Blog
The downtown office market and the budget
What the 2026-27 budget book says about office vacancy above 30 percent, falling commercial values, appeals reserves and a transfer tax that is recovering.
Look up from Market Street and downtown still looks like downtown. The Salesforce Tower still rises 1,070 feet over the Transbay Transit Center, and the Financial District still has its skyline. A city budget does not look up. It counts square feet that are leased or empty, values the Assessor-Recorder carries on the roll and what a building fetches when it sells. The mayor's proposed budget for fiscal years 2026-27 and 2027-28 describes the office market in several places, never dramatically, always in the flat language of revenue forecasts, and read together the passages tell one consistent story about what remote and hybrid work did to downtown and how the city's taxes have absorbed it. This case study follows that story through the budget book in the order the money moves: the vacancy, the values, the appeals, the sales and the taxes that hang on each.
The vacancy
The plainest statement sits in the budget's discussion of sales tax. The forecast has sales tax revenue flat in 2026-27, growing modestly in 2027-28 and reaching pre-pandemic levels in 2028-29. The reasons for the caution are spelled out: population is still below its pre-pandemic level, office vacancy rates remain above 30 percent with fewer employees going into the offices that are occupied, and tourism and business travel have not yet recovered. The budget expects all of it to improve over the coming years.
That sentence is an official statement about the downtown office market. A vacancy rate above 30 percent means that of every ten square feet of office space, more than three are unleased. "Fewer employees going into the offices that are occupied" adds a second effect: even the leased floors are used less, which thins the foot traffic that keeps lunch counters, shops and transit going. Sales tax is a local gauge of that effect, since it follows spending in the city.
The values
An empty building is worth less, and over time the Assessor-Recorder's roll shows it. The budget book says commercial property valuations continue to fluctuate, driven by high vacancy rates in middle-tier office properties and by interest costs that remain well above recent norms. Property tax revenue follows. The General Fund's share of property tax is budgeted at $2,407.0 million in 2026-27, which is $30.0 million, or 1.2 percent, less than in 2025-26, and at $2,427.0 million in 2027-28.
The dip is small in percentage terms because the roll rests on Proposition 13 base values, which grow by up to 2.0 percent a year until a property is reassessed. The budget assumes secured roll growth of 2.0 percent in each year, the maximum the state constitution allows, so most of the roll keeps growing. The squeeze comes from the commercial side, where recent sales and market values for office properties sit below their existing assessed values. Lower sale prices reset assessed values downward, and that limits near-term growth in the commercial property tax base. The Assessor-Recorder's narrative in the budget book reports that the city's assessment roll rose 1.9 percent to $357.8 billion in the most recent year, supporting about $4.2 billion in property tax revenue, so the roll as a whole is still growing even as the commercial segment weakens.
The appeals
Owners whose property values have dropped can ask for a lower assessment, and the city sets money aside for the refunds. The budget assumes $2.5 billion of reductions in current-year local assessment values in each of the two budget years, which works out to roughly $14.0 million in General Fund property tax refunds each year. It also assumes reserve deposits for future refunds of $215.0 million in General Fund revenue from appeals filed in 2026-27 and $191.0 million from appeals filed in 2027-28, to be paid when the Assessment Appeals Board decides on reductions. The Assessor-Recorder's office reported a backlog of more than 14,000 open reassessments at the start of the fiscal year, along with historically high assessment appeals tied to adjustments in the real estate market. The Assessor and assessment appeals explains how the appeals process works from an owner's side.
The reserve is prudence in dollar form. If the appeals succeed in the amounts the city fears, the money is there to pay them. If they do not, the reserve can be released later. Either way, a reserve in the hundreds of millions of dollars shows how seriously the budget treats the office market as a risk.
The sales
The transfer tax, which the city levies when buildings sell, is the revenue line most visibly tied to downtown deals, and it is the budget's good news. The city budgeted $358.8 million for 2026-27, $91.2 million, or 34.1 percent, more than the year before, and $370.4 million for 2027-28. The budget's explanation is that after pandemic-era changes drove the revenue to historic lows, it rebounded on lower interest rates and a reset in which building owners accepted losses on buildings bought before the pandemic and came back to the market. Office transaction volumes are improving and institutional investors are reengaging, according to the budget.
A hypothetical sale shows the logic. Suppose an office tower was assessed at $400 million on the roll and sells for $250 million. The sale produces transfer tax revenue right away, at the rates for a property over $25 million, and it signals a refund claim and a lower assessment, which cuts property tax for years. At a 6 percent rate on $250 million, the transfer tax would be $15 million, and the reassessment from $400 million to about $250 million would reduce the annual tax at 1.18162182 percent by about $1.77 million ($150,000,000 × 0.0118162182 = $1,772,432). The numbers are invented and the real calculation depends on the rate schedule and the base value, but they show why the budget describes recent sale prices as tending to fall below existing assessed values, and why a recovery in sales is welcome and complicated at once. the real property transfer tax and the budget covers the tax itself.
