Blog

The Treaty of San Francisco, 1951

The September 8, 1951 peace treaty with Japan, signed on the War Memorial Opera House stage: who signed, who refused, what it settled and when it took effect.

Six years after delegates signed the United Nations Charter a few steps away, the Civic Center was back in the world's headlines. On September 8, 1951, on the stage of the War Memorial Opera House, representatives of dozens of countries signed the Treaty of Peace with Japan. Call it the Treaty of San Francisco, or the San Francisco Peace Treaty; either way it brought the state of war between Japan and most of its former enemies to a formal close.

Why a treaty was needed

Japan surrendered in September 1945, but a surrender is not a peace treaty. For the next six years the country was occupied, with the United States in the lead, and its sovereignty was limited. When and on what terms to end the occupation got tangled up in the early Cold War. The communist victory in China in 1949 and the outbreak of the Korean War in 1950 made Washington eager to settle the Japanese question and bring Japan into the western camp as a stable partner.

John Foster Dulles, who negotiated the treaty for the United States and is generally credited as its principal author, spent much of 1950 and 1951 traveling and consulting with allies. The result was a treaty meant to be generous to Japan by the standards of the time: no heavy reparations, no permanent restrictions, and sovereignty restored. The generosity was deliberate policy, and it drew objections from countries that had suffered under Japanese occupation.

Five days in September

The conference ran from September 4 to September 8, 1951. President Truman opened it on the first day with an address that spoke of Japan's wish to apply for membership in the United Nations. The Soviet delegation spent the opening days making procedural attempts to slow things down, and none succeeded. On the final day, September 8, the Soviets read a long statement of their objections before the signing began. The pattern is clear: the rules had been fixed in advance, the Soviet Union tested them, and the rules held. The signing went ahead on the schedule the United States and its allies had set, with 48 signatures where a longer negotiation might have produced a different count, and with the absent and dissenting states recorded in the same record as the signers.

Two security treaties at the Presidio

The Opera House was not the only San Francisco site that week. The State Department chose the Presidio of San Francisco, then headquarters of the Sixth U.S. Army, for two security treaties closely tied to the peace settlement. The ANZUS treaty, a pact among Australia, New Zealand and the United States in which the three countries pledged to aid one another against attack, was signed there on September 1. On September 8, after the peace treaty was signed at the Opera House, the United States and Japan signed their bilateral security treaty at the Presidio. Japan's prime minister, Yoshida Shigeru, signed it, and the American negotiator, Dulles, was photographed with him afterward.

The venue was the Enlisted Service Club, a Spanish Colonial Revival building that had opened July 14, 1949. Officers of the Sixth Army greeted the delegations, with the Sixth Army Band and an honor guard from the 701st Military Police Battalion, and soldiers handled security, setup, transportation, communications and food. Today the building is called the Golden Gate Club and is rented for events. The choice of a military post was deliberate: the security treaties were about armed forces, and the Presidio was the Army's western command (The Presidio, from army post to national park site).

The conference in the Civic Center

San Francisco was the host city, and the conference met in the Veterans Building and the Opera House. The city already had a tie to international gatherings from six years earlier, and the War Memorial complex, with its large halls, could take in delegations from many countries. The War Memorial's own history calls the 1951 conference America's first live coast-to-coast television broadcast, a sign of how much attention the occasion drew (The War Memorial Opera House and Davies Hall; The Veterans Building and the War Memorial).

The setting was formal. The treaty text had been negotiated in advance among the principal powers, so the San Francisco meeting was a place to present it and sign it, not a forum for rewriting it. That set 1951 apart from the 1945 conference, where the charter's wording was debated line by line over two months (The UN Charter signed in San Francisco, 1945).

Who signed and who did not

Fifty-one countries took part in the conference. Of those, 48 signed the treaty on September 8, by the standard count, though some accounts say 49 because of how a delegation is counted. Three participants refused to sign: Czechoslovakia, Poland and the Soviet Union. Several other invited states, among them Burma, India and Yugoslavia, did not take part at all. Neither government claiming to represent China was seated, because the allies disagreed over which was legitimate, and the question of Taiwan was handled in a separate bilateral treaty, the Treaty of Taipei.

