Blog
How the Arts Commission funds public art
The 2 percent rule, the 1 percent downtown requirement, the Public Art Trust and the grants and galleries run by the Arts Commission, with a worked example.
Take a walk across the city on any given day and you will pass a good deal of art that nobody picked on a whim. It was paid for by a formula. The sculpture outside the library branch, the mural on the city wall, the poster in the Market Street shelter, the installation in the new park: all of it traces back to a few rules that set aside a share of construction budgets for art. The agency that administers them is the San Francisco Arts Commission, created by the 1932 city charter. Its own page describes the job as championing the arts: supporting local artists and arts nonprofits, and caring for the art the city owns.
Who the Arts Commission is
The Commission's office is in the War Memorial Veterans Building at 401 Van Ness Avenue, Suite 325, San Francisco 94102. The telephone number is 415-252-2266 and the general email is [email protected]. It sits in the Civic Center, in the same building as the Herbst Theatre (The Veterans Building and the War Memorial).
The agency does several jobs at once. It manages the Civic Art Collection, the artworks the city owns, and is responsible for preserving and caring for them. It runs the public art program and reviews the design of civic projects. It hands out grants to arts organizations. It operates galleries, runs programs that help artists sell their work, supports cultural centers and houses the city's film office. Different pieces of that portfolio are paid for in different ways, and the funding rules are the subject here.
The 2 percent rule
The permanent public art program rests on the Art Enrichment Ordinance, enacted in 1969 and often called "2 percent for art." It now lives in the city's Administrative Code, Section 3.19, and it works as a budgeting rule. When a city department proposes a bond or an appropriation for a covered project, it must add two percent of the gross estimated construction cost for art enrichment. A department that thinks that amount is wrong can propose a different budget to the Arts Commission, and unresolved disputes go to the mayor, who has 60 days to make a final determination.
The ordinance covers the construction or alteration of four kinds of project: buildings, aboveground structures such as bridges, new parks and transportation improvement projects. It does not cover everything. The exemptions include certain transportation work such as rail replacement, street paving and the purchase of transit vehicles; mechanical, plumbing, electrical, structural, seismic and disabled-access upgrades, unless they come with a larger alteration; most park and landscape renovations; certain utility infrastructure such as pipelines, power lines and substations; and airfield equipment. "Alteration" means substantial changes to the walls, partitions or ceilings of two-thirds or more of the floor space, not counting basements, and "construction cost" leaves out movable property and contingency.
After the money is appropriated, the Arts Commission supervises and controls how it is spent. It may set aside up to 10 percent of a project's allocation for maintenance and conservation of the artwork in the Civic Art Collection. It may combine funds for use at another city site when the funding source and the departments agree. And it may use up to 20 percent of the funds for the administrative costs of running the program, unless the funding source limits that use.
A worked example
Say the city builds a new public building with a gross estimated construction cost of $50 million. The numbers are hypothetical and show only how the rule works.
- Two percent of $50 million is $1,000,000 for art enrichment.
- If the Commission set aside the maximum 10 percent for maintenance and conservation, that is $100,000.
- If it used the maximum 20 percent for administrative costs, that is $200,000.
- That leaves $700,000 for the artwork itself.
Real amounts depend on the funding source and the project. The example shows why the program is a long commitment: the rule reserves money to look after the art once it is installed, not only to buy it.
The 1 percent rule for private development
A second rule reaches private builders downtown. The 1985 Downtown Plan required large projects in the downtown area and nearby neighborhoods to provide public art worth at least one percent of the total construction cost. The requirement is in the Planning Code, Section 429, and the Planning Department oversees it (San Francisco Planning). A private downtown office building with a $100 million construction budget, as a hypothetical, would owe at least $1 million of public art, usually a work in or beside the building.
Since May 2012 a project can send part of its one percent obligation to the Public Art Trust. The Trust's money can pay for restoring works in the Civic Art Collection, for nonprofit capital projects and for temporary public art. The change gave developers an alternative to commissioning a piece on their own site and gave the city a flexible pool of conservation money.
Programs funded and run by the Commission
The formulas support a family of programs.
- The Civic Art Collection is the body of art the city owns. The Commission cares for it and has a gift policy, commissioning policies and guidelines for the collection, temporary public art and mural design approval.
