Blog
When voters created the SFMTA, 1999
How Proposition E of 1999 merged Muni with the Department of Parking and Traffic, what changed in 2000, and why one agency runs buses, meters and tow trucks.
In most American cities the people who run the buses and the people who write the parking tickets work in different buildings and answer to different bosses. Not here. The same agency that runs Muni's trains, buses and cable cars also sets the rules for curbside parking, issues residential parking permits, tows illegally parked cars and writes the tickets that send people to its customer service center on South Van Ness Avenue. That arrangement is no accident of history. Voters chose it in 1999, in a ballot measure that rewrote how the city manages its streets.
Muni, looking for a home
The Municipal Railway began service on December 28, 1912, with the A and B Geary streetcars, and the first car was driven by Mayor James Rolph (The opening of Muni, December 28, 1912). What it lacked, for most of its history, was a home of its own. By the SFMTA's account, Muni moved through three organizational phases before 1999.
| Years | Where Muni sat |
|---|---|
| 1912 to 1932 | The Bureau of Engineering, within Public Works |
| 1932 to 1994 | A division of the San Francisco Public Utilities Commission |
| 1994 to 2000 | Overseen by the Public Transportation Commission |
A transit system lives or dies by what happens on the streets above its tracks: how much parking there is, how the lights are timed, whether a bus lane exists at all. In 1994 a Public Transportation Commission took over oversight of Muni, giving the system a board focused on transit alone. That was a step toward independence, but it left the street itself in the hands of a different department.
The other half: parking and traffic
That department was the Department of Parking and Traffic, DPT to everyone who dealt with it. Its roots go back to 1949, when the city created the Parking Authority to cope with the postwar growth of automobile traffic. In 1990 the city created DPT and folded the Parking Authority into it. DPT handled the signals, the signs, the parking meters, the citations and the engineering of the roadway.
So by the late 1990s San Francisco had two agencies answering for the same streets, with overlapping goals and different priorities. One ran the buses, the other ran the lanes and signals those buses used. If Muni needed a signal timed for a bus or a stretch of curb cleared for a stop, it had to negotiate with another department. If DPT wanted to add parking, it did not answer to the board responsible for transit. That is the kind of arrangement that breeds disputes whenever responsibility for one result, here the speed and reliability of a bus ride, is cut in two.
Taxis added a third strand. A Taxi Commission was formed in 1998; before that, regulation of taxis had been scattered across the Police Commission, the Tax Collector's office and the Department of Public Health.
Proposition E
The fix that went to voters in November 1999 was Proposition E. It combined Muni and DPT under a single agency, the San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency, and it gave that agency one board. The idea was to give the city one place where decisions about moving people, by bus, by car or on foot, could be weighed against each other, with one budget and one accountable board. Voters approved it.
The changes took effect in stages. In March 2000 the SFMTA became a city department and replaced the Public Transportation Commission. On July 1, 2000, it took over the management of Muni, and Muni's last general manager, who had also headed the Public Transportation Commission, became the agency's first executive director. DPT followed into the agency in 2002, bringing parking, signals and traffic engineering with it.
What the new structure allowed
The case for the merger rested on the notion that the street is one system. Under a single agency, a decision to add a transit-only lane could be made together with a decision about the curb parking it displaces, and the money raised by meters and citations could be weighed against the cost of running the service. The agency could plan signal timing, stop spacing and parking supply with the whole corridor in view, and one board could be held to account.
The change also laid some trade-offs bare. Parking revenue and transit needs now sat in one budget, and parking policy could be argued as part of transit policy. Decisions that had been bureaucratic turf questions became questions for a board that voters and the Board of Supervisors could scrutinize. The SFMTA's board is appointed by the mayor and confirmed by the Board of Supervisors, and it sets policy, approves the budget and approves changes to fares, fees and fines (San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency).
Later chapters
Two later measures built on the 1999 foundation.
- Proposition A of 2007 expanded the SFMTA's authority and oversight responsibilities. It let the agency issue bonds and required measurable standards for traffic and parking.
- Taxi regulation, 2009. In the spring of 2009 the SFMTA took over the regulation of taxis, authorized under the provisions of Propositions E and A. A function that had been scattered among three bodies before 1998 now sat with the agency that ran the buses.
