Blog

Labor contracts and the budget

The $379.5 million rise in San Francisco's labor costs in 2026-27, what drives it, how it compares with the March forecast and the 27 union contracts ahead.

Ask what the biggest line in the San Francisco budget is and the answer is not a program. It is people. The mayor's proposed budget for fiscal years 2026-27 and 2027-28 carries salaries and benefits for 32,756 employees, and what they cost is the single biggest reason city spending climbs year after year. That makes the labor contracts, the agreements bargained with the unions that represent most city workers, among the weightiest documents at City Hall, even though hardly any resident has ever read one. Here is what the budget book says about labor costs, why they are rising, how the proposal differs from the forecast that came before it and what bargaining lies ahead. The numbers are reported in neutral terms, and the piece takes no side at the table.

The headline numbers

The budget book's section on personnel expenses is short and specific. The proposed budget includes an increase in total labor costs of $379.5 million, or 5.2 percent, in fiscal year 2026-27, and a further increase of $363.7 million, or 4.7 percent, in fiscal year 2027-28. That total covers every fund in the city. The slice that falls on the General Fund, the flexible money that taxes pay for, is smaller. General Fund labor costs rise by $182.2 million, or 5.3 percent, in 2026-27, and by a further $107.1 million, or 3.0 percent, in 2027-28.

The gap between the totals and the General Fund figures comes from how the city is built. Much of the workforce is paid from other funds. Enterprise departments such as the airport, the transit agency, the port and the Public Utilities Commission pay their employees out of their own revenue, and some programs run on grants. A $379.5 million increase in all labor costs is therefore bigger than the General Fund's share, and both matter, since the enterprise departments raise rates and fares to cover their costs.

What drives the increase

The budget book names two drivers. In both years, the change comes from cost-of-living adjustments to wages for all city employees and from increases in employee benefit costs. Staffing reductions in the mayor's proposed budget offset part of it.

Those reductions show up elsewhere in the book. The two-year budget eliminated more than 550 vacant positions, the budget says, while protecting frontline service delivery. A vacant position has nobody in it, so cutting it saves its budgeted cost without ending anyone's job, but it also removes capacity a department might have used. the city as the largest employer describes the workforce those positions belong to.

Benefits run beyond wages. The Health Service System administers medical, dental, vision and voluntary benefits for the employees and retirees of the city, the San Francisco Unified School District, City College of San Francisco and the Superior Court, and the budget book reports 138,440 enrolled members. The pension system is a separate entity. The San Francisco Employees' Retirement System reports that it is 96.6 percent funded based on the actuarial value of assets as of July 1, 2025. A well-funded plan, the budget book says, supports the long-term financial health of the city. Neither figure is a labor cost increase on its own, but both sit behind the benefit costs the personnel section mentions.

The forecast and the proposal

The sharpest comparison in the section is against the forecast that came first. In March 2026 the Joint Report, produced by the Mayor's Budget Office, the Board of Supervisors' Budget and Legislative Analyst and the Controller, projected a General Fund labor cost increase of $528.5 million over the two years. The proposed budget's cumulative General Fund increase is $289.3 million, which is $239.2 million lower.

The arithmetic checks out from the pieces: $182.2 million plus $107.1 million is $289.3 million, and $528.5 million minus $289.3 million is $239.2 million. The distance between projection and proposal is the room the mayor's budget found, and the book credits the combination of wage and benefit assumptions and the staffing reductions. A forecast is a projection of costs if nothing changes. A proposed budget is the set of changes that decides what the costs will be. The Joint Report also projected deficits of $168.5 million in 2026-27 and $474.3 million in 2027-28, and how the two-year budget closed a $642 million gap describes how the package closed the gap.

What a labor contract is

A labor contract in city government is a memorandum of understanding between the city and a union that represents a class of employees. It sets the wages, the schedule of raises, the benefits the city pays and the terms of work. The Department of Human Resources negotiates for the city. Agreements go to the Board of Supervisors for approval, which is how the contracts get into the budget, and the Controller reviews the cost. Controller's Office explains the Controller's role in costing agreements.

The budget book gives the scale of the bargaining ahead. The Department of Human Resources is preparing to negotiate successor agreements with 27 labor unions representing more than 85 percent of city employees. Successor agreements are the contracts that follow the current ones as they expire, so the number tells a reader that most of the workforce is about to be at the table in the same stretch of time. The budget book calls labor negotiations a significant responsibility of the department.

