Blog

How a charter amendment reaches the ballot

Tracing File No. 251245, the term-limits measure that became Proposition B, from the Board's submission to the June 2, 2026 vote and the June 30 declaration.

An ordinance becomes law when the Board of Supervisors passes it twice and the mayor lets it stand. A charter amendment plays by other rules. The charter is the city's governing document, and changing it takes the voters. That makes the road from idea to ballot a different one, and it is worth knowing, because the charter holds the rules on everything from the mayor's powers to commission appointments. The clearest recent example is Proposition B, the term-limits measure voters approved on June 2, 2026. Its trail runs through public records at every step, and this timeline follows it, with the file numbers and dates that show where each step sits.

Step 1: The Board submits the measure to the voters

Proposition B began as File No. 251245 in the Board of Supervisors' Legislative Research Center. Board file numbers begin with the two digits of the year of introduction (the June 2026 election results resolution, for instance, is File No. 260753), so the number marks the measure as one introduced in 2025. The heading on the legislation described it as a charter amendment, and the text said in so many words that the Board of Supervisors submits the proposal to the voters at the June 2, 2026 election.

The legislation was approved as to form by the City Attorney's Office. The City Attorney's Office drafts and approves legislation for the city, and "approved as to form" is a statement about the text, not an endorsement of the policy. See What the City Attorney does for the city.

Charter amendments are marked up so voters can see exactly what changes. In the text of this one, new language appears underlined and deleted language appears struck through: the word "successive" was struck from the sections on the term limits for supervisors (Section 2.101) and mayor (Section 3.101), and the sentence that had allowed non-successive terms was removed. Reading the strike-throughs is the quickest way to understand a charter amendment, and the Legislative Research Center posts the text of every file. Proposition B and the move to lifetime term limits explains what the changes meant.

Step 2: Committee and public hearing

Like other legislation, a measure of this kind is introduced, assigned to a committee and heard in public. The Board's Rules of Order add a 30-day rule for measures that would create or revise major policy: a committee cannot consider them until 30 days after introduction. A change to term limits for the city's top offices is the kind of measure the rule is aimed at. At the hearing, supervisors can amend the language and the public can comment. How an idea becomes an ordinance at the Board of Supervisors shows the same path for an ordinance.

Step 3: The Board votes to place it on the ballot

On February 3, 2026 the Board voted 7 to 4 to place the measure on the June 2 ballot. Seven supervisors (Dorsey, Fielder, Mahmood, Melgar, Sauter, Sherrill and Wong) voted yes, and four (Chan, Chen, Mandelman and Walton) voted no. Supervisor Bilal Mahmood was the sponsor. The Board's general rule is that six of the eleven must vote yes to approve an ordinance, resolution or motion unless the charter or state law sets a different threshold, and seven votes cleared it comfortably.

Unlike an ordinance, a charter amendment does not become law when the mayor acts. The Good Government Guide's definition of the "final action" date tells the story: for resolutions it is the date the mayor approves, but for charter amendments and initiative ordinances it is the date the voters approve them, if they do.

Step 4: The ballot materials

Once a measure is on the ballot, the Department of Elections assembles the voter pamphlet. The November 3, 2026 pamphlet states what it contains for each local measure:

  1. The measure's letter and title.
  2. The City Attorney's statement or question, the wording that appears on the ballot.
  3. The Ballot Simplification Council's digest, a plain-language summary. (The pamphlet notes that the Council was formerly called the Ballot Simplification Committee.)
  4. The Controller's financial analysis. For Proposition B in June, the Controller's Office described no cost to government.
  5. An explanation of how the measure qualified for the ballot.
  6. Arguments submitted to the department: one proponent's argument and one opponent's argument selected under the Municipal Elections Code and printed free, a rebuttal to each, and any paid arguments, printed as submitted and not checked for accuracy by any official agency.
  7. The legal text of each measure.

The digest also states the vote the measure needs: "This measure requires 50%+1 affirmative votes to pass" appears on the charter amendments in the November pamphlet. The Ethics Commission's campaign dashboards, at campaign.sfethics.org, list the money behind each measure; Campaign money and the Ethics Commission explains them.

Step 5: The election

The June 2, 2026 election was a Consolidated Statewide Direct Primary, with local measures on the same ballot as state and federal primaries. Because a charter amendment changes the governing document, it needs a simple majority of the votes cast, 50 percent plus one. The bond on the same ballot, Proposition A (the Earthquake Safety and Emergency Response Bond), needed two-thirds, because a bond commits the city to borrow money.

Different measures, different thresholds. That is why the same election can adopt one measure comfortably and fall short on another that gets more than half the vote.

Step 6: Counting, certification and the Board's declaration

After the polls close, the Department of Elections counts, verifies and certifies the results; How San Francisco releases election results explains how. When the Director of Elections has certified, the Board declares the results by resolution. For this election, the Board adopted Resolution 392-26 (File No. 260753) on June 30, 2026, citing California Elections Code Sections 9269 and 15400, by a vote of 11 to 0. The resolution stated that Proposition B, Lifetime Term Limits for Mayor and Members of the Board of Supervisors, received the majority required for a charter amendment and was therefore passed by the voters.

