Blog
Alcatraz as lighthouse and bird sanctuary
Beyond the prison, Alcatraz was the West Coast's first lighthouse station and is now a seabird colony and garden island; what nests there and when to look.
Everybody knows Alcatraz was a prison. The federal penitentiary ran there from 1934 to 1963, held some of the best-known inmates in American crime history, and the cell house is the main reason people ride the ferry. But twenty-nine years is a short stretch of a long story. Before the penitentiary the island had a Civil War fort and a military prison, and before that a lighthouse that steered ships through the Golden Gate in the first years after the Gold Rush. Today it has a nesting colony of seabirds and a set of old gardens that the National Park Service tends alongside the cell house. The island is 22 acres of rock in the middle of a busy bay, and every period of its past left a layer.
The name and the pelicans
The name is Spanish. In 1775 the navigator Juan Manuel de Ayala sailed into San Francisco Bay and called the rocky island La Isla de los Alcatraces, usually translated as the island of the pelicans or of the large seabirds. The birds are built into the name, and when Ayala's chart went into the record, the island's identity as a seabird place came first. It had no fresh water, little soil and almost no vegetation, which made it useless for farming and good for birds and for anyone who wanted a place hard to leave (alcatraz in four chapters).
The first lighthouse on the West Coast
Alcatraz was the first lighthouse station on the West Coast of the United States, built after the 1849 Gold Rush made San Francisco one of the busiest ports on the Pacific. Fog and strong tidal currents made the Golden Gate and the central bay dangerous, and ships coming in after dark needed a light on the island. The station was lit in 1854, in a building at the island's high point, and the keeper's family lived on the rock. When the Army fortified the island in the 1850s, the lighthouse sat inside its works.
The first tower was later replaced. In 1909 a new, taller lighthouse went up on the island. The light kept working through the federal prison years, run by the Lighthouse Service and then the Coast Guard, and the lighthouse is still a landmark that visitors can see from the ferry as they approach the dock.
In one respect the lighthouse and the later prison did the same job. Both made use of the island's isolation. Ships needed a light because the Golden Gate is a narrow, windy channel, and the Army and later the Bureau of Prisons wanted a place ringed by cold, fast water.
Gardens made of imported soil
The island is bare rock, so everything green on it was carried in. Families of the Army and the Lighthouse Service hauled soil and plants over and made gardens in terraces and pockets around their housing. Remnants of those gardens survive, and the National Park Service calls them one of the island's less-noticed historic features. The planting dates from the residents who lived there between the 1850s and the 1960s, and the gardens became known for unexpected color against the bare stone.
After the prison closed in 1963, the plants ran wild for decades. Park staff and volunteers, working with the park's nonprofit partner, have restored many of the beds, which now bloom in spring and early summer. A visitor walking up the main road from the dock can pass them without noticing, so look at the terraces and the plantings beside the old buildings.
A bird sanctuary beside a prison
The most important ecological fact about Alcatraz is that it is a nesting site for seabirds and waterbirds. According to the National Park Service, species that nest on the island include:
- Western gulls, the large gulls that are the most conspicuous birds on the island and nest on ledges, rooftops and bare ground;
- Brandt's cormorants, dark diving birds that nest in colonies on the island's cliffs;
- Black-crowned night herons, which roost and nest in the trees and shrubs that grow near the buildings;
- Egrets, which nest in the same wooded patches;
- Pigeon guillemots, black seabirds with bright red feet that nest in crevices in the rock and in the walls.
The nesting birds are counted each year, and the park adjusts its management to limit disturbance from February through September. In practice some trails and areas are closed or restricted during nesting season, and visitors are asked to stay on marked paths and keep clear of nests and chicks. The bird colony is part of why the island is protected as part of Golden Gate National Recreation Area (Crissy Field and the Presidio shoreline).
The best time to watch birds on Alcatraz runs from late winter through early summer. At the dock, an information station offers a checklist called "Birds on the Rock" for ticking off what you see. On a spring visit you can watch gulls on eggs, cormorants collecting nesting material and herons in the trees, and the noise and smell of the colony are impossible to miss. Bring binoculars if you have them, since the cliffs and cormorant colonies are viewed from a distance.
A year on the rock
The island changes with the calendar, and the changes are easy to read once you know what to look for.
