Blog

The occupation of Alcatraz, 1969 to 1971

The 19-month occupation that began November 20, 1969, from the 1964 landing to the 1971 removal, and why it matters to Native self-determination.

Most people know Alcatraz for the penitentiary, which held its prisoners from 1934 to 1963. The more consequential chapter came after the cell doors were locked for good. On November 20, 1969, a group calling itself Indians of All Tribes landed on the empty island in San Francisco Bay and stayed nineteen months. The occupation was a protest, a community and an argument about who owns land the government no longer wants, and it is remembered now as one of the founding events of the modern Native American rights movement.

The first landings

There was a precedent five years earlier. On March 9, 1964, five Sicangu Lakota people, led by Belva Cottier and Richard McKenzie, took Alcatraz for about four hours. They rested their claim on an 1868 treaty with the Sioux that, as they read it, gave Native people the right to claim surplus federal land. The landing was short and ended with nothing to show for it, but the idea was out in the open.

The federal government had declared the island surplus after the penitentiary closed in 1963, and it sat empty in the middle of the bay in plain view of Fisherman's Wharf and the Marin shore (Fisherman's Wharf). Its empty buildings and its place on every postcard drew attention again in the late 1960s, when Native activists in the Bay Area were looking for a public stage for their grievances.

On November 9, 1969, Richard Oakes, a Mohawk activist, and a group of supporters made a brief symbolic landing and left the same evening. Eleven days later, on November 20, the full occupation began. About 100 Native people came ashore at first, including some 80 students from UCLA, along with Bay Area residents and activists. They called themselves Indians of All Tribes.

Why a Bay Area protest

The occupation drew on a population that federal policy had helped create. In the 1950s the government encouraged Native people to leave reservations for cities, through relocation programs that offered job training and a one-way trip to places like San Francisco and Oakland. At the same time Washington was pursuing termination, a policy of ending the federal government's special relationship with tribal nations. By the late 1960s the Bay Area had a large, young urban Native community, many of whom had grown up away from their home reservations and found in the city both opportunity and isolation.

That community had its own institutions, the San Francisco Indian Center among them, and many accounts of the occupation point to the center's loss in a fire in the fall of 1969 as a spur to action. Students on Bay Area campuses, including the group of UCLA students who joined the first wave on November 20, brought organizing experience from the campus protests of the period. An occupation of an island everyone could see, in the same decade as the Free Speech Movement and the civil rights marches, gave a long-standing set of grievances a stage (The Summer of Love, 1967 covers the same city at the same moment, from a different angle).

The island's own history

What the island had been mattered to the occupiers as well. Before it was a military post and a penitentiary, Alcatraz was a lighthouse station and a fortification, and before that a bare rock with seabirds (alcatraz as lighthouse and bird sanctuary). The federal prison there ran from 1934 to 1963, and when it closed the government declared the island surplus. To the occupiers that status was the legal hook: the land was federal property no longer in use, and on their reading of the treaty it could be claimed.

What they wanted

The occupiers' statement was addressed to "the Great White Father and all his people." It drew on the Treaty of Fort Laramie of 1868 to argue that unused federal land should revert to Native peoples. More concretely, they asked for the deed to the island and for it to become a Native American cultural and educational center. The proposals included a university, a cultural center and a museum, and the occupiers described an island that would serve Native people across the Bay Area and beyond.

The demands were bold, and the protest behind them was deliberately visible. Alcatraz sat in the middle of a major metropolitan area, in front of a large audience, with a name everyone knew. Few places in the country could have offered a better stage.

The federal government refused the demands for a deed, a university, a cultural center and a museum. It did not remove the occupiers by force at the start, though, and that gave the occupation time to grow.

Life on the island

In the first months the occupation was organized and energetic. The island had no regular water or power beyond what the government provided, and supplies came in by boat. Residents set up a school for children, a kitchen, a clinic and a governing council. Supporters from around the country sent food and money and came to visit. On December 22, the Berkeley radio station KPFA-FM began a daily broadcast from the island called Radio Free Alcatraz, hosted by John Trudell, a Santee Sioux activist. Affiliated stations in New York and Los Angeles carried it too, and it took the occupiers' message to a national audience.

