Blog
Last call: how liquor licenses are reviewed
The state issues the license, but San Francisco's Planning, Police, Supervisors and Entertainment Commission each weigh in. Here is the path and sound rules.
At 2 a.m., under state law, the taps shut off at every bar and restaurant in California, and they stay shut until 6. Everything before that moment is another matter. Whether a particular corner may serve alcohol at all is decided by a handful of authorities. The state issues the license. The city decides whether the site is zoned for it, whether the neighborhood already has too many, and how loud the music may be. A San Francisco applicant may work through five or six offices before the first drink is poured, and a neighbor with an objection has several places to make it.
The state issues the license
Every liquor license in California comes from the state's Department of Alcoholic Beverage Control, known as ABC. For a restaurant or bar, a few license types matter most:
- Type 41, on-sale beer and wine, eating place. Issued to restaurants. Distilled spirits may not be on the premises, except for cooking. The business must operate as a bona fide eating place, with suitable kitchen facilities and real meal sales.
- Type 47, on-sale general, eating place. Authorizes beer, wine and distilled spirits for consumption on the premises, with the same bona fide eating-place requirement.
- Types 20 and 21, off-sale licenses. Issued to retail stores for beer and wine (Type 20) or beer, wine and spirits (Type 21) consumed off the premises.
The city's own guide for opening a restaurant explains the practical differences. A beer-and-wine license, Type 41, can be applied for directly. A license that includes spirits, Type 47, can in San Francisco be had only by buying an existing one. Transfers average about 75 days, and a new license is expected to take three to six months. A license bought from a previous owner can be expensive, which is why a lease and a license are often negotiated together.
Once an application is filed, ABC posts a notice at the location so the public knows. If no one objects, ABC investigates the applicant's background and issues the license if the applicant is cleared. A neighbor, a community group or a city agency that objects takes the issue to ABC through its protest process.
The city's questions
State approval is not enough, because a license cannot be issued if it violates local zoning. Before an applicant gets that far, San Francisco has a set of local reviews of its own.
Planning. The Planning Department reviews every liquor license application against the zoning of the site and may approve or disapprove it. Zoning is specific to each address. A space that was a bar for thirty years is not automatically permitted to be one again, and the city's guides advise checking even sites that have served alcohol before. See San Francisco Planning for how the department works.
Police. The San Francisco Police Department's Alcoholic Beverage Control Liaison Unit, usually shortened to the ALU, reviews every license, may investigate the premises, recommends approval or disapproval, and can recommend conditions that ABC may attach to the license. The authority comes from Section 1298 of the city's Police Code. For the department's wider record see San Francisco Police Department.
The Board of Supervisors, when the area is crowded. The state's rules give local government a role where a neighborhood already has an undue concentration of licensed establishments or a high level of reported crime. In those areas a license may be issued only if a finding is made that it would serve "public convenience or necessity," usually shortened to PC or N. The Board of Supervisors makes that finding by resolution when ABC calls for a local determination, and ABC tells an applicant when one is needed.
How a PC or N request moves
The Board does not issue licenses. It makes a determination that ABC then weighs. The sequence on the city's fact sheet runs like this:
- File with ABC first. The applicant has to apply for the state license before asking the Board for anything.
- Write to the Clerk of the Board. A signed letter goes to the Clerk at City Hall, Room 244. It gives the applicant's contact information, the business name and address, the license type and whether it is a new license or a transfer, the proposed hours, when and how the ABC application was filed, when and how the state-required notice was posted, and an explanation of how the license serves public convenience or necessity in the neighborhood and citywide. The Clerk's office is covered at Clerk of the Board of Supervisors.
- Planning and the ALU review. The Clerk refers the request to both.
- A hearing, if both recommend approval. The Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee, which meets on the second and fourth Thursdays at 10 a.m., may schedule a hearing. The applicant has to attend, present and answer questions, and members of the public may comment.
- A resolution. The committee may prepare a resolution finding that the license would, or would not, serve public convenience or necessity.
- The full Board votes. A majority decides. Enacted resolutions are sent to ABC.
The Board is expected to act within 90 days of a valid request. If it does not, ABC may issue the license, but only if the applicant shows that public convenience or necessity would be served. So the decision is partly a matter of the clock. Delay does not automatically approve an application, and it does not automatically kill one either.
