Blog
The Peace Pagoda and Peace Plaza in Japantown
The five-tiered Peace Pagoda, a 1968 gift from Osaka, and the plaza that sits in the Japan Center built where redevelopment replaced Japantown's old core.
In the middle of Japantown, between Post and Geary Streets at Buchanan, a five-tiered pagoda of concrete and copper climbs out of a plaza of steps and fountains. It looks as if it has been there forever, and it has not. The Peace Pagoda was dedicated in 1968, a gift from the city of Osaka, and it stands on ground the city's redevelopment agency cleared in the 1960s. Pagoda and plaza together are a token of friendship between two cities and, at the same moment, a marker of what was lost when the neighborhood's historic core was rebuilt.
What follows is a profile of the pagoda and the plaza, of the Japan Center around them and of the neighborhood's history, with a note at the end on how to visit.
The pagoda
The Peace Pagoda stands at the southwestern corner of Peace Plaza, between the Japan Center Mall and the Nihonmachi Mall. It is a five-tiered concrete stupa, 100 feet tall. Twelve reinforced concrete pillars, each 65 feet tall, hold up five copper-clad conical roofs that shrink in diameter from 46 feet to 34 feet. At the top is a finial with a nine-ringed bronze element, a golden flame and a ball.
The architect was Yoshiro Taniguchi, a modernist from Japan. He chose a circular roof, inspired by an eighth-century Japanese Buddhist relic, over a traditional wooden design with square or octagonal roofs. A replica of a traditional pagoda would have looked wrong in the modernist Japan Center, and the circular form suits the buildings around it. The total cost was $185,000, and T.Y. Lin served as the structural consultant.
The people of Osaka, the city's sister city since 1957, presented the pagoda to San Francisco. It was dedicated on March 28, 1968, the same day as the Japan Center, with a separate dedication of the pagoda later that year. Corporate interests financed the Japan Center, but the pagoda was funded mainly by contributions from Osaka. It was meant as a symbol of Japanese-American friendship, in the manner of peace pagodas elsewhere, monuments that aim to inspire world peace.
Peace Plaza
The plaza around the pagoda measures 160 by 197 feet. Eight steps lead up to the pagoda, and other features include a waterfall wall and an eternal flame. The plaza has had a complicated maintenance history:
- 1990. The reflecting pools were drained because of leaks into the garage below.
- 1995. The Board of Supervisors allocated $600,000 for the plaza's renovation.
- 2001. The Department of Public Works completed a redesign.
- 2005. A nine-foot monument honoring Japanese Americans was added.
The plaza is public space. Public Works, whose role is described in San Francisco Public Works, redesigned it in 2001, and the Recreation and Park Department, covered in San Francisco Recreation and Park Department, joined the plaza's fiftieth anniversary events in 2018. During the COVID-19 pandemic the Japanese Cultural and Community Center of Northern California organized socially distanced outdoor seating in the plaza, which shows how the space works as the neighborhood's living room.
The neighborhood
Japantown covers about six city blocks in the Western Addition and is often described as one of the oldest ethnic enclaves in the United States. Post Street is its main thoroughfare, running between Fillmore Street and Laguna Street. The area is generally bordered by Bush or Pine Street on the north and Geary Boulevard on the south, in ZIP 94115. The city's neighborhood summaries give its Muni lines as the 38 Geary and the 22 Fillmore.
The community's history comes in chapters.
Before 1906. San Francisco had two Japantowns, one near Chinatown and one in the South of Market area. After the April 18, 1906 earthquake and fire, Japanese immigrants moved to the Western Addition, which became the main Japantown. By 1940 the district held more than 5,000 ethnic Japanese residents and more than 200 Japanese-owned businesses.
1942. Executive Order 9066 forced Japanese Americans from the Pacific coast into incarceration. Many of the vacated homes in the area were later filled by African Americans who came to the city for wartime industrial jobs. Executive Order 9066 and Japantown tells the story of the removal.
1950s and 1960s. Redevelopment in the Western Addition, led by the San Francisco Redevelopment Agency, razed existing housing and widened roads. The planning department's own studies say redevelopment displaced about 10,000 residents in the Fillmore area, and the Japantown core gave way to the Japan Center. The Fillmore redevelopment case and The Fillmore and Japantown: two histories describe the project and its consequences for both communities.