By early 1970 the community was under strain. The population shifted as students went back to school and others came and went. Organization loosened, and the group on the island grew to include people who were not Native, some of them from the San Francisco counterculture, which caused friction. On January 5, 1970, Richard Oakes's 13-year-old stepdaughter, Yvonne, died after a fall inside one of the island's buildings. Oakes left the island after her death, and with him went one of the occupation's most visible leaders.

In the following months the federal government changed its approach. It shut off the island's electrical power and removed the water barge that had supplied the occupiers. A few days later a fire destroyed several of the historic buildings. Participants and observers have disputed who was responsible ever since. Three occupiers were also arrested and convicted for selling about 600 pounds of copper taken from the island's fittings. Each of these events cost the occupation public sympathy, and the population on the island fell.

The end of the occupation

In January 1971 two oil tankers collided at the entrance to San Francisco Bay, an accident that drew attention to the island's position and to the risk of an environmental disaster. President Nixon then approved a plan to remove the occupiers. In June 1971, federal officers took the remaining residents off the island. The removal was peaceful, and the people they found were five women, four children and six unarmed men. The occupation officially ended on June 10 or 11, 1971, depending on the source, after nineteen months.

The island went back to federal control. In the following years the National Park Service took it over as part of the Golden Gate National Recreation Area and opened it to the public. Alcatraz today is a National Historic Landmark run by the National Park Service, and the occupation is part of the story told to visitors (alcatraz in four chapters; Visiting Alcatraz in practice).

What it changed

The occupation did not win the island, but its effects reached far past its demands.

  • Federal policy. The National Park Service's own account credits the occupation, directly or indirectly, with ending the federal policy of tribal termination, which had sought to end the government's special relationship with Native nations, and with making self-determination the official policy of the United States. The shift began in the Nixon administration.
  • Land returned. President Nixon returned Blue Lake and about 48,000 acres to the Taos Pueblo, a long-contested case that supporters of the occupation saw as part of the same change in federal attitudes.
  • Education. Occupied land near Davis, California, became the site of a Native American university.
  • Federal hiring. An occupation of the Bureau of Indian Affairs offices in Washington, D.C., later led to the hiring of Native Americans in that agency.
  • A model for protest. The occupation inspired later actions and handed a generation of activists a template for public, symbolic and sustained protest.

It is fair to add what it did not achieve. The government denied the central demands, and the cultural center and university on the island were never built. So the occupation's meaning has always been argued as much as its results: a victory of visibility and policy to some, an unfinished claim to others.

A timeline

Date Event
1934 to 1963 Alcatraz is a federal penitentiary
March 9, 1964 Five Sicangu Lakota occupy the island for about four hours
November 9, 1969 A brief symbolic landing led by Richard Oakes
November 20, 1969 The full occupation begins
December 22, 1969 Radio Free Alcatraz begins on KPFA
January 5, 1970 The death of Yvonne Oakes; Oakes leaves the island
1970 Power and water are cut; a fire destroys several buildings
January 1971 Two tankers collide at the bay's entrance; Nixon approves a removal plan
June 1971 The last occupiers are removed

Remembering it on the island

Visitors to Alcatraz can still find traces of the occupation. Graffiti the occupiers left, including the words "Indians Welcome" and "Peace and Freedom," remains visible on the island, and the National Park Service's interpretive programs include Native voices and the occupation's history. Native groups gather on the island to remember the occupation and to honor the people who took part (alcatraz as lighthouse and bird sanctuary).

For a wider look at what to see around the waterfront, including the ferry departure area at Fisherman's Wharf, see Fisherman's Wharf, and for ideas on a day that costs little, Free things to do in San Francisco.

Related guides

Related neighborhoods

Latest on this topic