Blog

The Fillmore and Japantown: two histories

How Japantown and the Fillmore grew, were reshaped by the 1942 removal and by redevelopment, and what each neighborhood keeps today.

Two neighborhoods share a few blocks of the Western Addition, and neither history can be told without the other. Japantown, about six blocks of shops, restaurants and community institutions around Post Street, was the center of a Japanese American community in San Francisco. The Fillmore, along Fillmore Street to the south and west, was the center of Black life and music in the city. In 1942 the first was emptied by government order. In the years after, the second filled with new residents. Then redevelopment cut both apart.

What follows is how that happened, as the city's planning record has it, and what each neighborhood is now. The dates are close together, a decade or two apart at most, which is part of what makes the story hard to hold in one piece: a family could be taken from Post Street in 1942, a different family could settle into the same flat within a few years, and by the late 1950s the block itself could be marked for clearance. Keep that overlap in mind and the rest follows in order.

The Western Addition

"Western Addition" means two things. Today it names a west-central neighborhood, often treated as another word for the Fillmore District. Historically it was a far broader area platted in the 1850s, about 500 blocks, and the name comes from the Van Ness Ordinance tract, which ran west from Larkin Street to Divisadero Street and "built out" the city westward.

After the cable car arrived in the 1870s, the area turned into a Victorian streetcar suburb. It came through the 1906 earthquake with its buildings largely intact, which is why so many Victorian houses still stand there (Western Addition and the Fillmore).

Japantown before 1942

Before 1906 San Francisco had two Japantowns. After the earthquake and fire, the Western Addition became the main one. By 1940 the ethnic Japanese population of San Francisco exceeded 5,000, and the community supported more than 200 Japanese-owned businesses. The Japanese YWCA, known as the Issei Women's Building, was founded in 1912 and still stands at 1830 Sutter Street. The Bush Street-Cottage Row Historic District is both a San Francisco Designated Landmark and a National Register listing.

Japantown is small: about six city blocks, Post Street its main thoroughfare, running from Fillmore Street to Laguna Street and bordered on the south by Geary Boulevard. It is described as one of the oldest ethnic enclaves in the United States (Japantown).

1942: Executive Order 9066

On February 19, 1942, the president signed Executive Order 9066, which led to the forced removal and incarceration of people of Japanese ancestry from the West Coast (Executive Order 9066 and Japantown). San Francisco's Japanese American residents were taken from their homes and businesses. The neighborhood emptied.

On the Fillmore the effect ran the other way. Between 1940 and 1950, San Francisco's Black population grew from 4,836 to 43,460. Wartime jobs drew new residents, and housing in the Western Addition, vacated by the removal of Japanese Americans, was there to be had. African Americans moved into the blocks around Fillmore Street, and the area became a population base and cultural center for the city's Black community.

One movement of people ties the two stories together: the homes Japanese American families left behind became homes for the new arrivals.

The Fillmore: "the Harlem of the West"

In the 1940s and 1950s the Fillmore carried a reputation as the "Harlem of the West." Its clubs presented jazz and rhythm and blues, and the performers who played the district included Louis Armstrong, John Coltrane, Ella Fitzgerald, Billie Holiday and Charlie Parker. Jimbo's Bop City was a notable nightclub.

In the 1960s the Fillmore Auditorium, at Geary and Fillmore, became a major concert venue in the psychedelic music scene and hosted early concerts by Jefferson Airplane and the Grateful Dead (The Summer of Love, 1967). The city's Black population peaked at about 13 percent in the 1970s.

Redevelopment

In August 1948 the Board of Supervisors designated the 108-acre Western Addition Project Area A-1 for redevelopment. That was the start of the urban renewal that many residents lived through as the removal of their neighborhood.

The San Francisco Redevelopment Agency acquired the land through eminent domain beginning in the late 1950s. The Area A-1 project, from 1956 to 1973, centered on the Japantown side. It covered 28 blocks, displaced about 8,000 people and destroyed about 6,000 low-rent housing units. A second project, Area A-2, began in 1966 and ran to the end of the 1970s, spanning about 70 blocks and displacing up to 13,500 residents. City planning documents on Japantown put the number of residents displaced by the redevelopment at about 10,000; the figures vary with which project areas and years are counted (The Fillmore redevelopment case).