- Winter (December to February). Rain and wind sweep the island, and the park advises rain gear in the wet months; the bookstores on the island sell it. Birds are present but the nesting season has not begun, and the ferry ride is the quietest of the year. The wet season in the downtown normals runs roughly November to April (The wet season, November to April).
- Late winter and spring (February to June). Birds return to their ledges. February is when the park's seasonal management of nesting areas begins, and by April the gulls, cormorants and herons are active. The gardens come into bloom. This is the best stretch for birdwatching, with the largest numbers and the most activity.
- Summer (June to August). Chicks fledge, and the island fills with visitors. The fog is thick, and a cold wind blows even when downtown is warm. Visitors who want quiet stay off the midday ferries.
- Early fall (September). The nesting season management period ends in September, and the downtown normals show it as the warmest month of the year, with an average high of 70.2 degrees; the water and the sky are often clearest then (september, the warmest month downtown).
The park's practical advice holds all year: wear layers and shoes with grip soles, avoid sandals, high heels and leather soles on the island's wet and sloping paths, and plan to eat before or after, since the only food sold on the island is dry snacks and candy at the bookstore.
How the park counts what it protects
Managing a bird colony on a visited island comes down mostly to data. Park biologists survey the nesting birds each year, counting nests and birds by species, and use the results to decide which parts of the island to close and for how long. Two things follow for visitors. Some closures are not permanent: an area that is off-limits in April may reopen in October. And the park posts bird-related notices on signs and in the visitor information station, and following them is the main way visitors affect the colony's success.
The count also builds a record. A colony of Brandt's cormorants that grows or shrinks from year to year tells biologists something about the fish stocks in the bay and the ocean beyond the Golden Gate. A visitor who spots a cormorant on a ledge is looking at one data point in a decades-long study.
Why the birds and the prison coexist
The prison made the island's birds possible, in an indirect way. The federal penitentiary kept the public away for nearly three decades, and for many years afterward the island was closed or only lightly visited. Without people, the birds found the ledges and trees safe from disturbance, and after the prison closed they moved into the abandoned buildings and the overgrown gardens. That is one reason the island is now an important nesting site on San Francisco Bay.
The park's managers face a balancing act that is rare in the national park system: a national historic landmark, visited by well over a million people in a typical year before the pandemic, that is also a bird colony. The solution is seasonal management and a narrow visitor footprint, which means keeping visitors on set paths, restricting areas during the nesting season and making the ferry landing and the cell house the main destinations.
Other layers: the Army, the occupation and the lighthouse's neighbors
The military period ran from 1850 to 1934. The Army built a fortress to guard the bay, fitted it with cannons and later used the island as a military prison, including during the Civil War. The federal penitentiary took over in 1934 and operated until 1963. In 1964 a group of American Indian activists briefly claimed the island under an old treaty, and from November 20, 1969 to June 1971 a group calling itself Indians of All Tribes occupied it for nineteen months. That occupation, a landmark in Native American activism, is a chapter of its own (The occupation of Alcatraz, 1969 to 1971).
When the occupiers left, the island came under the National Park Service as part of Golden Gate National Recreation Area, and the park service has been responsible for it since. The lighthouse, the cell house, the gardens, the occupation-era graffiti and the bird colonies all fall under that responsibility, which is why one island needs so many kinds of caretaking.
Visiting with the birds in mind
Alcatraz can be reached only by ferry. Alcatraz City Cruises, a private company under contract to the National Park Service, runs the service from Pier 33 on the Embarcadero, south of Bay Street, and the Muni F line stops by the landing. The practical details of tickets and planning the day are covered in the visit guide (Visiting Alcatraz in practice). For anyone who cares about the birds, a few extra tips apply:
- Go in spring. April through June is the peak of nesting activity, with chicks on the ledges, and the gardens are in bloom.
- Take the "Birds on the Rock" checklist from the dock information station.
- Stay on the paths. Closures during February through September protect nests, and the park's rangers enforce them.
- Look up and out as well as in. The ferry ride passes pelicans and cormorants on the bay, and the water around the island has its own bird traffic.
- Bring layers. The island is windy and cool even on a warm day in the city (seasons and what to pack).
The cell house will always be the main attraction. But the island's longer record, a navigational light, a garden made of imported dirt and a colony of seabirds, is why it has lasted as a landmark, and it is the part of the visit most likely to surprise someone who came for the prison.