Blog

The Assessor and assessment appeals

How San Francisco assesses property, what the annual notice means, the three appeal windows and how the Assessment Appeals Board hearings work.

Property tax is the one tax in San Francisco that residents can argue about after the fact, and the arguing happens in two rooms: the Assessor-Recorder's office, which sets the value, and the Assessment Appeals Board, which hears disputes over it. What follows, in question-and-answer form, is how the machinery works, when each door is open, and why it matters more to the city budget than to most individual homeowners.

Who decides what a property is worth for tax purposes?

The Assessor-Recorder, an elected citywide officer with an office in City Hall, Room 190. The office's stated mission is to fairly and accurately identify and assess all taxable property. The same office records deeds, marriage records and other documents, which is where the double-barreled title comes from. Its main line is 628-652-8100, and it takes email at [email protected].

The tax is not figured from today's market value. California's Proposition 13 pins the assessed value at what the property was worth when it last changed hands or was last newly built, and lets it grow by an inflation factor that cannot top 2 percent a year. The city's budget assumes the secured roll grows by exactly that maximum, 2.0 percent, in each of the next two fiscal years. The upshot is that two neighboring houses of the same size can carry very different assessments, depending on when each was last sold.

What triggers a new assessment?

A change in ownership or the completion of new construction. The Assessor-Recorder's office spells out both: all properties must be reassessed when ownership changes, though certain exclusions can apply, and the office reviews Department of Building Inspection permits to decide whether a construction project adds assessable value or is excluded. The exclusions the office lists include certain transfers between parents and children, earthquake retrofits and accessibility improvements, and Proposition 19 changed some of the tax benefits for families, seniors, severely disabled persons and victims of natural disasters. Each has its own eligibility rules and claim deadlines, set out on the Assessor-Recorder's pages.

When an event changes the value mid-year, the result is a supplemental assessment: a bill for the difference between the old and new values for the rest of the tax year. An escape assessment is the mirror image, catching a full year's increase in assessed value up to four years after the event that should have triggered it. The budget counts on about $12.0 million in supplemental property taxes and $25.0 million in escape assessments each year, which tells you how much money moves through these channels.

What is the annual notice?

Every year the Assessor-Recorder mails an Annual Notice of Assessed Value. It is an information letter, not a bill. It states the taxable assessed value the office has put on the property for the coming fiscal year. The office also publishes the roll itself: the 2026-2027 Property Information and Assessment Roll was released on July 17, 2026. The October tax bill is then worked out from the value on the roll. An owner who reads the notice and finds a number that does not match the facts of the property, such as a wrong square footage or a prior sale recorded in error, has two options depending on the timing, and the windows are firm.

When can an owner challenge a value?

There are two main channels.

  1. Informal decline-in-value review, January 2 to March 31. Single-family homeowners can ask the Assessor-Recorder's office to check whether the property's market value has dropped below its assessed value. This is a request to the Assessor-Recorder, not a hearing.
  2. Formal assessment appeal, July 2 to September 15. Any owner can file an assessment appeal with the Assessment Appeals Board during this window. For fiscal year 2026-27 the regular filing period ended on Tuesday, September 15, 2026, and applications had to be postmarked by that date. The Board states that it will not accept late applications.

A separate application covers supplemental, escape or roll correction appeals, for people who received a notice or tax bill of that kind and want to contest it.

The Board's address is City Hall, Room 405, 1 Dr. Carlton B. Goodlett Place, and it can be reached at 415-554-6778 or [email protected]. The filing fee and the current forms are on the Board's page at sf.gov.

How does the Assessment Appeals Board work?

The Board's job, in its own words, is to equalize the valuation of taxable property in the City and County, which in practice means settling disputes between the Assessor-Recorder's office and property owners. It is not part of the Assessor's office, and it does not set the tax rate.

The work is split among three boards, depending on the property. Board 1 hears appeals regardless of value, type or location. Board 2 hears property assessed at less than $50 million, excluding possessory interests, and property in two ranges of assessor's blocks, 1 to 876 and 3701 to 3899. Board 3 hears residential property of four units or fewer, along with property assessed under $50 million in the same block ranges. The Board meets Monday through Friday in two daily sessions, at 9:30 a.m. and 1:30 p.m., and the sessions run until the calendared items are done. In mid-November 2026 the Board was holding hearings on November 17 through 19, and the Board of Supervisors' meeting pages list the schedule.

