Blog

The Golden Gate International Exposition, 1939

How the bay was dredged into Treasure Island for the 1939 fair, what it celebrated, why the first season ended early and how the Navy got the island.

Most world's fairs borrow a park. San Francisco's 1939 fair built its own ground. In the middle of the bay, beside the rocky shoulder of Yerba Buena Island, dredges piled up an artificial island of 385 acres, and on that new land the city staged a two-season celebration of the Pacific and of the two great bridges just finished. The fair came and went. The island stayed, and it still carries the plan drawn for it in the mid-1930s.

A fair that began as a letter

It started small. In 1933 a letter to the editor of The San Francisco News proposed an exposition to mark the coming completion of the Bay Bridge and the Golden Gate Bridge. Organizers incorporated San Francisco Bay Exposition, Inc. in July 1934, and in February 1935 they settled on a site no one had used before: the Yerba Buena Shoals, a shallow area on the north side of Yerba Buena Island that lay directly in the new bridge's path (The Bay Bridge opens, 1936).

A shoal was a clever choice, and for a particular reason. The Bay Bridge was to run through a tunnel in Yerba Buena Island, so a flat island attached to it would have road access from the day the bridge opened. Backers had a second purpose in mind as well. San Francisco had been talking since 1931 about a municipal airport on the bay, and the fair's island was meant to become that airport once the exhibits came down.

The money came largely from Washington. President Roosevelt approved $3 million toward reclaiming the land, and the federal government did the construction. The scale of the work is hard to picture from the island today: about 19 million cubic yards of fill went into the 385-acre site, and dredging began on February 11, 1936. The new land was joined to Yerba Buena Island, which is why Treasure Island and Yerba Buena Island read as one place on a map yet are two very different pieces of terrain. One is a natural hill; the other is a flat, engineered platform.

Pacifica, the style of the fair

The designers got an unusual brief: make a place that looked as if it belonged to the whole Pacific Rim. Their answer was a style the fair itself called Pacifica, a streamlined Art Deco that borrowed forms from Asian, Latin American and Spanish Colonial buildings. William P. Day served as director of works. George W. Kelham, the fair's chief architect, died in October 1936, and Arthur Brown Jr. took over the design work. The two names count for San Franciscans for a second reason: Brown and Kelham were also among the architects of the city's civic buildings, and Brown was one of the pair behind City Hall.

The theme was "Pageant of the Pacific." Its symbols were the Tower of the Sun, the central vertical accent of the grounds, and an 80-foot statue of Pacifica, goddess of the Pacific Ocean. A Chinese village designed by Mark Daniels was built and managed by George Jue.

For comparison, the 1915 Panama-Pacific International Exposition had looked back to classical Europe and used the Marina's fill for its ground (The Panama-Pacific International Exposition, 1915). The 1939 fair looked outward and chose to float its fair on the bay. Each was a deliberate statement about where San Francisco saw itself in the world.

Two seasons, one midway

The first season ran from February 18 to October 29, 1939. A schedule had once called for the fair to run into early December, but the first season closed about a month ahead of that, a sign that the books were not balancing. A second, shorter season opened May 25 and ended September 29, 1940. In all, about 17 million visits were recorded across the two seasons.

The fair had a midway, called the Gayway after a naming contest in 1938. It covered 40 acres and held rides, sideshows and the kind of attractions a fair's more sober halls did not. Sally Rand's "Nude Ranch" was among the best known. In the 1940 season organizers added an Art in Action exhibition, in which working artists painted, carved and printed in front of the public. Two works made that summer survive in the city: Diego Rivera's mural Pan American Unity, now at City College of San Francisco, and Miguel Covarrubias's The Fauna and Flora of the Pacific, now at the de Young Museum in Golden Gate Park. The fair also hosted regional games of the first NCAA basketball tournament in the California Coliseum.

A quiet technological story ran through the fair too. Pan American Airways flew the Pacific in large Boeing B-314 flying boats, including the China Clipper, and during much of the fair offered two arriving and two departing flights a week. For a city that wanted a seaplane base and an airport on the bay, the traffic seemed to point to the future. Treasure Island was built with that future in mind.

