Blog
Hayes Valley between Alamo Square and Civic Center
Hayes Valley from farms to the Central Freeway to Octavia Boulevard and Patricia's Green, with its Victorian streets, jazz hall and the Muni 5 and 6.
Stand on Octavia Boulevard and look up. Where the sky opens over the plane trees, a concrete deck used to hang over the street, and the neighborhood lived in its shadow. Hayes Valley is a place that exists where a freeway used to be. Until 1989, an elevated freeway ran through it, over the streets and between the neighborhood and the rest of the Western Addition. After the Loma Prieta earthquake damaged the structure, the city closed it, and local activism helped keep it from being rebuilt. What replaced it was a boulevard, a park and a rebuilt neighborhood that now draws visitors who have never heard of the freeway.
It is a small place: a few blocks of shops, restaurants and houses between Alamo Square on the west and Civic Center on the east, in the northern part of the Western Addition. Its boundaries are loosely defined, and sources differ on exactly where it begins and ends (Hayes Valley).
The name
Hayes Street is named for Thomas Hayes, a former San Francisco county clerk and early landowner. The neighborhood takes its name from the street. The street runs west from Civic Center toward Alamo Square, and the shops along it, near where Octavia Boulevard crosses, are what most people mean when they say "Hayes Valley."
Before the city: Ohlone and farms
The Ohlone people gathered food in this area before Spanish colonization in 1776. After the 1849 Gold Rush, Italian farmers worked produce farms here, supplying a growing city, on land well west of the downtown.
By the 1870s, the cable car had arrived in the Western Addition, and the area became a Victorian streetcar suburb (Western Addition and the Fillmore). Row after row of Victorian houses went up on the blocks around Hayes Street and Alamo Square. When the 1906 earthquake and fire came, the part of Hayes Valley south of McAllister Street was spared the fires that followed, and so were many of the Western Addition's Victorian buildings (the 1906 earthquake and fire).
The freeway and the vote
The Central Freeway was an elevated roadway of roughly one mile, connecting US 101 and Interstate 80 with Hayes Valley. It grew out of a 1948 transportation plan that proposed a loop of freeways around downtown. The first segment, from the Bayshore to Mission Street, opened in 1955, and the extension to Golden Gate Avenue and Turk Street opened in 1959. That was also the year the Board of Supervisors, in one of the city's "freeway revolts," removed the rest of the planned Central Freeway and most other proposed freeways from the city's plan (The Embarcadero Freeway, 1968 to 1991).
The 1989 Loma Prieta earthquake damaged the northern section. In 1992 the state's transportation department, Caltrans, removed the freeway north of Fell Street, and the upper deck north of Mission Street was taken down in 1996. What to do next became one of the city's longest arguments. Residents of the Richmond and Sunset districts, who used the freeway to reach downtown and valued business access, favored rebuilding it. Hayes Valley residents saw the freeway as blight, and they had the backing of the mayor of the day. The question went to the voters several times: Proposition H in 1997 called for rebuilding the freeway, Proposition E in 1998 supported a boulevard, and in 1999 Proposition I, the boulevard, won 54 percent to 46 percent while Proposition J, the freeway, failed.
The lower deck reopened as far as Fell Street in 1997 but was removed in 2003. A two-way freeway was brought down to ground level at Market Street, and Octavia Boulevard, a surface boulevard, opened on September 9, 2005. It is four blocks long, from Market to Fell Street. Outer roadways serve the homes and businesses beside it, and inner lanes connect to the rebuilt freeway spur. It links to Fell, Oak, Franklin and Gough Streets, and north of Hayes Street it continues as Octavia Street, which runs through the Western Addition, Pacific Heights and the Marina to Bay Street at Fort Mason. The name honors Octavia Gough, the sister of a contractor who served on a commission that designed Western Addition streets.
A committee led by the city's Planning Department recommended the boulevard, and Caltrans found its traffic capacity acceptable (San Francisco Planning). At the boulevard's northern end is Patricia's Green, a park between Fell and Hayes Streets, named for the community activist Patricia Walkup, who died in 2006.
Not all of the cleared land became boulevard. The ramp lots and vacant parcels left by the demolition became sites for housing and other uses. In 2010, Hayes Valley Farm was established on former freeway land as an urban permaculture project, a temporary garden that ran from 2010 to 2013 on land waiting for development. Part of the site was later redeveloped for housing, and an apartment complex now stands there.
