Blog
Muni passes versus pay-as-you-go: the arithmetic
Worked break-even math for the $86 M pass, the $104 A pass and the $5.70 day pass against $2.85 single rides, with a note on cable cars.
Thirty rides cost $85.50. The "M" pass costs $86. That fifty-cent gap, sitting right at the edge of an ordinary month, is the whole argument, and everything else below is a way of finding out which side of it a given rider lives on.
The fares are the ones posted in November 2026: $2.85 for an adult single ride paid by Clipper, a card tap or MuniMobile, $3.00 in cash, $5.70 for a day pass, $86 for the "M" monthly pass and $104 for the "A" monthly pass. The SFMTA posts them on its fare page. The rest is division, and the answer moves with how often a person climbs aboard. If the fares change, the last section shows how to redo the sums in about a minute.
Where the pass starts to win
An "M" pass costs $86 and covers all Muni service, cable cars included. A single ride paid with Clipper or a tap is $2.85. To find the tipping point, divide the pass price by the fare.
Eighty-six divided by 2.85 comes to 30.18. Thirty rides at $2.85 add up to $85.50, a dollar and a half short of the pass. Thirty-one rides come to $88.35, which is more than the pass. The pass begins to save money on the 31st ride of the month.
The rider who still pays cash, at $3.00 a ride, gets there faster. Eighty-six divided by 3.00 is 28.67, so the pass wins on the 29th cash ride. That is one more reason to move to Clipper, though the cash rider's arithmetic at least comes out in the pass's favor sooner.
Count rides, not boardings. A single fare is good for 120 minutes, so a trip that starts on a bus and carries on to a Metro train inside that window is one ride, not two. A commute with a transfer is still one ride each way.
The monthly ledger
Here is the cost of paying by the ride set against an "M" pass, for a range of monthly totals.
| Rides in a month | Pay by the ride at $2.85 | "M" pass | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| 10 | $28.50 | $86.00 | Pass costs $57.50 more |
| 20 | $57.00 | $86.00 | Pass costs $29.00 more |
| 30 | $85.50 | $86.00 | Pass costs $0.50 more |
| 31 | $88.35 | $86.00 | Pass saves $2.35 |
| 40 | $114.00 | $86.00 | Pass saves $28.00 |
| 60 | $171.00 | $86.00 | Pass saves $85.00 |
At 30 rides the two options are within fifty cents of each other. From 31 on, the pass pulls ahead by a widening margin. Someone who rides to work and back on 20 workdays makes 40 rides, and that puts the pass comfortably in front.
Who comes out ahead with a pass
Three kinds of riders do.
- The five-day commuter. Forty rides a month at $2.85 run $114.00. The pass saves $28.00 a month, or $336 over twelve months, since 28 times 12 is 336.
- The commuter with a weekend habit. Add one more round trip a week, say on a weekend, and the month grows by about eight rides, to 48 in all. By the ride that is $136.80, which is $50.80 more than the pass.
- The cable car regular. The "M" pass covers the cable cars, and a single cable car ride is $9.00. Take a month of 20 Muni rides and 4 cable car rides. The Muni rides cost $57.00, the cable car rides cost $36.00, and the total is $93.00, or $7.00 more than the pass.
That last case is the one that surprises people. A few cable car rides inflate a pay-as-you-go month much faster than a few bus rides do. A resident who takes the cable car to work, or a visitor staying several weeks, will find the pass cheaper at a lower count of rides (riding the cable cars).
Where paying by the ride is the better bet
The pass loses whenever the rider falls short of the break-even.
- The occasional rider. Ten Muni rides a month cost $28.50, a third of the pass.
- The rider who is away half the time. A pass is a fixed monthly cost, and a regular job does not guarantee 30 rides. Take someone who commutes three days a week, about 13 days in a month. That is 26 rides, which cost $74.10, and the pass would run $11.90 more.
- The rider who walks or bikes. In a neighborhood where most errands are on foot, as in many of the dense central districts, the rides simply do not pile up (Biking in San Francisco).