The money problem

An exposition on this scale costs a great deal, and the 1939 fair did not pay for itself. The shorter first season, the move to reorganize the fair's finances and the creation of a revised 1940 season all point to a business that could not cover its bills from ticket sales and concessions. The 1940 season was shorter and cheaper, with some exhibits changed, but it did not turn the picture around. The comparison to 1915 is a harsh one: the Panama-Pacific fair of 1915 drew more than 18 million visits in a single season, while the 1939 fair needed two seasons to reach about 17 million.

In fairness to the organizers, they were up against forces larger than a fair. The Depression was still in effect in 1939, and by the second season war in Europe had changed what people were willing to spend on pleasure travel. The fair's theme was the Pacific as a meeting ground, a message that looked more fragile with every month of the war in Europe.

The fair on a timeline

The dates hold the sequence in the head better than a narrative does.

Date What happened
1933 A newspaper letter proposes an exposition for the two new bridges
July 1934 San Francisco Bay Exposition, Inc. is incorporated
February 1935 The Yerba Buena Shoals are chosen as the site
February 11, 1936 Dredging begins
October 1936 Chief architect George Kelham dies; Arthur Brown Jr. succeeds him
November 12, 1936 The Bay Bridge opens to traffic
May 27 and 28, 1937 The Golden Gate Bridge opens to pedestrians, then vehicles
February 18, 1939 The first season opens
October 29, 1939 The first season closes, earlier than planned
May 25, 1940 The second season opens
September 29, 1940 The fair closes for good
1941 The Navy takes over the island

Read down the middle of that table and the logic of the fair is plain. Land came first, the bridges second, the party last. The bridges opened in 1936 and 1937, two and a half years before the first visitor walked through a gate, and the exposition was a way of giving them a ceremony. Building the Golden Gate Bridge ran from January 1933 until May 1937 (Building the Golden Gate Bridge, 1933 to 1937), so the fair's first idea, the 1933 letter, arrived the same year the bridge went under construction.

Why a fair, in 1939

A world's fair in the late 1930s was an argument as much as an entertainment. The cities that held them wanted to tell visitors they were modern, connected and confident. For San Francisco that was a particular claim. The city had lost much of its downtown to the 1906 earthquake and fire and had answered with the 1915 fair. Twenty-four years later it was answering a different question: whether the bay, which the two bridges had turned from a barrier into a connection, could be the center of a regional economy.

What became of the island

When the fair closed, the plan to turn the island into a municipal airport ran into the war. The U.S. Navy took over the island, and it operated as Naval Station Treasure Island from 1941 to 1997. The airport idea did not return. Pan American's flying boats, a highlight of the fair, were not the future of the city's air travel, which would grow on the peninsula at the site now known as SFO (SFO, from Mills Field to an international airport).

For more than half a century, then, the island was a military base, and after the Navy's departure in 1997 a district waiting for a new plan. Today it is a neighborhood of the city, reached by the Bay Bridge and served by Muni's 25 Treasure Island bus, and the city's Treasure Island Development Authority, part of the City Administrator's office, oversees its redevelopment (Office of the City Administrator). Readers who want the neighborhood as it is now should start with Treasure Island; the longer account of how the island was made is in Treasure Island, built for a fair.

Looking at the fair now

Very little of the fair survives on the ground. The buildings were designed as temporary structures, and the Navy reused or removed most of them. The street plan is another matter. A visitor who walks the island's waterfront and looks at the arrangement of the roads and the flat, regular outline of the land is seeing the fair's footprint, the 385 acres drawn up in 1935 and filled in 1936.

Two other traces are easier to find. The Rivera mural at City College and the Covarrubias at the de Young are open to the public, and they are the clearest surviving artworks from the fair's Art in Action season. And the Bay Bridge itself, which the fair celebrated, still runs through its tunnel in Yerba Buena Island exactly where the exposition's planners put their island.

The fair's lasting result, then, is not a building but a place: a piece of San Francisco that did not exist before 1936, made from the bottom of the bay for a party that ran two summers.

Related city government

Related guides

Related neighborhoods

Latest on this topic