An owner who files usually has to bring evidence of value, such as comparable sales, an appraisal or income and expense records for a rental building. The residential guidance the Board links to is the State Board of Equalization's Publication 30, which describes how to prepare an appeal for homes. The Board can lower the assessed value, leave it alone, or raise it. After a decision, the Assessor-Recorder revises the roll and the Treasurer and Tax Collector issues any refund.

Why does the whole process matter to the budget?

Because the volume of appeals is a big factor in the city's finances. The mayor's budget book for fiscal years 2026-27 and 2027-28 says the Assessor-Recorder is managing sustained reassessment activity and historically high assessment appeals driven by adjustments in the real estate market. The assessment roll rose 1.9 percent in the most recent year to $357.8 billion in assessed value after exemptions, supporting about $4.2 billion in property tax revenue. At the start of the fiscal year the office was working through a backlog of more than 14,000 open reassessments.

The budget treats appeals as a risk to be reserved against. It assumes $2.5 billion of reductions in local assessment values in each of the two budget years, which means roughly $14.0 million in General Fund property tax refunds each year, and it sets aside reserve deposits for future refunds of $215.0 million for appeals filed in 2026-27 and $191.0 million for those filed in 2027-28. The General Fund's property tax revenue for 2026-27 is budgeted at $2,407.0 million, $30.0 million or 1.2 percent lower than the year before. The budget's explanation is that high vacancy in middle-tier office properties and high interest costs are dragging down commercial values. Recent sale prices tend to come in below existing assessed values, which points to refunds on properties with open appeals and also resets assessed values downward, limiting near-term growth in the commercial property tax base.

For a single homeowner the picture is quieter. A home bought years ago is usually assessed well below market, and appealing the assessed value is not usually worth the trouble. Appeals matter after a recent purchase, after a drop in market value since the last sale, or when an assessment carries an error.

A hypothetical timeline

Take a hypothetical buyer who closes on a condominium in March. The Assessor-Recorder records the deed, treats the sale as a change in ownership and sets a new base value near the purchase price. A supplemental bill follows for the part of the tax year that remains after the sale, and the next fiscal year's October bill reflects the new value in full. Suppose the buyer paid $1,100,000 but later thinks the figure on the Annual Notice of Assessed Value is too high, or the market falls and comparable condominiums are now selling for $950,000.

The buyer's options follow the calendar. A single-family homeowner can ask for an informal decline-in-value review between January 2 and March 31. Any owner can file a formal appeal between July 2 and September 15. The informal request is a conversation with the Assessor-Recorder's office, not a hearing, which makes it the natural first step where it is available. The formal appeal takes an application, and the Board schedules a hearing at which the owner presents an opinion of value and the evidence for it. Because tax installments follow the published schedule, an owner with an appeal pending should confirm with the Treasurer and Tax Collector how payments work for that bill.

Who sits across the table

Each side of a hearing has a part to play. The Assessor-Recorder's office presents its valuation and the evidence behind it. The owner, or someone acting for the owner, presents the other side. The Board then decides whether the value on the roll is right. Its decision can leave the value alone, lower it or raise it, and the outcome is recorded on the roll.

Commercial owners go about it differently. An office building, a hotel or a shopping center can carry an assessed value in the hundreds of millions of dollars, and the evidence is leases, financial statements and expert reports. Properties assessed at $50 million or more go to Board 1, which hears appeals regardless of value, while smaller properties are spread among the other boards. Big commercial cases are the reason the budget reserves hundreds of millions of dollars for refunds. For the many owners with modest appeals, the process is closer to a conversation about comparable sales than to a trial.

Where to start

An owner with a question about a value should start with the Assessor-Recorder: San Francisco Office of the Assessor-Recorder describes the office. An owner with a question about the amount due or a penalty should start with the Treasurer, and Office of the Treasurer and Tax Collector explains that office. Reading a San Francisco property tax bill shows where the assessed value appears on the bill, December 10 and April 10: the property tax calendar shows when payments are due while an appeal is pending, and buying a home: property tax basics explains reassessment for a buyer. The Board of Supervisors' page lists the Assessment Appeals Board's meetings, and the official pages are at sf.gov.

This is general information about the process, not advice on whether to appeal. The taxes remain due on the published schedule while an appeal is pending, which is a point to confirm with the Treasurer's office for a specific bill.

Related city government

Related guides

Latest on this topic