Blog
The Budget and Appropriations Committee
How the Board of Supervisors' budget committee meets, what the Budget and Legislative Analyst does, when the public can speak, and how cuts and add-backs work.
For roughly six months of the year, the busiest room in City Hall is the one where the Board of Supervisors' budget committee sits. Department heads file in one after another to say what they want to spend. An analyst the supervisors hired reads out what could be trimmed. Supervisors ask why a program costs what it costs, and residents line up at the microphone. When the last gavel falls, a mayor's proposal has been reshaped into the budget the full Board votes on.
The body is the Budget and Appropriations Committee. It is easy to overlook in the list of committees, and it may be the most consequential one the Board has.
Two committees, one calendar
The Board of Supervisors' committees meet on a regular schedule, posted on the city's meeting page. Two of them are about money:
- Budget and Finance meets on Wednesdays at 10 a.m. It is the year-round committee for contracts, grants, bond measures and other financial legislation.
- Budget and Appropriations meets on Wednesdays at 1:30 p.m. from February 1 to August 1. This is the budget season committee. While it is in session, it is where the annual or two-year budget gets its hearings.
The Board's other regular committees are Government Audit and Oversight (first and third Thursdays at 10 a.m.), Land Use and Transportation (Mondays at 1:30 p.m.), Public Safety and Neighborhood Services (second and fourth Thursdays at 10 a.m.) and Rules (Mondays at 10 a.m.). The full Board meets on Tuesdays at 2 p.m. (How to follow the Board of Supervisors from home).
The Board's president picks the committee chair. During the 2026 budget season, the Budget Chair was Supervisor Connie Chan, who said she planned to step down from the chair in August 2026, after that year's process ended. That is how the city's budget page describes the chair; the Board's committee page lists who holds the post now. The Board's president as of 2026 is Supervisor Rafael Mandelman (Board of Supervisors).
Where the committee sits in the year
San Francisco's budget runs on a two-year cycle, with the fiscal year from July 1 to June 30. The committee is one step in a sequence (The San Francisco budget year in twelve months):
- December. The Five-Year Financial Plan and the mayor's budget instructions go to departments (The Five-Year Financial Plan and the structural deficit).
- By February 21. Departments submit proposed budgets after hearings before their own commissions.
- May 1 and June 1. The mayor proposes the budget for some departments by May 1, and for all departments by June 1.
- June. The Board's Budget and Legislative Analyst reviews the mayor's proposal, and the Budget and Appropriations Committee takes it up, starting in the second week of June.
- Public Comment Day. In 2026 the committee held its public comment day on June 24.
- By August 1. The committee reports the budget to the full Board, which has to approve it by August 1, and the mayor signs it.
The city's budget page said the committee's public discussions in 2026 were scheduled to begin in May, and it posted a Budget Hearing Calendar for fiscal years 2026-27 and 2027-28 along with a schedule of department budget meetings. Start there if you want to know when a particular department appears.
The analyst who does the arithmetic
The committee's most important staff member is not an elected official. The Budget and Legislative Analyst is the Board's independent analyst. The office reads the mayor's proposal line by line and hands the supervisors a list of recommended cuts, such as positions that have sat vacant for a long time or contracts that look duplicative. The analyst's review takes about two weeks and concentrates on what changed from the previous year.
The analyst's reports do double duty. They are public documents, posted on the Board's budget pages. In May 2026, for example, the Board's analyst published reports on housing financial incentives and on citywide debt capacity. When someone says "the budget analyst recommended $X in cuts," they are citing a document anyone can read.
The analyst also signs the March Joint Report on the city's five-year outlook, together with the mayor's budget director and the Controller (Controller's Office). Three offices, one forecast, and a committee that has to turn it into a budget.
Cuts and add-backs
How does a mayor's proposal become the Board's budget? Mostly by subtraction first and addition second.
In June, the committee works through the analyst's recommended reductions. Supervisors adopt many of them. The money freed up is then on the table, and committee members use it to add back funding for programs they want to protect, often services that matter to individual districts. By the end of June the committee has a package of reductions and add-backs, which goes to the full Board for a vote.