These resolutions are public. The Board has made negative findings as well as positive ones, for example a 2017 resolution stating that a retail license at an address on Kearny Street would not serve public convenience or necessity. How an idea becomes an ordinance at the Board of Supervisors describes how committee work reaches a vote.
Where the Entertainment Commission fits
A liquor license says what a business may pour. It does not say whether a band may play. In San Francisco that is a separate permit from the Entertainment Commission, a six-member body that includes a law enforcement representative, a public health representative, a neighborhood representative, two industry representatives and an urban planning representative. It meets on the first and third Tuesdays of the month.
The permits relevant to a bar or restaurant are:
- Place of Entertainment. Regular entertainment at a venue, concert hall or nightclub.
- Limited Live Performance. Entertainment as a secondary activity, such as live music at a restaurant.
- Extended Hours Premises. Entertainment, food or non-alcoholic drinks between 2 a.m. and 6 a.m. This permit does not extend alcohol sales. The 2 a.m. cutoff stays.
- Billiard Parlor and Mechanical Amusement Device. For pool tables and arcade games that charge customers.
- Fixed Place Outdoor Amplified Sound. For music outdoors.
A venue where 50 or more people can gather at once also needs a place-of-assembly permit from the Fire Department.
The sound rules
Sound limits are written into the permit, and they are measured the same way every time. For a brick-and-mortar business, the ambient level is established as a 10-minute average of A-weighted and C-weighted decibel readings taken at the property plane, the edge of the business's own property. The "A" scale approximates how the ear responds at lower volumes but gives bass little weight. The "C" scale covers a wider range and does better at reflecting a loud performance, so a permit may list both. The standard is that operating sound inside the venue should not raise the ambient level outside by more than 8 decibels.
For one-time outdoor events the test can be simpler. If the permit lists an "ambient sound at an approved distance" condition, an inspector stands at that distance from the event's property line for three to five minutes. The sound is acceptable if normal traffic and surrounding noise largely drown it out. It has to come down if it clearly stands out over passing buses and street noise.
The Commission's enforcement team answers compliance questions and can compare an owner's handheld meter against the Commission's own. A neighbor with a sound complaint can report it through the Commission's online form or by calling 311. The Commission's own phone line is 628-652-6030. For how this ties into a venue's wider obligations, see The Entertainment Commission and venue sound.
What neighbors can do
The review is not closed to the public. A resident can take part at four points:
- At the posted notice. When an application is filed, ABC posts a notice at the location. A person or group with an objection to the license raises it with ABC through the state's protest process.
- At the Board committee. When a request for a public convenience or necessity finding reaches the Public Safety and Neighborhood Services Committee, the committee takes public comment, and its agenda is posted ahead of time on the Board's meeting page.
- At the Entertainment Commission. The Commission meets in public twice a month, on the first and third Tuesdays.
- After the bar opens. A sound complaint can be filed with the Commission or through 311, and an inspector can check the venue's levels against its permit. The permit's conditions travel with the business, so a complaint about a venue over its limit is a complaint about a specific, written number. Using 311 in San Francisco, by phone, app or web explains how 311 reports work.
An example of the timeline
Say a restaurant owner wants to open a cocktail bar in a neighborhood the state classifies as having an undue concentration of licenses. The owner buys an existing Type 47 license, because that is the only route to one, files the transfer with ABC, posts the required notice and writes to the Clerk of the Board asking for a public convenience or necessity finding. The Clerk sends the request to Planning and the Police Department's liquor unit. Both recommend approval, the committee hears the request on a second or fourth Thursday, and the full Board votes on the resolution at a Tuesday meeting. The Board aims to act within 90 days of a valid request, and the city's guide says transfers average about 75 days, so the owner can reasonably plan on several months between filing and a license in hand, with the Entertainment Commission's permits and the building permits running alongside. Every number in that example is a planning figure, not a promise. The departments set their own schedules.
Reading a corner
Put the pieces together and you can read a block. A restaurant that opens with beer and wine often reflects a license that was easy to get. A restaurant that serves cocktails often belongs to the owner of a purchased license. A new bar on a crowded commercial strip may be the subject of a Board hearing. Anyone who watches the Board's Public Safety and Neighborhood Services agenda sees those hearings before the license reaches ABC. For those planning to open one, the full sequence of permits, from lease to health permit, is set out in what it takes to open a restaurant here. The Board's own fact sheet is at sf.gov, and the Clerk of the Board can be reached at 415-554-5184.