The taxes that bridge the gap
The city does not lean on offices alone. The forecast calls business tax a bright spot in the revenue outlook, with growth largely reflecting revenue growth in the technology and professional services sectors, as well as administrative changes from Proposition M of 2024. The budget projects business tax revenue of $1,572.2 million in 2026-27, up 38.0 percent from the prior year's budget, partly from a one-time shift in timing. tech as the city's revenue engine looks at that line. The hotel tax is budgeted to rise to $289.4 million on the rebound in Moscone Center events, as The hotel tax and the Moscone Center describes.
The tax forecast, in the budget's own phrasing, assumes that the commercial real estate sector continues its recovery and office value reset during the budget period, which is why it pairs a lowered property tax forecast with growing transfer tax forecasts. The shape of the revenue picture is that of a city adjusting to a lower value for its offices instead of waiting for the old value to come back.
What the budget does in response
The budget does not wait for the office market to recover. It closes the gap partly with spending choices that have nothing to do with downtown, such as eliminating more than 550 vacant positions, and partly with one-time money. It allocates $505.0 million of General Fund year-end fund balance across the two budget years and withdraws $191.1 million from reserves, among them $84.9 million from the Federal and State Revenue Risk Reserve, $54.8 million from the Budget Stabilization One Time Reserve and $29.5 million from the Business Tax Stabilization Reserve. The March 2026 Joint Report had projected deficits of $168.5 million in 2026-27 and $474.3 million in 2027-28, with larger ones in the years after, and how the two-year budget closed a $642 million gap explains how the package closed the two-year gap.
Look at what is missing from that list. The budget does not assume offices refill on a schedule, and it does not count on a sudden rise in downtown property values. It treats the commercial real estate recovery as gradual and the office value reset as continuing. A budget built on the opposite assumption would book more property tax and hold fewer reserves. The choice is how the budget builds caution into a forecast that depends on a market it cannot control.
Two views of the same numbers
The figures support more than one reading, and each is held seriously.
One view says the reset is healthy and nearly done. Sales are happening, investors are returning and the transfer tax is rebounding. On that reading, a lower assessed value for older office buildings is a correction that lets the market clear, and the city's revenues will adjust upward as the market recovers. The business tax's strong growth in technology and professional services suggests the downtown economy is producing revenue even where it is not producing the same occupancy.
The other view says the strain is not over. Vacancy above 30 percent, with fewer workers coming in, is a structural change in how offices are used, and the budget's own wording points to a reset that runs through the budget period. On that reading, the risk lies in assessment appeals not yet decided, in the transfer tax's dependence on a handful of large sales and in the lingering effect on sales tax and transit ridership. The budget's decision to hold a reserve against refunds, and its warning that a disturbance in a relatively small number of transactions could derail the recovery, fit this view.
The budget book does not settle the argument, and neither does a single year's data. What it shows is the city's finance officers planning for both, with a forecast that assumes recovery and reserves that protect against its failure.
How a resident can follow it
A resident who wants to track the story has several public tools. The Board of Supervisors' Budget and Appropriations Committee holds hearings on the budget every spring, and the Controller publishes revenue reports during the year. The Assessor-Recorder publishes the assessment roll each July, and the 2026-2027 roll was released on July 17, 2026. The Assessment Appeals Board meets Monday through Friday, and its hearing schedule is public. The Treasurer and Tax Collector publishes tax information, and How to read the San Francisco budget book shows how to find the revenue pages in the budget book itself.
Where the neighborhoods come in
The effects are most visible where offices cluster. The Financial District and South of Market hold much of the office stock, and The Financial District and Montgomery Street describes the district's history. Foot traffic, transit ridership and the vitality of storefronts all depend on office occupancy, which is why vacancy in the towers turns up in retail on the ground floor. vacant storefronts and the commercial rents tax looks at the storefront side.
What to watch
Three numbers tell the story each year: the vacancy rate the budget cites, the volume and prices of the large sales that feed the transfer tax and the size of the assessment appeals reserve. The Controller's office, which reports on the city's finances, and the Assessor-Recorder publish the data, and Controller's Office and San Francisco Office of the Assessor-Recorder describe those offices. The mayor's budget materials are at sf.gov. These forecasts are projections, and the budget itself notes that a disturbance in a small number of large transactions could derail the recovery.