Blog

Executive Order 9066 and Japantown

The 1942 removal of San Francisco's Japanese Americans, from Bush Street to Tanforan and Topaz, and what happened to the emptied Post Street district.

In 1940, the blocks around Post Street in the Western Addition were home to more than 5,000 people of Japanese ancestry and more than 200 Japanese-owned businesses. Two years later almost all of them were gone. The shops had been sold off or shuttered, the churches and language schools stood empty, and the people who had run them were living in horse stalls at a racetrack south of the city. The order that did it was short, and it did not mention Japanese Americans at all.

The order

On February 19, 1942, President Franklin D. Roosevelt signed Executive Order 9066. It gave the Secretary of War and his military commanders the authority to designate military areas and to exclude "any and all persons" from them. Nothing in its text named an ethnic group. In practice it was aimed at people of Japanese ancestry on the West Coast, citizens and non-citizens alike, and it became the legal basis for the removal of roughly 120,000 people over the following months.

The Army's Western Defense Command, headquartered at the Presidio of San Francisco, did the work. Its commander, Lieutenant General John L. DeWitt, signed 108 Civilian Exclusion Orders and related directives there, one for each district to be cleared (The Presidio, from army post to national park site). A first proclamation on March 29, 1942 had already begun restricting movement and imposing the kind of notice that left families almost no time to prepare.

San Francisco fell in Military Area No. 1, and its Japanese residents were covered by Civilian Exclusion Order No. 20. Notices went up on telephone poles and storefronts. Families were told when to report, what they could carry, and where to go. They had days, not weeks, to deal with houses, leases, cars, inventory, pets and the contents of a lifetime.

From Bush Street to Tanforan

The procedure in San Francisco was bureaucratic and fast. Residents reported to a Civil Control Station at 2031 Bush Street, only a few blocks from Post Street, to register. Each family was given a number. The first group of 3,112 people bound for the Tanforan assembly center left the city in a caravan of buses around April 28, 1942.

Tanforan was a racetrack in San Bruno, just south of the city. It was converted into a holding camp in a matter of weeks, and families were housed in stables that had been whitewashed for the purpose. It operated from April 28 to October 13, 1942, and its population peaked at 7,816 people, most of them from the San Francisco Bay Area. In all, 8,033 Americans of Japanese ancestry passed through it, and 64 percent of them were United States citizens.

Tanforan was never meant to last. The War Relocation Authority was building ten camps in remote parts of the interior, and the people of Tanforan were sent on to them. About 98 percent of the 7,824 who were transferred went to the camp at Topaz, in the Utah desert, where many San Franciscans spent the war. The Civil Control Station on Bush Street and the racetrack in San Bruno belong to the same story as the empty storefronts on Post Street: a neighborhood was erased in a few weeks, and it was done by paperwork.

The words used at the time

The vocabulary of the period was official and soft. The Army spoke of "evacuation," of "assembly centers" and "relocation centers," and of residents being "relocated" for their own protection and for the war effort. Those terms appear on the notices, in the newspapers and in the agency records, and they are still the names of the camps in the archives. Many historians and community organizations now prefer plainer words: removal, forced removal and incarceration, because the people involved were held behind fences and guards and could not leave. When San Franciscans read the older documents, it helps to read the euphemism and the reality side by side. Tanforan was an assembly center on paper and a converted stable in fact.

What happened to the street

When the Japanese residents left, their property did not go with them. Owners sold what they could at once, often at a large loss, or left it with neighbors or churches. Businesses that had taken decades to build closed. Houses, stores and community halls stood vacant, and the Western Addition changed quickly.

War industries were pulling workers to the Bay Area, and the shipyards in particular drew tens of thousands of new residents. Many of the Black workers who arrived in San Francisco during the war found housing in the Western Addition and the Fillmore, in the buildings the Japanese American community had left. San Francisco's African American population rose from 4,836 in 1940 to 43,460 in 1950, and the wartime Fillmore became a center of Black life and, in the 1940s and 1950s, jazz. By 1943 many sections of the old Japanese district were vacant or had been taken over by new tenants.

Seen from the street, the district's changes ran in the opposite direction from its earlier ones. After the 1906 earthquake, Japanese immigrants had moved to the Western Addition, which became the city's main Japantown. After 1942, the Western Addition was rebuilt around a different community, and the Japanese Americans who returned came back to a neighborhood that no longer waited for them.