Neutral reading of the stakes

Each party at the table has a coherent position, and each bears on the numbers above.

  • City management has to balance pay against a budget under pressure. The March Joint Report projected deficits growing to $741.7 million in 2028-29 and $1,088.6 million in 2029-30, and the proposed budget reduced the five-year structural deficit by approximately $300 million. Management wants labor costs kept within what revenue can support.
  • Unions represent employees who face the city's high cost of living and who point to the work the city asks of them, such as running a transit system and two public hospitals. They want wages and benefits that keep pace with prices and staffing levels that keep the work manageable.
  • Residents are served by the departments and pay for them through taxes and fares. They want services that work and costs that can be sustained.

Those interests overlap more than they collide, and the contract is where they are reconciled. A budget that cuts positions to hold down costs can lower service levels, and a contract that raises wages and benefits can shrink the money left for positions. How to read the San Francisco budget book shows where to find the personnel numbers.

Labor against the rest of the General Fund

Labor is not the only General Fund cost on the rise. The budget book's next paragraph sets the personnel increase beside what it calls non-personnel expenses: professional services, materials and supplies, grants, capital projects and equipment, facilities maintenance, debt service, services of other departments and contributions to reserves. General Fund non-personnel spending rises by $220.4 million, or 9.3 percent, to $2.58 billion in 2026-27, and by a further $112.5 million, or 4.4 percent, to $2.69 billion in 2027-28. Capital spending drives the 2026-27 jump, and cost-of-doing-business adjustments to community-based organization grants and inflationary increases drive 2027-28.

Side by side, the two categories give a rough sense of proportion. In 2026-27 the General Fund's labor increase is $182.2 million and its non-personnel increase is $220.4 million. In 2027-28 the labor increase falls to $107.1 million and the non-personnel increase to $112.5 million. Labor is not the only reason spending rises, and the proposed budget holds down its own growth by eliminating vacant positions rather than by cutting wage rates. Transfers out of the General Fund add another $174.0 million in 2026-27 and $95.0 million in 2027-28, mostly to cover spending mandates voters have passed and support for hospitals and other funds.

The General Fund is 45.1 percent of the total budget in 2026-27 and 45.9 percent in 2027-28. A large share of its spending is locked in by voter-approved baselines for children's services, libraries, transit, recreation and parks and other programs, so the money managers can freely redirect is smaller than the total suggests. That is why labor cost, the largest controllable item, draws so much attention in any budget year.

The bargaining cycle in outline

A bargaining cycle follows a recognizable sequence, though the details differ by union and year. The Department of Human Resources prepares proposals with the Mayor's Office and the Controller's cost estimates. The city and each union trade proposals and sit down at the table. When the parties reach a tentative agreement, union members vote on ratifying it, and the agreement goes to the Board of Supervisors for approval. Once approved, the costs are built into the budget through the Controller's and the Mayor's Budget Office's estimates, which is why the March Joint Report matters: it projects what existing agreements will cost and what a settlement might add.

When many contracts are bargained at once, as the budget book says is coming, the effect on the budget is bigger than any single settlement. The city's financial planners have to estimate several outcomes at the same time, and the five-year financial plan carries those assumptions. A resident following the budget can watch for tentative agreements in the news and for the Board's votes on them, which are public and appear on the Board's agendas, as How to follow the Board of Supervisors from home explains.

A hypothetical illustration

To see how a percentage becomes money, take a hypothetical department with a payroll of $100 million in salaries and benefits. A 5.2 percent increase in labor costs, the citywide figure for 2026-27, adds $5.2 million, bringing the total to $105.2 million. A further 4.7 percent the next year adds $4.94 million, for $110.14 million. If the department eliminated vacant positions worth $2 million in budgeted cost, the net increase over the first year would be $3.2 million, not $5.2 million. The department is invented, but the arithmetic is the one the budget applies on a larger scale: the increase from wages and benefits, minus the savings from fewer positions.

What to watch

Watch the successor agreements, which will come to the Board of Supervisors, the Controller's cost estimates and the General Fund labor line in the next budget. The Department of Human Resources and the Board's Budget and Appropriations Committee do the work, and The Budget and Appropriations Committee describes how the committee reviews the budget. The city's budget materials are at sf.gov. This post reports published budget figures and does not forecast any negotiation.

Related city government

Related guides

Latest on this topic