Blog
Food halls and market halls
A question-and-answer guide to San Francisco's food halls: what they are, how each stall is permitted and inspected, and how they differ from markets.
Twelve kitchens, one set of tables, and a line at every counter: the food hall is the city's latest answer to an old question, which is how to feed a crowd without opening a restaurant. In a town of small storefront dining rooms, the format sits in an odd place. It is neither a single restaurant nor a street market, and the city's rules for permits, inspection and building use treat it as a collection of separate businesses. The common questions, in order, with answers drawn from what the city's own pages say about how food businesses are permitted.
What is a food hall?
A food hall is a building or a large room where several independent food vendors operate side by side, with shared seating. Each vendor has its own counter or stall, its own menu and its own kitchen, and customers order from whichever stalls they like and eat at common tables. A market hall is a close cousin with a retail lean, mixing food counters with sellers of groceries, produce, meat, fish and prepared foods to take home.
The format has a long history in cities, from the covered markets of Europe to the food courts of American malls. What sets a modern food hall apart is the mix: individual operators rather than chain outlets, a shared design and often a tie to a particular neighborhood or style of cooking.
Is there a food hall in San Francisco that everyone knows?
The best-known market hall in the city is the Ferry Building Marketplace, in the historic building at the foot of Market Street. The Ferry Building itself opened in 1898 and was for decades the city's gateway from the water. After the Embarcadero Freeway came down (see The Embarcadero Freeway, 1968 to 1991), the building was remodeled and reopened in 2003 as a marketplace with food vendors and shops, with ferry terminals behind it. The Port of San Francisco, which owns the waterfront, is responsible for the building and its surroundings (see Port of San Francisco).
Other versions of the hall turn up in the neighborhoods. The Japan Center in Japantown is a set of three shopping centers with restaurants, a grocery and other food businesses (see Japantown's food and the Japan Center). Chinatown's Stockton Street is a market street and not a hall, but it does a similar job (see chinatown's grocery and bakery streets). The point of the comparison is that "food hall" describes a way of organizing food sales, and the city has several.
How is a food hall different from a farmers market?
A certified farmers market is regulated as a market of growers, with an agricultural certificate from the state, a food safety permit from the city's Department of Public Health and, when it uses a public street, a street-closure permit from the SFMTA (see The Hayes Valley farmers market and Shared Spaces). It meets on certain days and then packs up. A food hall stays put: it occupies a building, keeps a regular schedule and holds standing permits.
In practice the two often coexist. The Ferry Building has a market hall inside and a farmers market outside, and the pairing draws a steady flow of people.
Does each stall need its own permit?
In general, yes. San Francisco regulates food businesses through the Department of Public Health's Environmental Health Branch, which issues health permits to restaurants, bars, food markets and similar businesses. The city's guidance says to apply at least one month before you open, and it says a new owner needs a new permit when the ownership structure changes. A stall in a food hall is, from the health department's side of the counter, a food business, so each operator typically applies for its own permit. The Food Safety program's phone number on the city's page is 415-252-3800 (see San Francisco Department of Public Health).
The steps in the city's guidance for a restaurant or retail food location are:
- Have a location, a registered business and the other city permits in motion. The health permit comes after these basics.
- Make sure someone is a certified food safety manager. At least one person must hold the certification, and almost all other food workers need a food handler card.
- Apply online. The application asks for the Business Account Number, a Location ID and the federal tax ID, and may also require a menu or floor plan.
- Pay the fees. Application, license and other fees appear in the Environmental Health fee schedule.
An operator who takes over an existing facility can request a site evaluation from the health department before signing a lease, a useful step for anyone eyeing a stall in a space that already has kitchen equipment.
What about the building itself?
Permits for the space come from other agencies. The Permit Center at 49 South Van Ness Avenue brings together the Department of Building Inspection, the Planning Department, Public Works and other agencies (see Department of Building Inspection and the Permit Center and San Francisco Planning). The Planning Department decides what use a space may have under the city's zoning rules, and the Department of Building Inspection reviews construction plans and inspects the work. A hall that converts a former retail or industrial building would go through both.
