Blog

The below-market rental lottery

How a San Franciscan applies for an affordable rental through the city's housing portal, how preferences and random numbers rank applicants, and what follows.

Nobody gets a below-market apartment in San Francisco by being first in line. Most of them go by lottery, run by the Mayor's Office of Housing and Community Development through an online portal called DAHLIA, the San Francisco Housing Portal. The city built it this way because the qualified applicants far outnumber the apartments, and because it wanted the outcome to turn on defined rules and random numbers, not on who heard about a listing first. What follows walks through the steps from finding a listing to getting an answer, how the rankings work and the mistakes that cost applicants their place. It is general information; each listing sets its own details, and the sf.gov pages state the current rules.

Step 1: Understand what the lottery is for

The city's affordable housing lottery hands out apartments and homes whose rents or prices are set below market by city programs. Most are offered by lottery on DAHLIA. For a small number of rentals the city reviews applications in the order they arrive instead, and the listing says which method applies. A lottery listing has an application period, and every application that comes in during the period is treated alike, whatever the day or hour. An applicant who finishes on the last afternoon has the same chance as one who applied on the first morning.

Step 2: Find a listing and read it closely

Each listing on DAHLIA describes the building, the number and size of the units, the rent, the income range for eligibility and the application deadline, and it names the preference programs that apply. The preference order can differ from one listing to the next, so the listing page is the authority on how that building ranks applicants. Read the household size and income requirements first: a household outside the range for a building cannot be assigned a unit there.

Step 3: Gather the documents

The application asks about income and about who will live in the unit, and it checks whether the household qualifies for any lottery preference programs. Every preference an applicant claims needs proof. The documents have to be dated within 45 days of the day the application is submitted, which makes the timing of paperwork matter: a paystub or a letter that is 50 days old at submission may not count. The practical move is to collect the documents shortly before applying and to keep a folder of the originals, since applying to several listings is allowed and encouraged, and the same documents may serve more than one application if their dates still fall within the window.

Step 4: Submit the application during the window

The application goes in online through the portal, and the listing gives the deadline. The city's guidance for applicants, published by the Planning Department and the Mayor's Office of Housing and Community Development, notes that the more listings an applicant enters, the better the chances of getting a place. Entering one lottery does not shut an applicant out of another.

Step 5: The drawing and the ranking

When the application period closes, the lottery gives every applicant a random number. The city runs the drawing using random.org, a public random number service. The random numbers do not settle the order on their own. Applicants who qualify for preferences move up, and an applicant with no preference lands in the General Lottery category, which ranks last in line. So the sequence is preferences first, in the order the listing sets, with random numbers sorting applicants inside each preference group.

A hypothetical shows how it plays out. Suppose a listing has 4 units and receives 1,000 applications. Of the applicants, 150 qualify for a preference that ranks first, 100 qualify for one that ranks second and the remaining 750 have no preference. Within each group, the random number sets the order. The four units are offered to people at the top of the list, so the first applicants contacted come from the 150 in the first preference group, in the order of their random numbers. The applicant with no preference sits far down the list and would be reached only if the people ahead decline or are found ineligible. That is why a general-lottery applicant should expect a long wait and should apply widely, and why an applicant with a preference should make sure the proof is in order.

Step 6: Results

Results usually show up on DAHLIA soon after the drawing. The city's guidance says all lottery results are posted online to their listing no later than one week after the lottery. An applicant can look up the listing to see the lottery rank and number. A lottery rank is a place in line, not an offer of a unit.

Step 7: The detailed review

After the lottery, a more detailed application and review begins. A representative from the building contacts applicants about renting or buying in the order of the lottery results, and the applicant then has to submit the full documentation showing the household meets the program's eligibility rules. This is the stage where applicants most often drop out: a document is missing, a household's income is out of range or the household size does not match the unit. Answering the building's representative quickly, within the time the notice gives, protects the applicant's place.

Mistakes that cost applicants

  • Stale documents. Paperwork older than 45 days at the time of application does not count.
  • Missing proof for a preference. A claimed preference without proof is not applied, and the applicant is ranked in the General Lottery category.
  • Missing the contact. The building representative reaches out through the contact information in the application. An applicant who changes email or phone without updating the portal can miss the call.
  • Ignoring the listing's rules. Each listing's income band, household size rule and preference order controls. The general guidance is a starting point, not a substitute for reading the listing.
  • Waiting for a single listing. One lottery is a long shot for most applicants. Entering many is the approach the city's own guide describes.

A sample timeline

A hypothetical applicant, a two-person household, finds a listing that closes on a Friday. The steps might run like this.

  • Three weeks before the deadline. The applicant reads the listing and confirms that the household size and income fit the range. They note that the building offers a preference the household might qualify for.
  • Two weeks before. The applicant collects the proof: recent paystubs, a benefits letter, and the document that supports the preference. Every document is dated within 45 days of the day the application will be submitted, so the applicant checks the dates against the submission date, not the day they started.
  • One week before. The application goes in through the portal. The applicant saves the confirmation.
  • The Friday deadline passes. The lottery is run, and every application, whenever it came in, receives a random number.
  • Within a week. The result is posted on the listing. The applicant sees a rank in the list for their preference category, say 37th among those with that preference. A rank of 37 for a building with 4 units is not hopeless, because people ahead of the applicant may withdraw, may not respond or may be found ineligible when the building reviews their documents.
  • Weeks or months later. The building's representative contacts applicants in rank order. The applicant who is reached submits the full documentation and, if everything fits, signs a lease.

The timeline is invented, and every listing sets its own dates. It shows two things worth knowing. The proof has to be ready before the application goes in, and the rank is only the start of a longer review.

Questions applicants ask

Does applying cost anything? The listing states any charge that applies. An applicant who is asked to pay to enter a lottery should check the listing and the sf.gov page, or call 311, before paying.

Can the same household apply to more than one listing? Yes. The city's own guide says that the more listings an applicant enters, the greater the chance of getting a place.

Does a high number guarantee an apartment? No. Rank is the order in which the building contacts applicants, and the building still has to verify eligibility.

What if the household's situation changes after applying? A change in income, household size or contact information can affect eligibility, and the applicant should update the information in the portal and tell the building when it makes contact.

What is the difference between a lottery and a waiting list? In the lottery, everyone who applies during the window is ranked together, so the day of applying does not matter. A first-come, first-served review, which the city uses for a small number of rentals, rewards early applications.

Who can help

The sf.gov pages explain how the lottery works, and 311, at 415-701-2311 from outside the city, can route a question about the system to the right office. The Mayor's Office of Housing and Community Development runs the lotteries, and the Rent Board's counselors, at 415-252-4600, can answer questions about a tenant's rights once they are in a rent-controlled or other covered unit. Language help is available through 311, which serves callers in over 160 languages. Rent Board and housing agencies describes the city's housing agencies, SF311 Customer Service Center covers the 311 system and Moving to San Francisco: a first-month checklist places housing in a newcomer's checklist.

After the lease is signed

A tenant in a below-market-rate unit is still a tenant. Whether the unit falls under the Rent Ordinance depends on its classification, which Rent control in San Francisco: myths and the 1979 cutoff explains, and some affordable units are governed by their own program rules rather than the Rent Ordinance's annual increase limit. A tenant with questions about increases or about their rights can use Renters' rights and rent control in San Francisco for the general picture and the Rent Board's counselors for specifics. The official explanation of the lottery is at sf.gov.

The details of the program, including income ranges, preference categories and listing procedures, are set by the city and change. The listing on DAHLIA governs.

Related city government

Related guides

Latest on this topic