Blog
The UN Charter signed in San Francisco, 1945
Two months in 1945 at the Opera House and the Veterans Building, from the April 25 opening to the June 26 signing, and how the Charter came into force.
The afternoon of June 26, 1945, in a theater on Van Ness Avenue: representatives of fifty nations signed the Charter of the United Nations, China first. It closed out two months of work in San Francisco that had begun while the war in Europe was still being fought and ended with the war in the Pacific not yet won. The organization that grew out of it keeps its headquarters in New York, but its birthplace is in the Civic Center.
Why San Francisco
Officially it was the United Nations Conference on International Organization, UNCIO for short. It opened April 25, 1945, in San Francisco and ran until June 26. Its job was to take a set of proposals the great powers had drawn up the year before at Dumbarton Oaks, a Washington estate, and turn them into a charter the wider group of Allied nations could accept.
Invitations went to the 46 countries that had signed the Declaration by United Nations, plus four others: Denmark, Argentina and the Soviet republics of Ukraine and Belarus. Poland, whose postwar government had not yet been settled, was not at the table. Its new government signed the Charter on October 15, which is why the United Nations counts Poland among its 51 original members, although the signing in San Francisco covered 50.
The choice of a Pacific port had practical and symbolic sides. The city had hosted large gatherings before, and it had the civic buildings: the Civic Center, finished in the 1910s and 1930s, held a municipal opera house and a veterans' building with a large auditorium. San Francisco was also, in the spring of 1945, a city at the center of the Pacific war effort, full of military and shipping activity. A conference there reminded the delegates that the world they were designing was not limited to Europe.
A president's death and a city's welcome
President Roosevelt, who had championed the conference, died April 12, thirteen days before the opening. His successor, Harry Truman, kept the date. Delegates from around the world gathered in a city that had hung out flags and decorations and cleared hotels and offices for them. The governor of California, Earl Warren, gave the welcome speech.
Roosevelt's death was observed in a way particular to the region. Delegates held a commemoration at Muir Woods, the grove of coast redwoods just north of the Golden Gate in Marin County, a short drive from the city. It was a modest, quiet counterpoint to the big meetings downtown.
The scale of the meeting
UNCIO was a large operation. About 850 delegates attended, and with their advisers and staff the total reached roughly 3,500 people. Another 2,500 or so were journalists, observers from other organizations and representatives of the press from around the world.
Most plenary sessions took place in the War Memorial Opera House, with its 3,006 seats, a hall large enough for a full plenary. The stage that normally held opera singers held national flags. The Charter itself was signed in a different building, a short walk away, the Herbst Theatre in the Veterans Building. The two halls, facing each other across the plaza beside City Hall, are why historical maps describe the Civic Center as the place where the United Nations began (The War Memorial Opera House and Davies Hall; The Veterans Building and the War Memorial).
How the Charter was written
The conference was organized in layers. A Steering Committee set the agenda, an Executive Committee prepared proposals for the plenary, a Coordination Committee reconciled the language, and a Credentials Committee checked each delegation. Four commissions handled the substance, and each commission was divided into technical committees that worked on individual sections. A proposal might begin in a technical committee, move to its commission, go back to be redrafted and finally reach the plenary for a vote.
The structure had one great advantage: hundreds of delegates could take part without paralyzing the whole conference. It also gave smaller nations a place to be heard, and they used it.
The most famous argument was over the veto. The great powers had agreed in principle that the permanent members of the Security Council should be able to block substantive decisions. The proposal had been put forward at the Malta meeting and adopted at Yalta. Several of the smaller countries wanted to limit that power, and some argued that a world organization in which five nations could block any decision would be a weak guarantee of peace. The large powers insisted the veto was essential to securing their membership, and in the end the provision went into the Charter essentially as proposed.
The Charter also had to settle the powers of the General Assembly relative to the Security Council, and each of those arrangements in the final text is the product of negotiation.
Adoption and signing
The last stage came at the end of June. On June 25, Lord Halifax presided over the final plenary session, and the delegates adopted the Charter unanimously. On June 26 the delegations assembled in the Herbst Theatre to sign it. China signed first, and the other delegations followed. President Truman came to San Francisco to close the conference, and in his speech he urged that the Charter be used for the common good of all peoples.