The best guide is a count of actual rides over a few months. Clipper keeps a history of trips, and a rider can look it over before deciding.
The day pass
The day pass is $5.70, which is exactly two single rides, so it pays off from the third ride of a day. Picture a visitor going to the Wharf, then to a museum, then back to the hotel, with a stop in between. That is four rides, $11.40 by the ride. The day pass costs $5.70 and saves the other $5.70.
Run it over several days and the habit holds. Three days of heavy use cost 3 times $5.70, or $17.10, far under the $86 of the "M" pass, which is built for a month. A visitor in town for a week will find the day pass cheaper than the monthly pass in nearly every case. Visitor passports, sold on Clipper, on MuniMobile and as paper passes, cover a set number of days and are worth a look too (How to ride Muni).
One caution before buying. Whether a day pass covers cable cars is a question for the fare page. The monthly "M" pass is listed as including them, but a visitor who means to ride them should confirm what the day product covers first.
The "A" pass
The "A" pass costs $104. It adds BART travel within San Francisco to the Muni service, and it runs $18 more than the "M" pass. The test is plain. Those extra dollars buy BART rides inside the city, so the pass earns its premium only if a person's within-city BART rides in a month would cost more than $18 at BART's posted fares. Divide $18 by the within-city BART fare to get the number of rides needed. BART posts that fare on its own site.
Consider a resident on the south side. BART from Balboa Park to Civic Center or Powell can be the quick way downtown, and someone who takes that trip regularly is just the sort of rider the "A" pass suits (The Excelsior and the Outer Mission). For anyone who uses BART now and then, the "M" pass plus a separate BART payment comes out cheaper. BART is its own agency, and the SFMTA does not set its fares (Using BART and Caltrain from San Francisco).
Free rides and discounts
Some riders never have to run the numbers. Anyone 18 and under rides Muni free, so a family's pass decision comes down to its adults. Eligible adults can get discounted fares, among them Clipper START's 50 percent discount, which brings a single ride to $1.40. On a discounted fare the break-even moves. The pass costs the same, but each ride costs less, so the pass wins only at a much higher count of rides. The fare page lists the programs and how to enroll in them (How Muni fares work in 2026).
A year of each
A month can hide what a year shows. Twelve "M" passes cost 12 times $86, which is $1,032. A rider who makes 40 rides every month pays 12 times $114.00, or $1,368 by the ride, so the pass saves $336. A rider who makes 20 rides a month pays 12 times $57.00, or $684, and paying by the ride saves $348 over the pass. The same monthly figures, $86 or $114 or $57, repeat for years, and the choice comes up again every thirty days. That is why it is worth getting right once.
Five steps, then done
- Count a typical month. Add up the rides in a normal month. A trip with a change inside 120 minutes counts once.
- Divide. Take the pass price over $2.85 and round up. At 2026 prices that is 31.
- Compare. Above the break-even, buy the pass. Below it, pay by the ride.
- Add the cable cars. Each is $9.00 by itself, so several in a month belong in the total.
- Check the date. Look at the fare page for current prices, since the budget can change them.
Two mistakes turn up again and again. One is buying the "A" pass for the BART coverage and then riding BART inside San Francisco only a few times a month. The other is buying a pass for a month the rider will spend away. A pass suits steady use. A rider with an irregular schedule is usually better off with Clipper and the single fare, which charges only for the rides actually taken (Proof of payment on Muni).
Redoing the math when fares change
Fares are set through the transit agency's budget, so every number above can move. The method does not. Take the monthly pass price and divide it by the single ride fare. Round up to the next whole number. That is the count of rides a month at which the pass starts to pay.
- At the 2026 prices, 86 divided by 2.85 rounds up to 31.
- At the cash price, 86 divided by 3.00 rounds up to 29.
- For the "A" pass against the "M" pass, divide the $18 difference by the BART within-city fare.
A rider who keeps a tally of monthly rides, and who checks the SFMTA fare page when the agency adopts a new budget, can keep the decision current (San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency). The cheapest option is whichever one matches how often a person really rides, and for most people that figure stays a mystery until they sit down and count.