1968. The Japan Center opened, with the pagoda and plaza at its heart. It is the neighborhood's focal point, a complex of three Japanese-oriented shopping centers around the plaza.
So the pagoda's story is tied up in a contested history. The monument was a gift of friendship from a sister city, and its setting came out of a redevelopment plan whose effects residents of the neighborhood still talk about. A visitor who reads the plaza only as a pleasant public space misses half of what it means.
The Japan Center around the plaza
The Japan Center is the complex around the plaza, and it opened in 1968. It consists of three Japanese-oriented shopping centers, with the pagoda between the Japan Center Mall and the Nihonmachi Mall. It is the neighborhood's focal point and the reason visitors come. Its design belongs to the same era as the redevelopment that produced it: a modernist superblock, with a garage under the plaza, replacing the older street grid of houses and shops. The garage explains the plaza's maintenance history, since the 1990 leaks from the reflecting pools into the parking structure below got the pools drained.
The redevelopment itself was led by the San Francisco Redevelopment Agency, under its director M. Justin Herman, and it razed existing housing and widened transportation corridors from the 1960s through the 1980s. The Japanese American population, already thinned by the 1942 removal, was reduced further. The neighborhood's resident population is small today, with a count from the 2010s listing 1,397 people, and its businesses and cultural groups have kept the community's institutions alive.
A timeline of the site
| Year | Event |
|---|---|
| 1906 | After the earthquake, Japanese immigrants move to the Western Addition, which becomes the main Japantown |
| 1940 | The district holds over 5,000 ethnic Japanese residents and more than 200 Japanese-owned businesses |
| 1942 | Executive Order 9066 leads to the forced removal of people of Japanese ancestry |
| 1957 | San Francisco and Osaka become sister cities |
| 1960s | Redevelopment clears the historic core |
| March 28, 1968 | The Japan Center is dedicated, with the Peace Pagoda presented by Osaka |
| September 15, 1968 | A separate pagoda dedication |
| 1990 | The plaza's reflecting pools are drained |
| 2001 | Public Works completes a redesign of the plaza |
| 2005 | A nine-foot monument honoring Japanese Americans is added |
| 2018 | The plaza's fiftieth anniversary is celebrated |
Festivals
Japantown's calendar hangs on two festivals described in the city's neighborhood literature.
- Northern California Cherry Blossom Festival. Held over two weekends every April, with a queen program and a Sunday parade.
- Nihonmachi Street Fair. Held for one weekend in August.
Festivals like these need street closures, which run through the city's permit process, as How a street fair or block party gets permitted in San Francisco explains. They are community events, and the organizers announce the dates, so a visitor planning around one should check its own website. The Fillmore and Japantown: two histories places the festivals in the neighborhood's longer story.
Visiting
The pagoda and plaza are open public spaces. Practical notes:
- Getting there. The 38 Geary runs along Geary Boulevard at the plaza's southern edge, and the 22 Fillmore serves the area. How to ride Muni covers fares.
- What to see. The pagoda itself, the steps and waterfall wall, the eternal flame and the monument added in 2005. The malls around the plaza are the neighborhood's shopping and dining center.
- Combine it. Japantown is a short ride from the Civic Center, Hayes Valley and the Fillmore. A walk around Civic Center and Hayes Valley between Alamo Square and Civic Center describe neighbors, and Japantown and Western Addition and the Fillmore give the neighborhoods' own profiles.
- Respect the space. The plaza is a gathering place and, for some families, a place of memory.
- Mind the date. The pagoda was dedicated on March 28, 1968, and the Japan Center celebrated its fiftieth anniversary in 2018, an event organized by the Japantown Merchants' Association, the Japan Center malls and the Recreation and Park Department.
What the monument means
San Francisco's Peace Pagoda is a work of modern architecture, a diplomatic gift, a public plaza and a reminder of redevelopment, all in one structure. Its form was chosen for a modernist setting, and its funding came from a city across the Pacific. The neighborhood around it is smaller than it was in 1940, and it has a core of businesses, cultural institutions and festivals that has endured.
For a resident or a visitor, the pagoda is a place to stand and think about how a city rebuilds, who pays for it and who gets to decide. The concrete roofs are modern, and the friendship they celebrate began in 1957 when San Francisco and Osaka became sister cities. The neighborhood's story, with its losses and its endurance, runs longer than either.