Blog
Vacant storefronts and the commercial rents tax
How two taxes and a building-code registry shape San Francisco's empty storefronts, with the rates, exemptions and the arguments landlords and neighbors make.
Walk any commercial corridor in San Francisco and the state of the economy is written in the ground-floor windows: a shop with a new tenant, a storefront papered over with a "for lease" sign, a restaurant that closed a year ago. The city has answered with three separate tools, run by two departments, that all bear on what happens to an empty storefront. The commercial rents tax charges landlords a percentage of the rent they collect. The commercial vacancy tax charges owners and tenants for space that sits empty. The vacant storefront registry asks owners to tell the city when a space is vacant. They are easy to mix up and they work differently. This case study pulls them apart, sets out the rates and exemptions each carries and gives the arguments on each side without picking one.
Tool one: the commercial rents tax
The commercial rents tax falls on what a landlord takes in. The Treasurer and Tax Collector describes it as a tax on the amounts businesses receive from leasing or subleasing commercial space in San Francisco, where commercial space is any building or part of one that is not residential real estate. It is a gross receipts tax levied in addition to the regular gross receipts tax, and it generally does not apply to businesses that are exempt from that tax.
The rates are 1 percent on receipts from warehouse space and 3.5 percent on receipts from other commercial space. Space used for industrial purposes, for arts activities or for non-formula-retail sales and services is excluded, and so are rents that are subject to the hotel tax or the parking tax. A credit is available for child care facilities.
Proposition M, approved in November 2024, did not change the rates. It set the small business exemption for the tax at $2,325,000. The tax is filed with the annual business tax return, and estimated payments are due April 30, July 31 and October 31.
A hypothetical shows the effect. A landlord collecting $240,000 a year in rent from a storefront is below the $2,325,000 exemption and owes nothing under the tax. A landlord with $3,000,000 in rents from non-warehouse commercial space is above the exemption, and at 3.5 percent the tax is $3,000,000 × 0.035 = $105,000. If the same $3,000,000 came from warehouse space, the tax at 1 percent would be $30,000. The numbers are invented, and the way the exemption operates is described in the Treasurer's rules.
The tax has a purpose beyond revenue for the General Fund. The budget book says 15 percent of commercial rent tax collections authorized by Proposition C in June 2018 are transferred into the General Fund, and the Treasurer's pages refer to an Early Care and Education Commercial Rents Tax, which indicates that part of the tax pays for early childhood programs.
Tool two: the commercial vacancy tax
The vacancy tax aims at ground-floor space that sits unused for a long time. It applies to certain ground-floor commercial space kept vacant for more than 182 days in a tax year, consecutive or not, in named neighborhood commercial districts as they existed on March 3, 2020. Owners, tenants and subtenants must file every year, even if the space was occupied or qualifies for an exemption.
The rates are per linear foot of frontage, rounded to the nearest foot: $250 for one year of vacancy, $500 for two consecutive years and $1,000 for three or more consecutive years. A hypothetical storefront with 30 feet of frontage would owe $7,500 for a first year of vacancy ($250 × 30), $15,000 for a second consecutive year and $30,000 for a third.
The tax comes with exemptions and exclusions, and they decide how it works in practice:
- A tenant that operated for more than 182 consecutive days during a lease of at least two years is exempt for the rest of that lease.
- Organizations exempt under section 501(c)(3) of the federal tax code are exempt.
- Time spent on a building permit application, up to a year, on a one-year construction period after the first permit, on a 183-day conditional use application and on a two-year disaster recovery does not count as vacancy.
- A major infrastructure project exemption, effective January 1, 2025, applies to space where a city project lasts more than 180 days in the tax year.
- An affordable housing exemption, retroactive to January 1, 2022, applies to property under a recorded covenant enforced by the Mayor's Office of Housing and Community Development.
The return for tax year 2025 was due March 2, 2026, and a late return draws penalties and fees even if no tax is owed. the empty homes tax and the vacancy tax compares the vacancy tax with the residential tax that the courts have blocked.
Tool three: the vacant storefront registry
The registry is another mechanism entirely, run by the Department of Building Inspection under the Building Code and created by an ordinance that took effect in 2019. A ground-floor, street-facing commercial storefront counts as vacant or abandoned if it is unoccupied for more than 30 days, and the owner registers within 30 days of the vacancy and re-registers every year. Owners can register through sf.gov, and the registration is shared with the department for the registry. The registry carries a fee, and the sf.gov registration page gives the current amount.
