Blog
Alcatraz in four chapters
From fortress and military prison to federal penitentiary, the 1969-1971 Native American occupation and National Park Service care, Alcatraz in four parts.
A little over a mile off the Fisherman's Wharf waterfront sits a small rock that has been a lighthouse site, a fortress, a military jail, a federal penitentiary, a protest camp and a national park. The best-known chapter, the prison that held the gangsters, lasted only 29 years. The island's other uses cover a far longer span and say more about how the United States has treated its remote places. Here is the island's history, cut into four chapters.
What the name means
The name comes from the Spanish. In 1775 the explorer Juan Manuel de Ayala charted San Francisco Bay and named an island there Isla de los Alcatraces, an old word usually translated as pelican or seabird island. His island was the one now called Yerba Buena. Over the years the name drifted to the smaller rock to the west and stuck to the place where the prison would later stand.
The bird connection is real. The island is a nesting ground for seabirds, and its colonies include western gulls, cormorants, Brandt's cormorants, pigeon guillemots, Heermann's gulls and black-crowned night herons. Parts of the island are managed to protect nesting birds (alcatraz as lighthouse and bird sanctuary).
Chapter one: the fortress and the military prison
The first chapter belongs to the Army. After the Gold Rush, the United States wanted the entrance to San Francisco Bay defended, and the Army Corps of Engineers began fortifying the island in 1853. The first fort was completed in 1858. The island also held the first lighthouse on the West Coast.
During the Civil War, from 1861 to 1865, the fort mounted 85 cannons, later 105, and held Confederate sympathizers and prisoners of war. Its guns never fired at an enemy. Troop strength peaked at 433 in early 1865. In 1861 the island also began to serve as the military prison for the Department of the Pacific, and it kept that role for decades. On March 21, 1907, the Army officially designated Alcatraz the Western U.S. Military Prison.
The Army kept using it as a prison for the same reason the Bureau of Prisons would later choose it: cold, fast-moving water all around makes escape difficult. A guard on the island could see the whole shoreline, and the nearest land was a long swim away.
Chapter two: the federal penitentiary
In October 1933 the Justice Department acquired the site, and the Army's disciplinary barracks passed to the Bureau of Prisons. The federal penitentiary operated from August 11, 1934, to March 21, 1963. It was built to hold the inmates other federal prisons could not manage, which earned it a reputation as the toughest prison in the system.
Its best-known inmates were Al Capone, who was in Cell 181; Robert Stroud, the "Birdman of Alcatraz"; George "Machine Gun" Kelly; and Alvin "Creepy" Karpis, who served more time on the island than any other inmate. The popular image of Alcatraz owes a great deal to these names and to the films made about them.
The escape record is part of the story. In the penitentiary's history, 36 prisoners made 14 escape attempts. Twenty-three were caught alive, six were shot and killed, two drowned, and five are listed as missing and presumed drowned. The most famous attempt came on June 11, 1962, when Frank Morris and the brothers John and Clarence Anglin escaped and were never found. Officials believe they drowned, though the case remains a staple of popular speculation. The prison closed less than a year later, on March 21, 1963, in part because it was expensive to run on an island, where everything, fresh water included, had to be brought in.
The penitentiary in numbers
A few sums put the prison's record in proportion.
- Length of service. From August 11, 1934, to March 21, 1963, the penitentiary ran for 28 years and about seven months, a little under 29 years.
- Escape attempts. There were 14 attempts involving 36 prisoners. Of the 36, 23 were caught alive, 6 were shot and killed, 2 drowned and 5 are missing and presumed drowned. Those four groups add up to 36.
- Unsolved case. Frank Morris and John and Clarence Anglin, who escaped on June 11, 1962, are the best known of the men never found, and their case is the one that is never settled.
- Time as a fortress. The Army's use of the island, from the first fortification in 1853 to the transfer to the Justice Department in October 1933, lasted about 80 years, nearly three times the length of the penitentiary.