A simple hypothetical, labeled as such: say the mayor proposes $100 million for a department. The analyst recommends $4 million in cuts, such as positions that have been vacant for a year. The committee adopts $3.5 million of them. Then the committee restores $1.5 million for a community program the department had proposed to eliminate. The department's budget ends at $98 million, and the $2 million of net savings becomes part of the General Fund's balance to be spent elsewhere or held. Some version of that arithmetic runs through hundreds of lines.
The Budget Chair's own recommendations in 2026 show what priorities look like in practice. According to the city's budget page, the chair's list included eliminating vacant management positions before further workforce reductions, prioritizing services and contracts that receive federal and state grants and maximizing reimbursement, reviewing and consolidating grant contracts of $1 million or less, reducing administrative costs such as unused cell phone lines, leases and equipment contracts, continuing to invest in oversight bodies such as commissions, inspectors general, Controller auditors and whistleblower investigators, and prioritizing shovel-ready capital projects before launching new ones.
Who gets a hearing
Not every part of city government runs on the same schedule. The Municipal Transportation Agency, the Public Utilities Commission, the Airport and the Port have fixed two-year budgets, with only small changes in the off year; other departments follow a rolling cycle, so a full process runs every year. In 2026, the Budget Chair said the committee's review would include enterprise departments that earn their own revenue, such as the Airport, the SFPUC and the SFMTA (San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency, San Francisco Public Utilities Commission).
The calendar is built around department presentations. A department comes before the committee with its proposed budget, answers questions, and listens to the analyst's list. The Budget Chair's introduction to the 2026 process called the budget about $16 billion and a "statement of values."
What the committee cannot change
A budget committee never starts with a blank page. Large parts of the budget are settled before the first hearing, and the March Joint Report shows how. The Charter sets baselines, minimum spending levels for services such as the Municipal Transportation Agency, the Library and the Public Education Enrichment Fund, and most baselines rise with the city's aggregate discretionary revenue. Salaries and benefits follow labor contracts and pension and health costs, which the report projects year by year. Debt service, state and federal requirements and the General Reserve deposits add to the commitments.
That explains why the committee's fights are so often over a small slice of the total. The budget is about $16 billion in all, but the room to decide, the money not already committed by charter, contract or law, is far smaller. A reduction of a few million dollars is a big event for a committee looking for savings at the margin, and an add-back of a few hundred thousand dollars for a community program can be the difference between a service continuing or not (The Five-Year Financial Plan and the structural deficit).
Enterprise departments such as the Airport, the Public Utilities Commission and the Municipal Transportation Agency raise most of their own money through fares, fees and rates rather than the General Fund. Their inclusion in the 2026 review, which the Budget Chair announced, meant the committee looked at their budgets alongside the General Fund departments.
How the public takes part
This is the committee where members of the public have the most direct say, because there is a day set aside for it. The city's budget page for FY 2026-27 posted a Public Comment Day for June 24, 2026, with details in a linked PDF. The page also gave an email address for written comments to the committee, with a subject line identifying the budget the comment concerns. The same page lists the mayor's proposed budget documents, the March outlook, the Controller's nine-month status report and the schedule of department budget meetings.
If you want to speak:
- Check the day and time for the department or topic you care about, using the hearing calendar and the Public Comment Day notice.
- Prepare a short statement. Speaking time at a public hearing is limited, so a specific request that names the item works better than a general speech.
- Send written comments too. A letter can carry data and detail that will not fit in a short statement.
- Watch the vote. The committee's final action is a committee vote on the budget package, then a vote at the full Board.
Full Board meetings are broadcast on SFGovTV, and agendas and minutes are posted by the Clerk of the Board (Clerk of the Board of Supervisors).
What came out of the 2026 round
The 2026 budget cycle ended with the Board passing the budget unanimously. The mayor signed a $16.9 billion budget for fiscal year 2026-27, which the mayor's office said closed a $642 million two-year deficit while strengthening the social safety net. The city's budget book lists $17.2 billion for fiscal year 2027-28.
Then the cycle starts over. The committee's budget season opens on February 1, the mayor's proposal arrives by June 1 and the Board has to approve a budget by August 1. Anyone who wants to follow along can watch the Board's budget pages for the next calendar, or read the March Joint Report and the December outlook as an early signal of how big the gap will be.