What is in the neighborhood now
A walk along Hayes Street from Franklin to Laguna passes the neighborhood's mix.
Shops and restaurants. Hayes Street's storefronts are filled with independent boutiques, cafes and restaurants. The neighborhood's reputation for shopping and dining comes from the way small storefronts line a few walkable blocks. As elsewhere, individual businesses open and close, so the best guide to the current ones is the street itself.
Victorian houses. The side streets have Victorian and Edwardian houses and flats, many of them divided into apartments. They belong to the same architectural generation as the famous houses on Steiner Street.
Public housing. Public housing sits among the Victorians. The mixture of housing types is part of the neighborhood's character, and it is one of the things that sets Hayes Valley apart from nearby districts that are more uniformly high-income.
SFJAZZ Center. The SFJAZZ Center opened in early 2013 as a jazz concert hall. It continues a jazz tradition associated with the Fillmore, a few blocks west (The Fillmore and Japantown: two histories).
Patricia's Green. The green at the end of Octavia Boulevard is the neighborhood's front lawn: a small park with benches, paths and open space in the middle of a dense urban neighborhood. The Recreation and Park Department runs the city's parks (San Francisco Recreation and Park Department).
Alamo Square
At the western end of the neighborhood, Alamo Square Park is a four-block hilltop park overlooking downtown. It is bordered by Hayes, Steiner, Fulton and Scott Streets. The name refers to a lone cottonwood, an álamo, at a watering hole on a horse trail between Mission Dolores and the Presidio in the 1800s. Mayor James Van Ness created the park in 1856. The Recreation and Park Department operates it, and it is open daily from 5 a.m. to midnight, with a playground and a tennis court.
The row of Victorian houses on Steiner Street facing the park, often called the Painted Ladies, is one of the best-known postcard images of San Francisco, usually shown with the downtown skyline behind it. The Alamo Square neighborhood has Victorian architecture that was largely untouched by urban renewal, which is why the area looks as it does.
The label "Cerebral Valley"
In the early 2020s the neighborhood picked up a new nickname. "Cerebral Valley" describes the concentration of generative artificial intelligence communities, startups and "hacker houses" that grew up in and around Hayes Valley. It is a recent layer, and a good example of how the neighborhood's identity keeps changing: it has been a place of Ohlone food gathering, Italian farms, a Victorian streetcar suburb, a freeway corridor, a rebuilt boulevard neighborhood and, now, a tech cluster.
The freeway is not entirely gone
What remains of the Central Freeway is a short elevated spur south of Market Street, carrying US 101 traffic toward Mission Street and the Golden Gate Bridge. In 2022 a state senator asked Caltrans to study demolishing it and other nearby elevated freeways, which shows that the argument the voters settled for Hayes Valley in 1999 has not ended for the stretch that remains. The boulevard is the evidence that a city can choose to take a freeway down, and the remaining structure is the reminder that the choice is never made just once.
The seasons on Hayes Street
The NOAA normals for the downtown station give the pattern for the neighborhood: average highs of about 58 degrees in January and about 70 in September, the warmest month, with the dry season running from June through September and the wet season from roughly November through April. A stroll along the boulevard is easy in any of them, though the park fills on sunny afternoons.
Getting there
Several Muni bus lines serve Hayes Valley. The 5 Fulton and the 6 Hayes/Parnassus run through the neighborhood, and the Van Ness Avenue and Civic Center stations are close (How to ride Muni). Civic Center is a short walk east, and Alamo Square a short walk west. The ZIP code is 94102.
A good short walk:
- Start at Civic Center and walk west on Hayes Street.
- Cross Octavia Boulevard at Patricia's Green.
- Continue west along Hayes Street's shops to Alamo Square.
- Climb the park and look east, down Hayes Street, toward downtown.
- Return by the 5 Fulton or 6 Hayes/Parnassus bus, or on foot.
Reading the neighborhood
Hayes Valley is a case where the physical changes can be read in the streets. Where Octavia Boulevard runs, the freeway ran. The vacant lots next to it became housing, and the park at its end was named for an activist. The surrounding blocks of Victorian houses are the same ones that stood there before the freeway and survived it.
For the neighborhood's context, read about the districts around it: Civic Center to the east (A walk around Civic Center) and the Western Addition, with the Fillmore and Japantown, to the northwest.