Blog

The Fillmore redevelopment case

What the Redevelopment Agency cleared in the Western Addition from 1956 to the 1970s, who was displaced, and what supporters and critics argued.

Hardly any chapter of San Francisco's postwar history gets argued over as steadily as the redevelopment of the Western Addition. Supporters called it a campaign against slum conditions. Many of the people who lived there called it something else, and their phrase, "Negro Removal," survives in the city's memory as shorthand for what happened to the Fillmore. The record is long enough to give both sides a fair hearing, and the numbers are specific enough to hold on to.

The Fillmore before the bulldozers

By the 1940s the Fillmore was a crowded, mixed district at the center of the Western Addition. The neighborhood had been rebuilt after the 1906 earthquake and held a large stock of old Victorian flats, many cut up into apartments. Japanese Americans had made the northern blocks their Japantown. Then World War II changed the district's makeup. Shipyard and war-industry jobs drew Black workers to the Bay Area, and after the removal of Japanese Americans in 1942 (Executive Order 9066 and Japantown) many homes and storefronts stood empty and filled with new arrivals. San Francisco's African American population rose from 4,836 in 1940 to 43,460 in 1950, from half a percent of the city to 4.5 percent.

The Fillmore of those years was known as the "Harlem of the West." Its clubs on Fillmore Street and along Post and Geary drew jazz musicians and their audiences into the 1950s, and Jimbo's Bop City, which operated from around 1950 to 1965, was among the best known. It was also, by the standards of the time, an overcrowded, aging neighborhood with many deteriorated buildings. That second fact is what made the district a target.

What urban renewal was, and why San Francisco used it

Redevelopment in the 1950s was a federal and state program. Under the Housing Act of 1949, cities could designate "blighted" areas, acquire the land (by eminent domain where needed), clear it and resell it to developers who agreed to build to an approved plan. San Francisco's Redevelopment Agency ran projects in several parts of the city, and the Western Addition became its largest.

Supporters laid out the reasoning like this. Large parts of the district had substandard housing, with poor sanitation, overcrowding and structures that would not meet modern codes. Individual owners, the argument went, had little reason to fix up properties one at a time in a neighborhood of failing buildings. Only a comprehensive, publicly financed project, they said, could break the cycle: clear whole blocks, rebuild streets, supply new housing and public facilities and bring in private investment. The Agency's leaders also argued that new housing and a new commercial center would give the area a future.

Two projects, 1956 to the late 1970s

The work was split into two project areas.

A-1 A-2
Years 1956 to 1973 Begun 1966, through the end of the 1970s
Size 28 city blocks About 70 blocks
People displaced About 8,000 Up to 13,500 residents, 4,522 households
Low-rent units removed About 6,000 About 5,000
Centerpiece The Japanese Cultural and Trade Center (the Japan Center, opened 1968) New housing, institutions and street changes across the Fillmore

A-1 centered on the Japantown side of the district. Its showpiece was the Japan Center, whose three shopping centers opened in 1968, with the Peace Pagoda and Peace Plaza as landmarks (The Peace Pagoda and Peace Plaza in Japantown). A-2 reached farther south and west into the heart of the Fillmore. Different sources total the displaced population differently, which is why accounts run from about 10,000 residents to figures above 20,000 when both projects are counted. The project-level figures in the table are the most useful, because they come with a block count and a time frame.

Behind the numbers sits a physical change. Blocks of old Victorian flats and the commercial strips that served them were demolished. In their place went new apartment buildings, public housing, institutional buildings and wider streets. The layout of the cleared blocks and the widened transportation corridors reshaped how the neighborhood fit together, and whole stretches of Fillmore Street changed character.

How a project area worked

The mechanics explain why residents had so little say. A redevelopment project moved through a fixed sequence.

  1. Designation. The city and the Agency declared an area blighted, which opened the door to federal and state funds.
  2. A plan. The Agency adopted a redevelopment plan setting out land uses, street changes and the kinds of buildings that could go up, parcel by parcel.
  3. Acquisition. The Agency bought the properties it needed, or took them by eminent domain, paying owners an appraised price. Tenants, who were the majority in the Fillmore, did not own and received relocation assistance instead.
  4. Relocation and demolition. Occupants were moved out and the structures cleared, often block by block as the work advanced.
  5. Resale. The cleared land was sold, usually at a reduced price, to developers committed to build what the plan required.