M. Justin Herman, the redevelopment agency's director, led it. The Japanese Cultural and Trade Center was his first major project as director. Construction began in 1965, and the center opened in March 1968. Many of the Fillmore's buildings were demolished, along with the businesses in them. The agency issued Certificates of Preference to displaced businesses, giving them a priority claim to return. As of 2001, only 4 percent of the certificates had been redeemed.

Japan Center and the Peace Pagoda

Japan Center came out of that project. It covers 5 acres and had a construction budget of $15 million. The architect Minoru Yamasaki created the site's architecture, and the interiors of the malls were designed by Takenaka & Associates of Osaka. It has three mall buildings, west to east: the Kinokuniya Mall, the Kintetsu Mall, now called Japan Center West, and the Miyako Mall, now Japan Center East. The site is bounded by Geary Boulevard on the south, Post Street on the north, Fillmore Street on the west and Laguna Street on the east.

The five-tiered concrete Peace Pagoda was designed by Yoshiro Taniguchi and presented to San Francisco by the people of Osaka. It stands in Peace Plaza, which Taniguchi also designed. A renovation plan for the plaza was approved in 2023, and construction began in 2024 (The Peace Pagoda and Peace Plaza in Japantown).

Osaka was San Francisco's sister city from 1957. One block of Buchanan Street was renamed Osaka Way in 2007. Osaka ended the relationship in 2018.

The Fillmore after redevelopment

In the 1990s the Redevelopment Agency created the Fillmore's Jazz Preservation District, meant to recall the neighborhood's music history. The Fillmore Heritage Center housed a jazz club that closed in 2014. The district has gone on changing, and gentrification has been significant since the early 1990s. The stretch of the Central Freeway that ran through the neighborhood to Turk Street closed right after the 1989 Loma Prieta earthquake and was later demolished (Hayes Valley between Alamo Square and Civic Center).

A timeline

Year Event
1850s The Western Addition is platted, about 500 blocks
1870s The cable car arrives and the area becomes a Victorian streetcar suburb
1906 The earthquake and fire spare the Western Addition's buildings; it becomes the main Japantown
1912 The Japanese YWCA, the Issei Women's Building, is founded
1942 Executive Order 9066 leads to the removal of Japanese Americans
1940-1950 The city's Black population grows from 4,836 to 43,460
1948 The 108-acre Area A-1 is designated for redevelopment
1956-1973 The A-1 project, centered on the Japantown side
1966 The A-2 project begins, ending at the close of the 1970s
March 1968 The Japanese Cultural and Trade Center opens
1989 The Loma Prieta earthquake damages the Central Freeway
2024 Construction begins on the Peace Plaza renovation

Smaller losses and changes

Redevelopment is the biggest part of the story but not the only one. The Japantown Bowl opened in 1976 and closed in September 2000, and its lot is now mixed-use housing. Cherry blossom trees planted in 1994 were vandalized in January 2021. During the COVID-19 pandemic, the Japanese Cultural and Community Center of Northern California organized socially distanced outdoor seating in Peace Plaza. When a neighborhood is small and its institutions few, changes like these are the ones that show up in its record.

The police department's Northern Station serves Japantown and the Fillmore. The city's Planning Department has published a cultural history and economic sustainability strategy for Japantown, gathering the neighborhood's history and the policy ideas that follow from it; it is the best single document for anyone who wants to read further (San Francisco Planning).

What each neighborhood keeps

Japantown has events that carry the community's traditions forward: the Northern California Cherry Blossom Festival, which runs two weekends each April, and the Nihonmachi Street Fair, one weekend in August. The Japanese Cultural and Community Center of Northern California organizes community activities. The Japanese YWCA building and Cottage Row are surviving prewar sites.

The Fillmore is in transition. Muni bus lines 22, 21, 24, 38, 31, 43, 47, 49 and 5 serve it, and Fillmore Street is the main north-south thoroughfare. The Fillmore Auditorium is at Geary and Fillmore.

What the record asks of a visitor

None of this is abstract. The residents who were displaced and the businesses that held Certificates of Preference were real people and real storefronts, and a visitor to Japantown or the Fillmore can learn the story from the sites themselves and from the city's planning documents.

The plain approach is the best one. Walk Post Street and Fillmore Street, look at the dates on the buildings, read what the plaques say and take note of what is missing. For transit, the 22 Fillmore and 38 Geary both serve Japantown (How to ride Muni).

Related city government

Related guides

Related neighborhoods

Latest on this topic