Together those changes made the SFMTA the city's single agency for getting around: transit, traffic, parking and taxis.
What residents notice
For a resident, the consolidation shows up in a handful of everyday transactions. The agency that runs the 14 Mission is also the one that issues the parking ticket when a car blocks a bus stop, and the one whose tow truck takes it away.
- Parking tickets. Citations are paid or protested through the SFMTA, online, by phone, by mail or at the customer service center at 11 South Van Ness Avenue (how to pay a parking ticket).
- Residential parking permits. Issued by the SFMTA, which mails renewal notices four weeks before expiry (Parking in San Francisco: signs, street cleaning and color curbs).
- Towing. The agency tows illegally parked and abandoned vehicles, and a car that has stayed more than 72 hours in one place can be treated as abandoned (the towed-car trail).
- Garages and lots. The SFMTA operates city-owned garages and lots.
- Muni and cable cars. Service, fares and the cable car system, including the Central Subway extension of the T Third line that opened in 2023, belong to the same agency (The T Third and the Central Subway; the cable car system: three lines and a museum).
- Curb rules. Street-cleaning schedules and color-coded curbs are part of the same portfolio (reading parking signs, street cleaning and color curbs).
The agency's board sets the fares and publishes them on the SFMTA's website; they change with each budget, so a rider should check the current table before relying on any figure.
Before and after, function by function
A table of who answered for what shows how far the 1999 vote moved things.
| Function | In 1998 | By 2010 |
|---|---|---|
| Buses, Metro and cable cars | Public Transportation Commission (Muni) | SFMTA |
| Signals, signs and traffic engineering | Department of Parking and Traffic | SFMTA |
| Meters, citations and permits | Department of Parking and Traffic | SFMTA |
| Taxi regulation | Taxi Commission (formed 1998) | SFMTA (from spring 2009) |
Three boards and departments became one, and the number of separate bodies a resident or a business had to deal with over a street problem fell with them.
A hypothetical morning
A made-up example shows how the pieces now connect. Say a delivery truck stops in a bus lane on a weekday morning. The bus behind it cannot reach the stop, riders wait, and the driver radios the transit operations center. The same agency owns the lane, the sign that restricts it and the parking control officers who write the citation. If the truck is blocking the lane in a way that calls for removal, the tow is arranged through the agency too. If riders complain about missed trips, the board that oversees the bus service is the one that approves the fines the truck's owner may pay. None of that is unusual for a city agency today, but before 1999 it would have taken cooperation between separate departments, each with its own budget and its own board.
The example also shows why the topic stirs strong feelings. Every link in that chain, from the bus lane itself to the amount of the fine, is a choice about who gets to use the street, and when one agency holds all of those choices it owns the answer.
Eighty-eight years in three homes
Count from Muni's first day in 1912 to the SFMTA's takeover in 2000 and the system spent 88 years under three overseers before it joined a single agency. It sat in Public Works for the first 20 years, in the Public Utilities Commission for the next 62 and under the Public Transportation Commission for the final six. Only after those 88 years did it share a board with the people who timed the signals and wrote the tickets. The sheer length of that history is one reason the 1999 vote was treated as a major change rather than a minor reorganization.
Arguments that continue
The structure created in 1999 has not ended the arguments over how streets should be shared. Supporters point to the ability to coordinate transit with the street and to a single point of accountability. A common worry runs the other way: that a single agency responsible for transit, parking and enforcement may treat motorists as a revenue source, or may weigh competing demands in ways that satisfy neither drivers nor riders. Both views come from the same fact. Put Muni and the street under one roof and the choices about the street belong to one board, and so do the complaints.
Timeline
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| December 28, 1912 | Muni begins service with the A and B Geary streetcars |
| 1932 | Muni becomes a division of the Public Utilities Commission |
| 1949 | The Parking Authority is created |
| 1990 | The Department of Parking and Traffic is created |
| 1994 | The Public Transportation Commission takes over Muni oversight |
| 1998 | The Taxi Commission is formed |
| November 1999 | Voters approve Proposition E |
| March 2000 | The SFMTA becomes a city department |
| July 1, 2000 | The SFMTA takes over management of Muni |
| 2002 | DPT joins the SFMTA |
| 2007 | Proposition A expands the agency's authority |
| Spring 2009 | The SFMTA takes over taxi regulation |