That last figure is the one most visitors do not expect. The prison that gave the island its fame is the shorter of its two institutional lives, and the Army's long tenure left the island's older buildings, foundations and fortifications.
Chapter three: the occupation, 1969 to 1971
The third chapter began on November 20, 1969, when a group of Native American activists, calling themselves Indians of All Tribes, occupied the island and claimed it under an old treaty provision about surplus federal land. The occupation lasted about 19 months, until June 11, 1971. At its height it drew supporters from across the country, and it became one of the best-known protests of its time.
The National Park Service describes the occupation as a founding event of the American Indian Red Power movement. A 1964 attempt had come first, and the 1969 occupation reached much further, with a radio broadcast, a public voice for the occupiers and a flow of supplies by boat. Several buildings on the island were damaged or destroyed by fire during the occupation. It ended when federal officials removed the last occupiers, but it left a lasting mark on federal Indian policy and on how Americans think about the island (The occupation of Alcatraz, 1969 to 1971).
The occupiers' messages are still visible. Graffiti from the occupation survives on some buildings, and the park service treats it as part of the historic record.
Chapter four: a national park
The fourth chapter began in 1972, when the island became part of the Golden Gate National Recreation Area, managed by the National Park Service. On January 17, 1986, it was designated a National Historic Landmark. Since then the island has been a visitor site. The park service maintains the cellhouse, the guard buildings and the gardens, and it runs the programs that explain the island's history to visitors.
Published visitor figures range from nearly 1.4 million a year to 1.7 million in a 2018 report. The island sits in the same national recreation area as the Presidio and the shoreline parks (The Presidio, from army post to national park site).
A four-part timeline
- 1775. Ayala names an island in the bay Isla de los Alcatraces. The name later moves to the smaller rock.
- 1853 to 1858. The Army fortifies the island, and the first fort is finished in 1858.
- 1861. The fort begins to serve as the military prison for the Department of the Pacific.
- March 21, 1907. Alcatraz is officially designated the Western U.S. Military Prison.
- October 1933. The Justice Department acquires the site.
- August 11, 1934. The federal penitentiary opens.
- June 11, 1962. Morris and the Anglin brothers escape.
- March 21, 1963. The penitentiary closes.
- November 20, 1969. The occupation begins, lasting until June 11, 1971.
- 1972. The island becomes part of the Golden Gate National Recreation Area.
- January 17, 1986. It is designated a National Historic Landmark.
Visiting in practice
Alcatraz can be reached only by ferry, and a visit takes a half day. The National Park Service's page for the island, at nps.gov/alca, is the official starting point for tickets, the schedule and the programs on the island. The ferries leave from the Fisherman's Wharf area, a cable car ride from Union Square (Fisherman's Wharf).
A few things help a first-time visitor plan.
- Buy ahead. The visit is popular and the boats run on a schedule. The park's own page is the place to check what is offered and when.
- Wear layers. The bay is cold and windy, even in summer, and the island is exposed. The seasons chapter of the city's guides covers what to pack (seasons and what to pack).
- Expect stairs and slopes. The island rises from the dock to the cellhouse on a steep path, and some parts are not easily accessible. The park service describes what is available.
- Bring children with some preparation. The cellhouse tour is an audio tour about the prison, and parents may want to preview it (Visiting San Francisco with kids).
Alcatraz is a federal site within the Golden Gate National Recreation Area, not a city one. The National Park Service runs the island and its programs, and the city's connection to it is geographic: it lies within sight of the waterfront.
Why it still draws people
Alcatraz holds three different stories at once, and each draws a different audience. For readers of American crime history, it is the home of famous prisoners and an escape that was never solved. For readers of Native American history, it is the site of the occupation that opened a new period of activism. For readers of military and engineering history, it is a Civil War fortress and a showcase of coastal defense. The cellhouse, the guard towers and the gardens make all three visible in a single walk, which explains how a rock the size of a few city blocks became one of the most visited places in the country.