Yoshida Shigeru signed for Japan. Dean Acheson, then Secretary of State, signed for the United States. Many of the other delegations were led by their foreign ministers or ambassadors.

The three refusals are worth understanding. The Soviet Union objected to the way the treaty dealt with territories Japan had held and with the American role in the Pacific, and it complained that the conference had not been set up to reopen the text. Poland and Czechoslovakia followed the Soviet line. Their objections did not stop the treaty from taking effect, but they left a legacy: the Soviet Union and Japan did not conclude a formal peace treaty in 1951, and the territorial questions between them stayed open for decades.

What the treaty did

Several provisions mattered most.

  • End of occupation. The treaty restored Japan's sovereignty. It entered into force April 28, 1952, once enough states had ratified it, and the Allied occupation ended that day.
  • Territory. In Article 2 Japan renounced its rights to Taiwan, the Pescadores, the Spratly and Paracel Islands and other territories it had held. Disputes over some of those places remain live today.
  • Reparations. Article 14 dealt with reparations. It recognized that Japan's resources were not enough to pay in full for the damage it had caused, so the treaty provided for services and other forms of compensation and let individual countries negotiate arrangements.
  • Sovereignty and security. A separate security treaty between the United States and Japan was signed the same day, September 8, at the Presidio. It allowed American land, sea and air forces to be stationed on Japanese territory, and it became the foundation of the alliance between the two countries.

The treaty is often read as a bargain: Japan accepted losses of territory and a limited path on reparations, and in exchange got a quick return to sovereignty and a place in the postwar order.

A table of the treaty's reach

Item Detail
Date signed September 8, 1951
Venue War Memorial Opera House, San Francisco
Participating countries 51
Signed 48 (some accounts say 49)
Refused to sign Czechoslovakia, Poland, Soviet Union
In force April 28, 1952
Japan signed by Yoshida Shigeru
United States signed by Dean Acheson

The treaty and the city

For San Francisco the treaty is a point of civic pride and a point of history. The city had hosted the founding of the United Nations in 1945, and in 1951 it hosted the peace settlement with a former wartime enemy. Together the two events made the Civic Center, in the eyes of historians, a place where the postwar order was made.

The treaty had a local side too. The Bay Area had a large Japanese American community, and only nine years earlier the city's Japanese residents had been removed under Executive Order 9066 (Executive Order 9066 and Japantown). A peace treaty with Japan signed in a hall a short distance from the Western Addition came while many Japanese Americans were rebuilding lives and businesses the war had interrupted. The Japan Center, which opened in 1968, would come within two decades.

Seeing the place

The Opera House stage where the treaty was signed is the stage the San Francisco Opera and San Francisco Ballet still use, with 3,006 seats in the house. The Veterans Building next door holds the Herbst Theatre, the hall used for the UN Charter signing in 1945. Both are on Van Ness Avenue, opposite City Hall, and both can be seen from the sidewalk any day of the week (A walk around Civic Center; Civic Center).

The War Memorial's performance calendars list current productions, and anyone who buys a ticket will be sitting where delegates from dozens of nations once sat. For free ways to spend time in the Civic Center, the city's free events and the public gallery in the Veterans Building are good places to start (Free things to do in San Francisco).

From signature to force

A treaty does not take effect the moment it is signed. The Treaty of San Francisco was signed September 8, 1951, and entered into force April 28, 1952, which is 233 days later. In that interval the signatory governments went through their own ratification procedures, and the allied occupation of Japan, which had begun in 1945, stayed in place until the treaty came into force. Counted from the surrender of September 2, 1945, to the day sovereignty returned, the occupation lasted a little under seven years. The five days in San Francisco were the diplomatic center of that long process, and the 233 days afterward were its legal conclusion.

Reading the treaty today

The Treaty of San Francisco still matters because the arrangements it created are still in place. Japan's borders and the status of disputed islands in the Pacific, the American military presence in Japan and the reparations settlements with Southeast Asian countries all trace to the 1951 text or to the agreements made under it. Foreign-policy writers still cite it. When an international dispute turns on whether a territory was or was not renounced in 1951, the paper trail begins at the Opera House in San Francisco.

Related guides

Related neighborhoods

Latest on this topic