Blog
The empty homes tax and the vacancy tax
What San Francisco's empty homes tax was, why courts blocked it, and how the commercial vacancy tax on storefronts works, with its rates and exemptions.
San Francisco has tried two taxes on empty property, one for vacant homes and one for vacant storefronts. They rest on the same premise, that an empty space in a city of high rents costs the neighbors something, and they have met very different fates. The empty homes tax is blocked by the courts and is not being collected. The commercial vacancy tax is in force, and it asks storefront owners and tenants to file a return every year. Both sit on the Treasurer and Tax Collector's list of taxes, so anyone scanning that list could easily take both for live. A few questions and answers sort out which is which.
What was the empty homes tax?
The Empty Homes Tax fell on residential units kept vacant for much of the year. Voters approved it in November 2022 as a ballot measure, and the Treasurer and Tax Collector administered it, with owners filing and paying through the same business tax channels that handle other annual taxes. The idea was to push owners of idle units toward renting or selling them and to raise money for housing, in a city where housing supply has been a long-running political fight. Opponents argued that it infringed on property owners' rights and that state law, not a city tax, governs when and whether an owner must rent a unit.
Why is it not being collected?
A court struck it down, and an appeals court agreed. The Treasurer and Tax Collector's page on the tax lays out the sequence:
- On October 31, 2024, the San Francisco Superior Court ruled that the tax violates the federal and state constitutions and is preempted by California law, in case number CGC-23-604600.
- On November 26, 2024, the court issued a judgment and order that prohibits the city from enforcing or administering the tax.
- On September 11, 2026, the California Court of Appeal affirmed the trial court's ruling, holding that state law preempts the tax, in case number A172067.
As a result, the Treasurer and Tax Collector says it will stop all work to collect the tax. Owners will not be required to file or pay unless and until the appeals court's decision is reversed. So a San Francisco property owner is not now asked to file an Empty Homes Tax return, even though the tax still shows on the Treasurer's list. Whether the city seeks further review is for the city attorney and the Board of Supervisors to decide, and the Treasurer's page is the place to watch for any change.
The legal reasoning reaches past this one tax. Preemption means a state law occupies the field and displaces the local rule; the appellate decision as reported by the legal press rested on that principle, and it leaves city leaders to look for other tools toward the same housing goals. Rent control in San Francisco: myths and the 1979 cutoff explains one existing tool, the Rent Ordinance's protections for tenants in older units, and the below-market rental lottery explains another, the city's affordable housing lottery.
What is the commercial vacancy tax?
A different tax, and a live one. The Commercial Vacancy Tax applies to certain ground-floor commercial space kept vacant for more than 182 days in a tax year, whether the days run consecutively or not. Voters approved it in the March 2020 election, and the Treasurer and Tax Collector administers it.
Where it applies. The tax covers ground-floor space that is adjacent or tangent to a public right of way, located in a named Neighborhood Commercial District or Neighborhood Commercial Transit District as those districts stood on March 3, 2020, and that is not residential. In practice that means the neighborhood shopping streets, not the downtown office towers.
Who files. Owners, tenants and subtenants of taxable commercial space must file every year, even if the space was occupied or qualifies for an exemption. Owners file for each taxable commercial space, and residential units are left off. The return for tax year 2025 was due March 2, 2026, and late returns draw penalties and fees even when no tax is owed.
The rate. The tax is charged per linear foot of frontage, rounded to the nearest foot: $250 per linear foot for one year of vacancy, $500 for two consecutive years and $1,000 for three or more consecutive years. Take a hypothetical storefront with 25 feet of frontage. The tax is $6,250 for one year of vacancy, $12,500 for a second consecutive year and $25,000 for a third or later year. The rising scale is meant to make long-term vacancy expensive.
Who is exempt
The tax has several exclusions, which is why filing is required even from owners who owe nothing.
- A tenant that operated a business for more than 182 consecutive days during a lease of at least two years is exempt for the rest of that lease.
- Organizations exempt under section 501(c)(3) of the federal tax code are exempt.
- Certain time periods do not count as vacancy: a building permit application period of up to one year, a one-year construction period after the first permit, a 183-day conditional use application period and a two-year disaster period.
