Blog
The Angel Island Immigration Station, 1910 to 1940
The station opened January 21, 1910 and held Chinese and other Asian immigrants for days or years. The poems on its walls, the 1940 fire and the preservation.
For thirty years, a corner of Angel Island in the middle of San Francisco Bay held people who wanted to come to America. Between 1910 and 1940 the federal government used it as the main West Coast port of entry for Asian and other immigrants, a place often called the Ellis Island of the West. The comparison undersells the difference. Ellis Island screened most arrivals in a few hours. Angel Island was built, in large part, to enforce the Chinese Exclusion Act, and many of the people held there waited weeks, months or years for a decision.
Why an island
The idea came out of a 1904 study that recommended an island site, partly for its isolation, which allowed tighter control over who entered and slowed the spread of disease. The War Department transferred 20 acres of the island to the Department of Commerce and Labor in 1905, and construction began that year in an area then known as the North Garrison. California State Parks notes that public controversy dogged the project from the start.
The station had a specific job. It was designed to process Chinese immigrants, and its procedures were built around the exemptions in the Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882. Before the island opened, Chinese arrivals had been held aboard ships and in a loft at the Pacific Mail Steamship Company's dock in San Francisco, a history told in Chinese exclusion and San Francisco.
Opening day and the move from the dock
The station opened on January 21, 1910, and on January 23 officials moved 101 Chinese detainees and one South Asian detainee from the Pacific Mail dock to the island, according to the Angel Island Immigration Station Foundation. It went into partial operation at first. A rush of European immigrants was expected because of the Panama Canal, but after 1914 the outbreak of World War I canceled it, and the station stayed mostly an Asian immigration facility.
Over its thirty years, California State Parks says, the station was the entry point for most of the approximately 175,000 Chinese immigrants who came to the United States, and more than 80 countries were represented among the people processed. The National Park Service estimates that the station processed up to one million immigrants in all.
Inside the station
The routine was designed for scrutiny. Officials separated detainees by race and sex, and children under 12 could stay with their mothers. Each detainee got a medical exam. Immigrants whose documents were in question were held for examination, and the hearings could take days, months or even several years. Most detainees stayed from a couple of days to a couple of months, and a few were held for up to two years. Set that against Ellis Island, where screening averaged two to three hours, and the difference in purpose is plain.
For Chinese applicants, the process turned on proof. Many were seeking entry under the exemptions in the exclusion law, and officials questioned them about their claims. The detention barracks held them while they waited, in rooms of bunk beds with little to do. The restored barracks today show the recreated bunk rooms and recreation areas.
The poems
The best-known record of the station is the poetry carved into the barracks walls. Detainees carved poems into the wood and plaster, often expressing frustration and unhappiness. The poems began to appear about ten months after men started living in the barracks. Many are still legible today.
Few people knew of them until 1970, when a park ranger, Alexander Weiss, discovered them. The poems are now regarded as one of the most important records of the experience of Chinese immigrants under the exclusion laws.
The shed that came before
The station replaced something worse. From 1898 the Pacific Mail Steamship Company used a second-floor loft at Pier 40 on the San Francisco waterfront as a makeshift detention facility for Chinese arrivals, after the company's largest ship was sent to support the Spanish-American War. The shed measured about 100 by 50 feet. A journalist in 1898 described more than 350 immigrants packed into it and compared it to a honeycomb of tiny rooms. Bunks were stacked five or six tiers high, and the space was overcrowded and poorly ventilated.
The shed's best-known occupant was Sun Yat-sen, detained there in April 1904 and released after an appeal to the Acting Secretary of Commerce and Labor. The shed's conditions helped make the case for a purpose-built station. When the island station opened, the shed's detainees, 101 Chinese and one South Asian man, were the first to move.
From plans to opening
It took five years to get the station open. Congress allocated $200,000 for construction in 1905, and most of the buildings were finished by 1908. Then they sat unused for lack of funds to operate them. The station officially opened on January 21, 1910, with its first immigrants arriving the next day. Those were the people who would test the buildings' design: an administration building that held offices and the hearing rooms, barracks for detainees separated by sex and race, a hospital and the dining and recreation facilities that served them.