- Shaping Legacy is a multi-year effort to review the monuments and memorials in the Civic Art Collection, with artists and communities taking part in guiding the work.
- Art on Market is a partnership with the SFMTA and an outdoor advertising company. Since 1992 it has commissioned new artworks every year, has worked with more than 130 artists and has commissioned over $1.2 million in art. The works appear as posters on Market Street.
- StreetSmARTS is a Public Works program run through the Arts Commission. It pairs artists with private property owners and city departments to create murals, which the program says also deter vandalism (The Mission's murals as public record).
- Civic Design Review examines civic capital projects to make sure they improve the public realm.
Grants, galleries and other support
Not all of the Commission's money comes out of construction budgets. Its Grants for the Arts program gives general operating support to arts and culture organizations, handled through the Commission's Community Investments division.
The Commission also runs galleries that are free to enter. The SFAC Main Gallery is in the War Memorial Veterans Building, and Art at City Hall shows works in City Hall's North Light Court and on the ground floor (San Francisco City Hall, the building). It operates Art Vendor Programs that help artists turn their art into a business, and it supports cultural centers that are partner organizations: the African American Art and Culture Complex, the American Indian Cultural Center, the Asian Pacific Islander Cultural Center, the Mission Cultural Center for Latino Arts, the Queer Cultural Center and SOMArts.
Housing is in the mix as well. The Commission provides information on affordable artist housing and on Artist Housing Certification, and one project, the Artists Hub on Market, which a nonprofit developer is building, is expected to open 94 affordable artist homes in early 2028. Film permits go through Film SF, the San Francisco Film Commission, which is part of the Arts Commission (Filming in the city and Film SF).
Questions people ask
Is the money a separate tax? No. The 2 percent is added to the budget of a covered project before a bond or appropriation is proposed, so it is part of what the building, park or transportation project costs, not a separate charge. The ordinance requires the sponsoring department to include it.
Who decides what art is bought? The ordinance says art enrichment includes works "as approved by the Arts Commission," and the Commission supervises and controls the spending. The commissioning policies are published on sf.gov, along with guidelines for the Civic Art Collection, temporary art and mural design approval, so anyone curious how a particular choice was made can read the rules that governed it.
Does the 2 percent pay for murals? Not as a general rule. Murals fall under a separate set of mural design approval guidelines, and the StreetSmARTS program pairs artists with property owners and city departments. The 2 percent rule is tied to the construction of covered city projects.
What if a department thinks the 2 percent is wrong for its project? It can propose a different budget to the Commission. If the two cannot agree, the dispute goes to the mayor, who has 60 days to settle it.
Does the art ever need repairs? Yes, which is why the ordinance lets the Commission set aside up to 10 percent of a project's allocation for maintenance and conservation, and why the Public Art Trust can pay to restore works in the Civic Art Collection.
Why is the downtown rule 1 percent when the city's own is 2? Different laws, different builders. The 2 percent rule dates to 1969 and covers city projects. The 1 percent rule came with the 1985 Downtown Plan, covers large private projects in the downtown area and is administered through the Planning Code.
Seeing the results
The best way to see the formulas at work is to walk a route. At Civic Center, the Main Gallery in the Veterans Building and the art in City Hall show the Commission's own exhibition work (Civic Center; Free things to do in San Francisco). In the Mission, the murals on the sides of buildings and down the alleys show a wider history of public painting, only part of it city-funded (Mission District). Along Market Street the posters are the Art on Market series. And at a new city building or park, the artwork near the entrance may have been bought under the 2 percent rule.
Timeline
| Year | Event |
|---|---|
| 1932 | The Arts Commission is created by the city charter |
| 1969 | The Art Enrichment Ordinance (2 percent for art) is enacted |
| 1985 | The Downtown Plan establishes the 1 percent private requirement |
| 1992 | Art on Market begins |
| 1997 | The Art Enrichment Ordinance is added to Administrative Code Section 3.19 |
| May 2012 | Projects can direct part of their 1 percent obligation to the Public Art Trust |
| 2014 | The ordinance is amended, effective August 30 |
| Early 2028 | The Artists Hub on Market is expected to open 94 affordable artist homes |