The return

Japanese Americans began returning to San Francisco after the exclusion orders were lifted, and some resumed their old trades. Many did not come back; they resettled elsewhere in the country, or on the East Coast, or found that their old homes and shops were gone. The returning residents found the Fillmore transformed, and they found something else coming. The city's Redevelopment Agency had identified the Western Addition for clearance.

The first major project, called A-1, ran from 1956 to 1973 and was centered on the Japantown side of the district. It covered 28 city blocks, displaced about 8,000 people and removed roughly 6,000 low-rent housing units. Its centerpiece was a new Japanese Cultural and Trade Center. The second project, A-2, began in 1966 and ran through the end of the 1970s across about 70 blocks. The two together are treated in detail in The Fillmore redevelopment case, where the arguments for and against urban renewal are laid out. For the Japanese American community the practical result was a second displacement, a generation after the first.

The Japan Center opened in 1968. Its three Japanese-oriented shopping centers, the Peace Plaza and the five-tiered concrete Peace Pagoda, designed by Yoshiro Taniguchi and given by the people of Osaka, are the most recognizable physical results of that redevelopment (The Peace Pagoda and Peace Plaza in Japantown). The Japan Center, in other words, was built on land cleared by the same agency whose work had removed housing from the area, and the community's relationship to it has long been complicated. Many Japanese Americans in San Francisco regard the center as an anchor; others point to what had to be cleared for it.

Japantown today

Today Japantown is about six city blocks in the Western Addition, with Post Street as its main thoroughfare, running from Fillmore Street to Laguna Street. The Japanese name for the neighborhood, Nihonmachi, appears in the Nihonmachi Street Fair, held one weekend each August, and the Northern California Cherry Blossom Festival fills two weekends every April with a parade and the Queen Program at the Kabuki Theatre. The Vollmer House at 1735 to 1737 Webster Street, built between 1876 and 1885, is a California Historical Landmark and survives from the earlier Western Addition. The district is one of the oldest Japanese enclaves in the country, and in a city where neighborhoods change quickly it has stayed in the same place since the early twentieth century, apart from the gap of 1942 (Japantown; Japantown's food and the Japan Center).

For the Fillmore side of the story, including the jazz clubs of the 1940s and 1950s and what became of them, see Western Addition and the Fillmore and The Fillmore and Japantown: two histories.

How the city remembers it

San Francisco has marked the removal in several ways. Interpretive displays in Japantown trace the community's history. The National Park Service, which manages the Presidio, has published material on the executive order and on the role the Presidio played as the command post for the exclusion program. Each February 19, observed in the Japanese American community as the Day of Remembrance, the date of the order is marked with programs and talks.

Japantown's history also frames the city's later arguments about neighborhood planning. When residents and planners discuss how to protect small businesses, how to prevent displacement in the Western Addition or how to treat a historic cultural district, the records of 1942 and of the redevelopment years are the starting point. The city's Planning Department has surveyed the district and published context statements for it, and the history of the removal is part of the record on which those documents rely (San Francisco Planning).

Reading the record

A few points are worth keeping straight, because the story is often compressed.

  • The order did not name Japanese Americans. Executive Order 9066 authorized military commanders to exclude people from areas; the exclusion orders that followed applied to people of Japanese ancestry.
  • Most of the people removed were Americans. At Tanforan, 64 percent of those held were United States citizens.
  • San Francisco was cleared in stages, quickly. Registration at Bush Street, a bus caravan around April 28, 1942, a few months at Tanforan, then Topaz.
  • The same blocks were cleared twice. The first removal was a military order; the second, beginning in 1956, was a municipal redevelopment program.
  • The neighborhood did not disappear. It survives as six blocks on Post Street, anchored by the Japan Center, the Peace Pagoda and the festivals that fill the calendar.

A visitor who walks Post Street from Fillmore to Laguna crosses the whole district in a few minutes. The Peace Pagoda marks the middle of the walk. Standing there, it is worth remembering that in the spring of 1942 the same few blocks were registered, numbered and emptied.

Related city government

Related guides

Related neighborhoods

Latest on this topic