federal revenue.

Some one-time reserves were also used for one-time projects, such as capital and deferred maintenance, equipment and workforce support meant to improve the federal revenue outlook. The book specifies that those one-time uses are not reflected in the Joint Report's deficit projections: they are on top of the gap, not part of closing it.

The result, in the book's words, is a reduction of the five-year structural deficit by approximately $300 million.

What the balanced budget still paid for

Closing a gap does not mean spending nothing new, and the book is explicit about where it kept spending. The executive summary lists the priority areas the proposal protects or expands:

  • The safety net. The book notes that over 200,000 San Franciscans are enrolled in Medi-Cal and over 100,000 rely on CalFresh, and that as many as 20 percent could lose access to those benefits without intervention given federal eligibility changes. The budget fully maintains Tenant Right to Counsel funding in both years and establishes an Emergency Housing Risk Reserve against the loss of federal housing voucher money.
  • Public safety. The budget fully funds the new agreements with the police officers' and firefighters' unions, as part of the mayor's effort to return the Police Department to full sworn staffing, and funds additional investigator positions at the Department of Police Accountability.
  • Streets and infrastructure. A $79 million General Fund investment, plus $126 million of existing debt financing and state sources, goes to potholes and repaving over two years, and the budget funds more than 180 capital projects with $250 million of General Fund support over the two years.
  • Schools and children. The General Fund contributes $134 million in FY 2026-27 to the Public Education Enrichment Fund and $45 million to the voter-adopted Student Success Fund, both set-asides for the school district.

None of those items was a surprise; most are annual commitments. What changed in 2026 is that they were being funded while the same document eliminated more than 550 vacant positions and trimmed grants and contracts. That combination, protection in some places and subtraction in others, is the real content of the phrase "balanced budget."

The numbers behind the headline

The mayor's office describes the budget as closing a $642 million two-year deficit, which is the March Update's $642.8 million rounded. It is worth separating three different numbers that often get blurred:

  1. The two-year deficit ($642.8 million). This is what had to be closed to adopt a balanced budget for FY 2026-27 and FY 2027-28. The budget closed it.
  2. The structural deficit reduction (about $300 million). This is the amount by which ongoing savings and revenues shrink the long-run shortfall, across the five-year plan.
  3. The remaining out-year shortfall. The March Update projected $741.7 million in FY 2028-29 and $1,088.6 million in FY 2029-30. The book says the ongoing savings "will not eliminate the structural deficit outright" because healthcare costs, cost-of-living adjustments and inflation on materials and supplies will keep rising faster than projected revenues.

The mayor's letter puts it this way: if the city fails to act, the structural deficit grows to $1 billion. The Five-Year Financial Plan and the structural deficit follows what those later-year numbers mean.

What happened at the Board

The mayor introduced the General Fund budget on June 1, 2026. The Budget and Appropriations Committee holds public hearings in June, with the help of the Board's Budget and Legislative Analyst, who recommends reductions, and sends its recommendations to the full Board by the end of June. The charter requires two votes of the full Board between July 15 and August 1. The mayor's office says the Board passed the $16.9 billion budget unanimously and the mayor signed it. The Budget and Appropriations Committee explains the committee's role, and How an idea becomes an ordinance at the Board of Supervisors explains the two-reading rule.

Reading the case: questions an analyst would ask

The record does not settle every judgment call, but it shows where the judgments were made. A careful reader of the budget would ask:

  • How much is permanent? Eliminated vacant positions and consolidations are ongoing savings. Reserve draws, such as the $191.1 million withdrawn from reserves across the two years, are not. The book also uses $505.0 million of General Fund year-end fund balance as a source in the two years. Both are one-time resources.
  • What happens to services? The book says it protects frontline service delivery and the mayor's letter acknowledges that a responsible budget requires tradeoffs. Hiring slowdowns and reduced grants affect residents in ways that show up in later performance reports.
  • What did the federal change cost? The mayor's letter describes a new $100 million reserve for further federal cuts to housing and homeless services, plus $34 million to help residents stay enrolled in Medi-Cal and CalFresh, the benefit programs the budget says more than 200,000 and more than 100,000 San Franciscans rely on.
  • What do the labor agreements cost? The proposed budget fully funds the recent agreements with the police officers' and firefighters' unions, which the book says provide a 14 percent pay increase over four years, and it counts a $379.5 million increase in total labor costs in FY 2026-27 alone.

These are questions, not conclusions. The Controller's Office and the Board's analyst publish their own reviews, and the city's budget information page posts the proposal, the Board's changes and the final ordinance. If you want the annual calendar rather than this year's story, The San Francisco budget year in twelve months is the companion, and How to read the San Francisco budget book is a guide to the document itself.

Related city government

Related guides

Latest on this topic