Enforcement leans partly on owners reporting. In 2024 a proposal before the Building Inspection Commission to exempt storefronts vacant because of public infrastructure construction was rejected by the commission by a vote of 10 to 1. So the registry and the vacancy tax chase the same goal, information and incentive, from two directions. Department of Building Inspection and the Permit Center describes the department.
The arguments
The debate over these tools is a live one, and each side has a coherent case.
Neighbors and some businesses say long-vacant storefronts hurt the corridor. A dark window cuts foot traffic for the shop next door, and a block with several empty spaces can feel unsafe or in decline. They argue that some owners hold out for a higher rent rather than lease at a market rate, and that a tax rising with the length of vacancy gives owners a reason to lease sooner. The registry, on this view, tells the city and the public where the problem is.
Owners and some brokers say vacancy is rarely a choice. A space can sit empty because of permit delays, a stalled lease negotiation, a construction project outside the owner's control or a market in which few businesses want the space. They argue that a landlord losing rent already has every incentive to lease, that a tax adds to the cost for owners in trouble and that the filing requirement, which applies even to owners who owe nothing, is a burden. The exemptions for permit time, construction and infrastructure are the city's answer to part of this.
Tenants and small businesses see it their own way. High commercial rents can make a small business unviable, and the commercial rents tax falls on the landlord but may be reflected in the rent. A tenant who would fill a space may not be able to afford the asking rent, which brings the question back to rents and the broader cost of doing business. Starting a small business: First Year Free describes the city's steps to ease start-up costs.
Neither the tax nor the registry settles these questions by itself, and the city has revised the rules over time, as the infrastructure exemption added in 2025 shows.
How the three fit together: one invented storefront
Follow a single made-up storefront through a year to see how the tools interact. A 25-foot-wide ground-floor space on a neighborhood commercial street has been empty since the previous tenant left in February.
- March. After 30 days of vacancy, the owner registers the space with the Department of Building Inspection's vacant storefront registry and pays the registry fee. The registration is repeated each year while the space stays vacant.
- Through the year. The owner counts vacancy days toward the 182-day line for the vacancy tax. Days spent on a building permit application, up to a year, do not count, so if the owner applies for a permit to rebuild the interior in May, the clock may pause.
- The following March. The owner files the vacancy tax return even if the space was occupied part of the year, and pays tax if the vacancy exceeded the exclusions: at $250 per linear foot, a 25-foot frontage would owe $6,250 for one year of vacancy.
- Meanwhile. If a new tenant signs a lease and pays rent, the rents tax applies to the owner's receipts only if the owner's commercial rents are above the $2,325,000 exemption. A single-storefront owner is far below it.
The structure shows through. The registry is about information and runs on a 30-day clock. The vacancy tax is about the length of vacancy and runs on a 182-day clock with exclusions. The rents tax is about receipts and is aimed at larger landlords. A small owner with one space will usually meet the first two and not the third.
What data would answer the question
Both sides would be helped by the same information: how many storefronts are vacant, for how long and why. The registry exists to produce some of that, and the vacancy tax adds an annual filing that reveals the status of every taxable space. The sf.gov pages invite owners of vacant storefronts to register, which means the registry is only as useful as owners make it. A city that wants to know whether vacancy is rising or falling in a corridor needs both the registry and the tax returns, and the departments that run them, the Department of Building Inspection and the Treasurer and Tax Collector, share the information that the registration form provides. A neighborhood group that wants to track the question can start with the Treasurer's pages for the districts covered by the tax and the department's registry page for the process.
Where it shows up in the neighborhoods
Vacancy is local. A shopping street in the Mission District, the retail core around Union Square and the Columbus Avenue corridor in North Beach have different mixes of tenants, rents and foot traffic, and each knows its own kind of empty window. The districts that count for the vacancy tax are the neighborhood commercial districts defined as of March 3, 2020, and the Treasurer's map shows which areas apply. the downtown office market and the budget looks at the downtown side of commercial real estate, where the problem is empty offices rather than empty storefronts.
Where to start
An owner of a storefront should look at the Treasurer's pages for both the rents tax and the vacancy tax and at the Department of Building Inspection's registry page. A tenant should ask the landlord whether the space is registered and whether an exemption applies. Office of the Treasurer and Tax Collector describes the Treasurer's office, San Francisco Planning describes the zoning rules that decide what can open in a space and Starting a business in San Francisco explains how to open a business in one. The tax pages are at sftreasurer.org. This is general information about published rules, not tax or legal advice.