The dates, in one table

Step Date or marker
Introduced at the Board 2025, as File No. 251245
Board votes to place on ballot February 3, 2026, 7 to 4
Election June 2, 2026
Results certified by the Director of Elections Before June 30, 2026
Board declares results (Resolution 392-26, File No. 260753) June 30, 2026, 11 to 0

Reading a charter amendment in the pamphlet

For the November 3, 2026 election, the pamphlet covers 14 state measures, one regional measure and 10 local measures, so a voter has a lot of reading. A routine helps. Start with the question printed on the ballot, then the digest's "The Way It Is Now" and "The Proposal" sections, which set the old rule beside the new one. Read the "Yes vote means" and "No vote means" lines, which state in one sentence what each choice does. Check the Controller's statement for the cost. Then read the arguments, remembering that the pamphlet prints them as submitted and notes that no official agency has checked them for accuracy, and finish with the legal text if a word in the digest matters to you. The pamphlet's glossary, "Words You Need to Know," defines the Charter as the city's constitution and says it can be changed only by a majority of the votes cast in San Francisco.

What the charter holds

It helps to know what kind of rules live in the charter, because those are the rules only voters can change. The City Attorney's Good Government Guide cites charter sections throughout, and together they sketch the document:

Charter section Subject
2.101 Supervisors' terms of office (changed by Proposition B)
2.114 The ban on Board interference in administration
3.100(18) The most common way the mayor appoints commissioners
3.101 The mayor's term of office (changed by Proposition B)
4.101 Residency and age rules for commissioners
4.109 The Police Commission and the chief of police
4.137 The Sheriff's Department Oversight Board
6.102 The City Attorney as the city's legal representative
8A.102 The Municipal Transportation Agency's board of directors
13.103.5 The Elections Commission
15.100 The Ethics Commission
15.103 "Public office is a public trust"
16.114 The Board's power of inquiry

Several of these bodies exist because voters said so. The Sheriff's Department Oversight Board and the Office of Sheriff's Inspector General were created by a 2020 voter mandate, and the Controller's Inspector General function was created by voters in November 2024. The two-year budget cycle that governs the city's finances came from Proposition A on November 3, 2009, which amended the City Charter to require it. The Municipal Transportation Agency was created by the voters in 1999. In each case the rule is more durable than an ordinance, because the Board cannot repeal it alone.

Charter amendment versus ordinance

Ordinance Charter amendment
Who can pass it The Board, with six of eleven votes, plus the mayor's action or a veto override of eight The voters, by the threshold the measure requires
Readings Two, at least five days apart The Board places it on the ballot; voters decide
Effective Usually the 31st day after the mayor's action, or sooner for some types When the voters approve it, as declared by the Board
Who can undo it The Board, by another ordinance Generally only the voters
Example A street closed to trucks at certain hours Lifetime term limits for the mayor and supervisors

The practical result is that a Board majority can place a question before the voters but cannot decide it, and that the supervisors who voted against Proposition B in February were still bound by what the electorate decided in June.

Other ways onto the ballot

The Board's route, which Proposition B took, is one of several. The Ballot Simplification Council's digest for a measure on the November 3, 2026 ballot (Proposition D, which would change these very rules) lists the ways the charter currently allows a measure to be placed on the ballot:

  • By a majority vote of the Board of Supervisors.
  • By four or more Board members without a Board vote.
  • By the mayor, without a Board vote.
  • By a signature initiative, a petition signed by at least 2 percent of the city's registered voters, about 10,600 signatures at the time of the pamphlet, with more than 530,000 registered voters in the city.

A charter amendment placed by petition has a higher bar. The pamphlet says 53,076 signatures were required to place an initiative charter amendment on the 2026 ballot, a number equal to 10 percent of the registered voters when the proponents' "Notice of Intent to Circulate Petition" was published. Proponents of three of the November charter amendments (Propositions D, E and F) submitted petitions by a July 6, 2026 deadline; on July 23, 2026 the Department of Elections certified, after a random check of the signatures, that each had enough valid ones to qualify. Proposition A, a charter amendment on city departments and commissions, took the Board route: the Board voted 9 to 2 on July 14, 2026 to place it on the ballot.

Once a signature initiative is submitted to the Department of Elections it cannot currently be withdrawn, and signature initiatives usually appear on the next regularly scheduled election. Proposition D, which is on the November ballot and whose result was not final in mid-November, would raise the signature requirement for initiatives from 2 percent to 8 percent of registered voters (from about 10,600 to about 42,500), allow petitions to be withdrawn up to 102 days before an election and remove the ability of four or more Board members, or the mayor, to place measures on the ballot without a Board vote. If voters approve it, the route Proposition B took, a majority of the Board, would remain; the others would change. This timeline describes the rules as they stood in mid-November 2026.

What to check, if you want to follow the next one

A short routine works for any charter amendment:

  1. Search the Legislative Research Center for the word "charter" or for the sponsor.
  2. Read the text with its markup. The struck and underlined words are the amendment.
  3. Watch the Board vote, since the placement vote is where supervisors state their reasons on the record. How to follow the Board of Supervisors from home explains how.
  4. Read the voter pamphlet for the digest, the controller's statement and both sides' arguments.
  5. Check the declared results in the Board's resolution after certification.

For the reference record on the department that runs all of this, see San Francisco Department of Elections. The city's register to vote page links the pamphlet and the department's other resources.

Related city government

Related guides

Latest on this topic