The Charter did not take effect the day it was signed. Under its own terms it came into force once it had been ratified by China, France, the United Kingdom, the Soviet Union, the United States and a majority of the other signatories. That condition was met October 24, 1945, a date the United Nations observes each year as United Nations Day.
Two buildings only thirteen years old
The halls the delegates used were young. The War Memorial complex went up in the early 1930s, with construction beginning January 28, 1931 and cornerstones laid on Armistice Day that November. The War Memorial Opera House opened October 15, 1932, with Puccini's Tosca, and the Veterans Building opened November 11, 1932. Arthur Brown Jr., who also designed City Hall, was the architect of the complex, and the two civic buildings share a vocabulary: stone facades, large symmetrical masses and a ceremonial approach from Van Ness Avenue (San Francisco City Hall, the building).
The room where the Charter was signed, then called the Veterans Auditorium and now the Herbst Theatre, was an auditorium designed for veterans' groups and public events, not a diplomatic chamber. It seats 892 today, after a refurbishment in 1978. That a charter for the postwar world was signed in a hall built for veterans' meetings and recitals says something about the improvised character of the conference. San Francisco had no purpose-built assembly hall. It had a municipal opera house and a memorial building, and it made them serve.
The Civic Center and a second treaty
The same stage returned to world affairs six years later. The Treaty of San Francisco, which ended the state of war with Japan, was signed on the Opera House stage on September 8, 1951, and the Veterans Building hosted sessions of that conference (The Treaty of San Francisco, 1951). The War Memorial's own history calls the 1951 conference America's first live coast-to-coast television broadcast. Between them, the 1945 and 1951 conferences made the Civic Center one of the few places in the country where two major international texts were signed within a few hundred feet of each other.
What the building remembers
The two halls look different today than they did in 1945, but they stand in the same place and work every day. The Opera House is home to the San Francisco Opera and San Francisco Ballet. The Veterans Building holds the Herbst Theatre, known for the Frank Brangwyn murals originally painted for the 1915 Panama-Pacific International Exposition. The building's offices include the Arts Commission, whose main gallery is in the Veterans Building (How the Arts Commission funds public art).
The Charter's anniversary is marked in San Francisco from time to time. In 2019 the United Nations General Assembly proclaimed April 25, the date UNCIO opened, as International Delegate's Day, and the story of the conference belongs to any walk through the Civic Center (A walk around Civic Center; Civic Center).
The conference by the numbers
A few figures put the scale in proportion. The conference lasted 62 days, from April 25 to June 26. Invitations went to 50 countries, 46 signatories of the Declaration by United Nations plus four others, and 50 states signed on the last day. About 850 delegates came, a total of roughly 3,500 people counting advisers and staff, and around 2,500 more were journalists and observers. That is about one journalist or observer for every three and a half delegates and staff, a ratio that shows how closely the world's press was watching a meeting held in an opera house on the edge of the Pacific.
A short chronology
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| 1944 | The great powers draft proposals at Dumbarton Oaks, in Washington |
| April 12, 1945 | President Roosevelt dies |
| April 25, 1945 | The San Francisco conference opens |
| June 25, 1945 | The final plenary adopts the Charter unanimously |
| June 26, 1945 | The Charter is signed at the Herbst Theatre |
| October 15, 1945 | Poland signs |
| October 24, 1945 | The Charter enters into force |
Seeing it in person
The setting costs nothing to see. The Civic Center's plaza, the Opera House and the Veterans Building are all on Van Ness Avenue, within a short walk of City Hall and the Main Library. The Veterans Building has a public gallery, and performances at the Opera House and the Herbst Theatre are on the War Memorial's calendar. The best way to picture the signing is to stand on the sidewalk between the two buildings and look at how close they are. A delegate who had spent the day in plenary at the Opera House could cross the street and sign the document in the other hall.
Few cities host a founding moment and then go back to ordinary business. San Francisco did both: the Charter was written there, and the theaters have been given over to operas and ballets ever since (Free things to do in San Francisco).