Reading the poems
Many poems are still legible today. They speak of the sea voyage, of the family left behind, of the humiliation of detention and of the poet's hope or despair about the decision. Many of the writers were anonymous. The poems matter to historians for two reasons. They are a first-person record from people whose cases are otherwise documented mainly in officials' files. And they survived in a physical place, the same wooden walls where the writers waited, which is why preserving the barracks and preserving the poems are one project.
What burned and what moved
The fire in August 1940 started in the administration building. The Angel Island Immigration Station Foundation attributes it to an electrical fault and says it also consumed the dining facilities and women's dormitories. The government had already been thinking about leaving the island, and the fire settled the question. The last detainees were transferred on November 5, 1940, to temporary quarters at 801 Silver Avenue in San Francisco, a landlocked building in the city. The island's immigration function moved back to the mainland, and the station's buildings stood empty.
Comparing the two island stations
| Ellis Island, New York | Angel Island, San Francisco Bay | |
|---|---|---|
| Nickname | Gateway for Europe | The "Ellis Island of the West" |
| Typical screening | Two to three hours on average | Days to months, in some cases years |
| Main population | European immigrants | Chinese and other Asian immigrants |
| Legal focus | General immigration inspection | Enforcement of the Chinese Exclusion Act |
| Purpose of site | Processing | Processing and detention, away from the mainland |
The table is a simplification, and its screening-time row comes from the park service's own comparison, but it shows why Angel Island's reputation is different.
August 12, 1940: the fire
On August 12, 1940, a fire destroyed the administration building. It hastened a decision that had been under consideration, to abandon the station. On November 5, 1940, the last group, about 200 immigrants, about 150 of them Chinese, moved to temporary quarters in San Francisco. Three years later, in 1943, Congress repealed the Chinese Exclusion Act with the Magnuson Act.
After the station closed, the island found other uses. The Army decommissioned its installations on the island in 1946. California bought 37 acres in 1955, which formed the start of the state park, and the military left the island entirely in 1962. Angel Island State Park today covers 740 acres.
Preservation
The discovery of the poems in 1970 drew attention to the old barracks. A Save America's Treasures grant funded restoration work in 2000, including the rehabilitation of the building and the carved poems. The immigration barracks have been restored with recreated bunk rooms and recreation areas, and the station is a National Historic Landmark. Guided tours of the detention barracks are offered.
A timeline
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| 1904 | A study recommends an island site for an immigration station |
| 1905 | The War Department transfers 20 acres; construction begins at the North Garrison |
| January 21, 1910 | The station opens |
| January 23, 1910 | Detainees are moved from the Pacific Mail dock |
| After 1914 | World War I cancels the expected rush of European immigrants |
| 1940, August 12 | Fire destroys the administration building |
| 1940, November 5 | The last group of about 200 leaves for San Francisco |
| 1943 | The Magnuson Act repeals the Chinese Exclusion Act |
| 1946 | The Army decommissions its installations |
| 1955 | California buys 37 acres, creating the state park |
| 1962 | The military leaves the island |
| 1970 | A park ranger discovers the poems |
| 2000 | A Save America's Treasures grant funds restoration |
Why it belongs to San Francisco's story
The station was a federal facility, not a city one, and the island lies in the bay, outside the city limits. But San Francisco was where the station's work began and ended: the dock where the earlier detainees waited, the Chinatown to which successful applicants went and the families who waited for news in the city. The immigrants' experience in the station is part of the history of Chinatown, and the same laws that created the station shaped the lives of the neighborhood's residents. The detention of Japanese Americans in 1942, a separate chapter, is described in Executive Order 9066 and Japantown.
Visiting
The station can be visited, and the state park's own information is the place to confirm current tours and the ferry schedule. The park's page is at parks.ca.gov, and the National Park Service's page on the station is at nps.gov. The visit is covered in Angel Island by ferry, and other free and low-cost ways to spend a day are listed in Free things to do in San Francisco.