The health department's role is separate. For a new or remodeled food business, the department reviews plans before construction, including drawings and a menu, so that the kitchen layout meets food-safety rules. The standing advice is to talk to each agency early, because the approvals interlock. The city's guide to opening a restaurant lists the steps, and the Office of Small Business offers free counseling (see Starting a business in San Francisco and what it takes to open a restaurant here).
A worked example: one stall, in order
Say a cook wants to open a stall in an existing hall. This is hypothetical, and it shows the order of the steps only, not timelines, which vary.
- Talk to the Office of Small Business. The city's counselors offer free one-on-one help with permitting and registration, and an early conversation shows which approvals apply.
- Register the business with the Treasurer and Tax Collector and obtain the business account number the health application asks for.
- Get the certifications. One person becomes a certified food safety manager, and the other workers get food handler cards.
- Ask for a site evaluation from the health department if the stall's space already has kitchen equipment, before signing a lease.
- Submit plans. If the stall will be built or remodeled, the health department reviews drawings and a menu before work begins, and the building and planning agencies review the construction.
- Apply for the health permit at least a month before the planned opening.
- Pass inspection and open.
A cook who skips a step, say by starting construction before the plans are approved, risks tearing out and redoing the work. That is why the city's guidance keeps repeating the advice to wait for approval before building.
What about a food truck parked near a hall?
Mobile food facilities have their own rules, and the distance to a restaurant matters. On public streets and sidewalks, a food truck must stay at least 75 feet from restaurant primary entrances, and it must also keep specified distances from schools, hydrants, bus zones and street artists (see how food trucks and carts get permitted). The rule is one reason a truck does not usually park at the front door of a hall or a restaurant. Trucks that operate on private property, a parking lot for instance, go through a different process involving the Planning Department.
Who inspects the stalls?
The Environmental Health Branch inspects food facilities, and the rules that apply to a restaurant on a street apply to a stall in a hall. Inspectors look at how food is stored, handled and cooked, at hygiene and at the condition of the facility. The detail of how inspections work and how results are shown to the public is covered in how restaurant health inspections work.
A food hall adds a shared element: the seating area and restrooms. Those belong to the building's operation, and the operator of the hall is responsible for keeping them in order.
What about alcohol?
Alcohol is regulated separately. Liquor licenses come from the state, and the city has a role in the review process (see last call: how liquor licenses are reviewed). A hall that offers a bar generally treats it as a separate business with its own license, not as part of any one food stall.
Are food halls the same as pop-ups and night markets?
No. A pop-up or a night market is temporary. For an event with many food vendors, the city's guidance is different: the event organizer collects each vendor's application and submits them as a packet to the health department, with a site map showing booths, restrooms and water sources, no less than two weeks before the event (see night markets and the street-vending permit). A permanent hall does not follow that process, since it holds standing permits.
Why open one, and why not?
Food halls appeal to operators for practical reasons. A stall is smaller and cheaper to open than a full restaurant, and a hall can bring customers to a vendor who might not draw them alone. Landlords like them because a mix of tenants can fill a large space.
They carry risks too. A hall lives on foot traffic, and a stall with a weak location can fail. The same shared space that helps vendors reach customers can also make it hard to stand out. These are business questions, and the city's guidance is mostly about the regulatory side.
What does a visitor need to know?
For someone planning to eat at a hall, there are no special rules. Each stall is a food business with its own menu and permit. The hall's hours, the stalls' hours and the available seating vary, and each operator's own information is the best source. What matters most to a visitor is what the city's rules already guarantee: a permit, an inspection regime and, for allergies or special needs, the right to ask a vendor directly.
Where to go for official information
- Health permits and food safety: the Department of Public Health's Environmental Health Branch.
- Building and zoning: the Permit Center, with the Planning Department and the Department of Building Inspection.
- Starting a food business: the Office of Small Business, which offers counseling, and the city's guide to opening a restaurant.
- Waterfront space: the Port of San Francisco, for the Ferry Building and other port property.
The format is simple and the rules around it are not, but they follow a logic: each vendor is a food business, each space has a use, and each agency covers its own part of the approval.