Blog
The Sanctuary Ordinance: what the city says
Questions and answers on San Francisco's Sanctuary Ordinance: its 1989 origin, what city employees may not do, how complaints work and the Rapid Response line.
Few phrases in American politics have been stretched as far as "sanctuary city." Out in the national argument it is a slogan; at City Hall it is a specific piece of local law with a chapter number. As the city describes it, the Sanctuary Ordinance is a set of rules about what San Francisco employees and departments may and may not do when federal immigration authorities come calling. What follows takes the common questions in turn, reports what the city says the ordinance does, how a resident raises a complaint and where help is to be had. It takes no side in the national fight, and it is general information, not legal advice.
What is the Sanctuary Ordinance?
It is a local law in the city's Administrative Code, in Chapters 12H and 12I. The older chapter goes back to 1989, when the Board of Supervisors passed it as the "City and County of Refuge" Ordinance. In 2013 the city added a second ordinance, "Due Process for All," which set limits on notifying federal immigration authorities of jail releases and on honoring requests known as detainers. Both were last amended in July 2016, according to the city.
The thing to understand is that this is a rule about city government's own conduct. It governs what San Francisco employees, departments and resources do. It does not and cannot change federal immigration law, and it does not stop federal agents from carrying out federal duties inside the city limits.
What may city employees not do?
By the city's account, the ordinance bars employees from:
- Using city resources to help federal immigration authorities with investigations, detentions or arrests tied to alleged civil immigration violations.
- Asking about immigration status on applications for city benefits, services or opportunities, unless federal or state law, regulation or a court decision requires it.
- Limiting city services or benefits on the basis of immigration status, unless federal or state law, public assistance eligibility criteria or a court decision requires it.
- Sharing the release status or personal information of any person, except in limited circumstances in which law enforcement may answer a federal request for notice of an upcoming release.
- Holding a person on a civil immigration detainer after they become eligible for release.
There is a qualification, and it is an important one: the general bar on assisting federal immigration enforcement does not apply when federal or state law requires the assistance. The ordinance limits discretionary cooperation. It does not override a legal requirement.
What does the city say the purpose is?
Public trust. The city says residents should be able to call police and fire and use public health programs whatever their immigration status. The reasoning runs like this: a person who fears that a 911 call or a clinic visit could lead to an immigration consequence may stay quiet about a crime or skip care, and that leaves the whole neighborhood less safe or less healthy. The city also notes that some federally funded programs may carry different rules, record-keeping and reporting requirements, so the ordinance's limits are not the whole story for every service.
The departments most affected are the ones that deal with residents most directly: the police, the Sheriff's Office, the public health system and the Human Services Agency, among others (San Francisco Police Department, San Francisco Sheriff's Office).
What do critics say?
The ordinance has been argued over for decades. Supporters make the city's case: trust between immigrant communities and local government improves public safety and public health, and federal immigration enforcement is a federal job that local taxpayers and employees should not be asked to do. Critics answer that local limits on cooperation can keep federal agencies from reaching people they believe pose a danger, and that detainers and release notices help enforce federal law. Both sides point to particular cases. Where local authority ends and federal authority begins has been fought over in public and in court, and a resident who wants the details can turn to the City Attorney's materials and the court record (City Attorney).
California has its own law on the subject, setting limits on state and local cooperation across the state. The city's ordinance operates alongside it.
How does someone file a complaint?
Complaints about alleged violations go to the Human Rights Commission, and the form lives at sf.gov/file-sanctuary-city-ordinance-complaint. A resident who thinks a city employee shared information or helped federal immigration enforcement outside the ordinance's rules can file there. The commission handles the complaint through its own process and sets its own pace, so a complainant should ask the commission what to expect.
For lesser trouble, such as a service denied or a question about whether a form may ask something, a resident can start with 311, which runs around the clock and serves callers in over 160 languages, or with the department involved (Using 311 in San Francisco, by phone, app or web, SF311 Customer Service Center).
Where can someone get help?
The city points to several resources. Its "Know your rights" page on sf.gov summarizes the general rules, says plainly that it is general information and not legal advice, and tells anyone with a specific situation to talk to a licensed attorney. It comes in English, Spanish, Traditional Chinese, Filipino and Vietnamese. A few points from it:
- If stopped on the street, a person can ask the officer, "Am I free to go?" If the answer is yes, they can leave. If not, they can stay silent and ask for a lawyer.
- If officers come to the home, a person does not have to open the door. They can ask officers to slip a judicial warrant under the door, and without a judicial warrant there is no obligation to let officers in. An administrative warrant, issued by an immigration official or the Department of Homeland Security, also does not require a person to allow entry.
- If arrested, a person has the right to an attorney and the right to remain silent, and the page advises against signing anything without a lawyer.
The city lists the SF Rapid Response Hotline at 415-200-1548, which connects people to legal assistance and support services, and an Immigrant Support Hub on its website. The hotline is run with community organizations that provide legal help.
The Office of Civic Engagement and Immigrant Affairs, part of the City Administrator's group of departments, coordinates much of the city's work with immigrant communities. It can be reached at 415-554-0600 or [email protected] (The Office of Civic Engagement and Immigrant Affairs, Office of the City Administrator).
More questions
Does it cover the schools and City College? The ordinance governs city departments. The San Francisco Unified School District and City College of San Francisco are separate bodies with their own elected boards, legally distinct from city government, so questions about their policies go to those institutions (San Francisco Unified School District).
Does it cover the Superior Court? No. The Superior Court of California, County of San Francisco, is a state court, not a city department, and state and federal law govern what it does (Superior Court of California, County of San Francisco).
Is the ordinance the same as state law? No. California has a separate state statute that sets limits on cooperation statewide. The city's ordinance is a local law with its own text and its own complaint process, and the two work together.
Can the rules change? Yes. The ordinance sits in the Administrative Code and the Board of Supervisors can amend it, as it did in 2016; the city's pages show the current version. The full text of Chapters 12H and 12I can be found through the city's legislative research tools (How an idea becomes an ordinance at the Board of Supervisors).
Where does the money come from for legal help? The city describes immigration legal help and a rapid-response network run with community partners. The appropriations for these programs show up in the city's budget documents.
Does the ordinance change daily life?
For most residents it is invisible. A person who calls 911, visits a clinic, borrows a library book or signs a child up for school never meets it. It matters in a narrow set of cases, when federal immigration authorities ask local agencies for help, and it shapes what the Sheriff's Office does at the jail and what forms ask. The city's stated goal is that people use services without fear of being asked about their status unless a law requires it.
San Francisco's history goes some way toward explaining why the city took this road. It has been a port of entry for immigrants since the Gold Rush, and it has a record of both welcoming and shutting out newcomers, from the Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882 to the forced removal of Japanese Americans in 1942 (Chinese exclusion and San Francisco, The Angel Island Immigration Station, 1910 to 1940). A large share of the city's residents were born abroad, so immigration is a practical subject of city policy as well as a political one.
A note on limits
The ordinance covers the city's own employees and resources. It does not govern federal agents, state agencies or private businesses, and it creates no legal immunity for anyone. A person facing a legal problem should seek advice from a licensed attorney, and the city's pages list resources for finding one. The Rapid Response line is the place to start for people who need an attorney quickly, and the Office of Civic Engagement and Immigrant Affairs is where to ask about anything else.