Because the plan fixed the uses in advance, a household that wanted to stay in the neighborhood had to wait for the new buildings and hope to qualify for them. The Certificates of Preference were meant to bridge that wait, and it is the step critics say failed most plainly.

What the displaced lost

The housing numbers tell part of the story. The families displaced were mostly renters, and many were low-income. The new housing built in the project areas was generally not priced for them. The Agency was required to help relocate residents, and it issued Certificates of Preference, meant to give displaced households and businesses a priority when new housing or commercial space came available. In practice the certificates were hard to use. As of 2001, only 4 percent of the certificates issued to businesses forced out by the Agency had been redeemed. For a business displaced in the 1960s, a priority right that matured decades later did little to keep it alive.

The losses were cultural, too. The jazz clubs closed, a long list of Black-owned businesses and churches lost their buildings and members, and the people who had given the Fillmore its character scattered across the city, across the bay and into other cities.

Residents did not stand by. A group called the Western Addition Community Organization, known by its initials WACO, organized against the A-2 project and pressed for a voice in what would be built. Opposition of that kind, in San Francisco and in other cities, is part of why urban renewal drew much closer scrutiny as the 1960s went on. The phrase "Negro Removal" became widespread among the displaced residents themselves, and it describes what the program looked like from the neighborhood's side of the fence.

The case for the program, and its limits

A fair account includes the supporters' arguments, a few of which have survived scrutiny better than others.

  • Housing conditions were poor. Overcrowding and deteriorated buildings were real, and some parts of the area did need rebuilding or major repair.
  • Federal money was available, and private capital was not. Without the program, supporters said, the district would have gone on declining.
  • New institutions and housing were built. The Japan Center, new apartment buildings and public facilities exist because the Agency assembled the land.

The criticisms are specific too.

  • Clearance was too broad. Whole neighborhoods were removed when selective rehabilitation might have saved much of the housing and the businesses.
  • Relocation did not work. Households were moved, and certificates that promised a way back were redeemed at low rates.
  • The costs fell on one community. The loss of homes and businesses landed hardest on Black and Japanese American residents, who had little say in the plans.

Neither list settles it, because the two sides are describing different things: one measures what was built, the other what was lost. Both can be seen on the ground in the Western Addition today.

The long afterlife

The Redevelopment Agency's role ended in 2012, when California dissolved redevelopment agencies statewide. Before that, in the 1990s, the city's agency created the Historic Fillmore Jazz Preservation District, an attempt to restore some of the area's identity. The most ambitious effort was the Fillmore Heritage Center, a development of apartments and commercial space that housed the San Francisco branch of the jazz club Yoshi's. Yoshi's closed in 2014 and was replaced by a venue called The Addition, which closed on January 14, 2015. The failure of those businesses is part of why people still argue about what kind of development can bring the old Fillmore back.

The story keeps its force because the disputes it raised are still current. Debates over how to protect long-time residents, how to design affordable housing that serves those displaced and how to preserve a cultural district all draw on the Fillmore's example. The city's Planning Department now surveys historic and cultural districts as part of its work (San Francisco Planning), and the rent rules that protect existing tenants were built over the decades after urban renewal (Renters' rights and rent control in San Francisco). For the neighborhoods themselves, see Western Addition and the Fillmore and Japantown, and for the walk, The Fillmore and Japantown: two histories.

A note on how to read the numbers

Because the figures in this story are quoted so often, it is worth saying how they fit together. The block counts and the displacement totals are project figures, and they describe the two Western Addition projects, not the whole city's redevelopment record. The 4 percent figure for the certificates describes businesses, not households. The population statistics for the war years describe the whole city, not the Fillmore alone. Taken within those limits, the numbers support a plain conclusion: the redevelopment of the Western Addition removed thousands of people and thousands of low-rent homes over roughly two decades, and the system meant to bring them back worked for very few.

Related city government

Related guides

Related neighborhoods

Latest on this topic