- A major infrastructure project exemption, effective January 1, 2025, applies to space in these districts when a city project lasts more than 180 days in the tax year. For 2025 only, districts shown in green on the Treasurer's map were exempt on this basis.
- An affordable housing exemption, retroactive to January 1, 2022, applies to property under a recorded restrictive covenant enforced by the Mayor's Office of Housing and Community Development.
The infrastructure exemption has a particular logic in San Francisco, where long street construction projects on commercial corridors can leave storefronts empty for reasons the owner does not control.
The separate vacant storefront registry
The vacancy tax is not the city's vacant storefront registry, which the Department of Building Inspection runs under the Building Code. Owners of vacant storefronts can register through sf.gov, and the registration is shared with the department. An ordinance that took effect in 2019 created the registry, and it asks owners to register a vacant ground-floor storefront within 30 days of the vacancy and to renew each year. The two programs overlap in what they watch, but different departments run them under different rules and fees. vacant storefronts and the commercial rents tax looks at both in the context of commercial rents.
A checklist for a storefront owner
Because the vacancy tax wants a return from every owner of taxable space, vacant or not, the practical steps run in a fixed order.
- Check the address against the district map. The tax covers ground-floor, street-facing, non-residential space inside the neighborhood commercial districts as they stood on March 3, 2020. The Treasurer's map shows which districts apply.
- Count the days. Vacancy beyond 182 days in the tax year, consecutive or not, is the trigger. Days inside a permit, construction, conditional use or disaster exclusion period do not count.
- Look for an exemption. A tenant that operated for more than 182 consecutive days under a lease of at least two years, a 501(c)(3) organization, a project affected by a major infrastructure project and a space bound by an affordable housing covenant are the categories the Treasurer lists.
- File by the deadline. The return for 2025 was due March 2, 2026. A late return carries penalties and fees even when no tax is owed.
- Check the registry separately. The Department of Building Inspection's vacant storefront registry has its own registration and its own fee, and the sf.gov page lists the current amount.
A tenant owes the same return. A tenant in a space that sat empty because the landlord could not find a lessee is in a different position from a tenant that signed a lease and has the exemption, and the facts of each lease decide it.
Why cities tax vacancy
The case for taxing vacancy rests on a view of the street as shared infrastructure. A vacant storefront on a commercial corridor darkens the block, cuts foot traffic for the neighbors and can hold back the corridor's revival, and the owner may prefer to wait for a higher rent than lease at a lower one. A tax that rises with the length of the vacancy gives the owner a cost for waiting. Critics answer that landlords already lose rent while a space sits empty, that some vacancies come from permit delays or lease negotiations beyond anyone's control, that a tax at those rates can push marginal owners into bad leases, and that the paperwork burdens even owners who owe nothing. The exemptions for permit periods, construction and infrastructure projects are the city's attempt to answer the second of those points.
The residential version of the argument is much the same and more contested, because it raised a legal question the storefront tax does not: whether a city may use a tax to influence an owner's decision about renting out housing at all. The courts' answer so far is that state law forecloses it.
How the two taxes compare
| Empty Homes Tax | Commercial Vacancy Tax | |
|---|---|---|
| Target | Vacant residential units | Vacant ground-floor storefronts in neighborhood commercial districts |
| Status | Blocked by the courts; not collected | In force; annual return required |
| Administered by | Treasurer and Tax Collector | Treasurer and Tax Collector |
| Latest legal step | Court of Appeal affirmed the ruling, September 11, 2026 | Return for 2025 due March 2, 2026 |
Residents of neighborhoods with visible vacancies, such as stretches of the Mission District or the shopping streets near Union Square, often ask which of these taxes covers the building down the block. For a storefront it is the commercial vacancy tax. For an apartment, today, neither. A tenant with questions about a unit's status can start with Rent Board and housing agencies, and an owner with a storefront can start with Office of the Treasurer and Tax Collector and Department of Building Inspection and the Permit Center. The Treasurer's pages at sftreasurer.org carry the current forms and notices.
This is general information about two taxes, not legal or tax advice.