Blog
The 1934 waterfront and general strikes
The May 9, 1934 longshore strike, Bloody Thursday on July 5 and the four-day general strike of July 16 to 19 shut down much of San Francisco.
Monday, July 16, 1934, was the morning San Francisco quit. The port was already shut. Now tens of thousands of workers who had nothing to do with the docks put down their tools in sympathy with the longshoremen, who had been out for more than two months. The general strike ran four days, and it remains the most dramatic labor action the city has seen. It grew out of a fight that began on the waterfront on May 9.
The strike begins, May 9
On May 9, 1934, longshoremen in every major West Coast port walked off the job, and they would stay off it until July 31. Sailors joined several days later. The strike reached ports from Everett and Seattle in Washington down through Portland and San Francisco to San Pedro in Los Angeles. The men's leading demands were a union hiring hall to replace the morning ritual by which employers picked workers at the dock, known as the shape-up, a contract covering the whole coast and recognition of the union.
The National Park Service names the hiring hall as the top demand. Under the shape-up, men gathered at the docks each morning and foremen chose who worked, a method the dock workers thought arbitrary and ripe for favoritism. A hall run by the union would hand out work in order. Harry Bridges, an Australian-born longshoreman, emerged as one of the strike's most prominent leaders and went on to become one of the significant labor figures of his time. He headed the Joint Marine Strike Committee, which brought together delegates from the maritime unions.
July 3 to July 5: Bloody Thursday
For two months the docks sat closed, and employers and city leaders hunted for a way to open them. On July 3, fights broke out along the Embarcadero between police and strikers as a few trucks got through the picket line. On Thursday, July 5, employers tried to push cargo through the lines under police escort, and a major clash followed near the Embarcadero. The city and the California National Guard tried to open the port by force, according to the Park Service.
Police shot and killed two strikers that day. Most accounts name them as Howard Sperry, a longshoreman and World War I veteran, and Nick Bordoise, a union cook who backed the strike. Accounts differ on exactly how it happened, and the day has been known ever since as Bloody Thursday. A funeral procession for the two men on July 9 drew an enormous crowd; estimates run from several thousand people stretched more than a mile and a half down Market Street to as many as 40,000.
July 16 to 19: the general strike
After Bloody Thursday, the Bay Area's unions moved toward a general strike. On July 14 the San Francisco Labor Council voted to call one. At 8 a.m. on Monday, July 16, it began, and it ran for four days. Estimates of how many workers took part range from more than 100,000 to about 150,000 across the Bay Area. Much of San Francisco shut down.
The city answered hard. On July 17, police and vigilante groups raided radical organizations, and more than 300 arrests were reported that day. On July 19 the Labor Council voted to end the general strike after four days and recommended arbitration of the longshoremen's demands. The longshoremen voted to accept arbitration in every port except Everett, and the waterfront strike formally ended on July 31.
The outcome
The arbitration award came down on October 12, 1934. It gave longshoremen an hourly rate of 95 cents, five cents short of the dollar they had demanded, plus a contract covering the whole West Coast and a union-controlled dispatcher for the hiring hall. The National Park Service sums it up this way: the longshoremen won almost all of their demands, and ports up and down the coast became unionized.
The casualties across the whole strike were serious. The most commonly cited counts are nine deaths, more than 1,000 injuries and more than 500 arrests along the coast, including the two San Francisco deaths on July 5. The strike had a long afterlife as well. In 1937 the West Coast district of the International Longshoremen's Association split from its parent union and eventually became the International Longshore and Warehouse Union, the ILWU. Every July 5, the union closes West Coast ports in memory of Bloody Thursday.
The shape-up and the hiring hall, side by side
At bottom the dispute was about who decides who works, and a hypothetical morning makes the difference plain.
Say a longshoreman shows up at the docks at dawn under the shape-up. A hundred men stand in a crowd, and a foreman looks them over and points to the ones he wants for the day. The men not picked go home without pay. Nothing in the system guarantees that the same men get chosen in turn, that the oldest hands get work or that a man who spoke up for the union gets picked at all.
Under a hiring hall run by a union dispatcher, as the October 12, 1934 arbitration award provided, the same hundred men register at the hall and a dispatcher hands out jobs in order. The employer still decides how many workers it needs, but the union decides who goes. That shift, from a foreman's choice to a dispatcher's list, was the top demand of the strike, according to the Park Service, and the arbitration award gave it to them.
Reading the numbers
A few simple sums give a sense of scale.
- The length. From May 9 to July 31, 1934 is about 83 days, nearly twelve weeks of closed ports.
- The general strike. If 150,000 workers stayed out for four days, as the larger estimates have it, that is up to 600,000 worker-days of lost work in less than a week. Use the smaller estimate of more than 100,000 and the total is still above 400,000.
- The wage. The union demanded a dollar an hour, and the arbitration award set 95 cents, which is 5 percent below the demand. The longshoremen gave up a nickel on the wage and won the hiring hall and the coastwide contract.
- The deaths. Two of the strike's casualties fell in San Francisco on July 5, and the funeral procession on July 9 drew crowds that sources estimate from several thousand to about 40,000, a sign of how far the deaths reached into the city.
A coast and a city
The strike was a West Coast affair that played out differently in each port. In San Pedro two strikers died on May 15, less than a week after it began. In Seattle a striker died on June 30, and another man on July 19, and in Portland a replacement worker died on August 20, after the general strike in San Francisco was over. San Francisco's story is the best known because of the general strike, but it was one piece of a coastwide labor movement. When all the West Coast ports unionized afterward, the 1934 settlement became a change for the whole coast, not just for one city.
A timeline
| Date in 1934 | Event |
|---|---|
| May 9 | Longshoremen strike at every major West Coast port |
| July 3 | Fights on the Embarcadero as a few trucks pass the picket line |
| July 5 | Bloody Thursday; two strikers are killed in San Francisco |
| July 9 | Funeral procession for the two men |
| July 14 | The San Francisco Labor Council votes to call a general strike |
| July 16 | The general strike begins at 8 a.m. |
| July 17 | Police and vigilante raids; more than 300 arrests reported |
| July 19 | The Labor Council votes to end the general strike |
| July 31 | The longshore strike ends |
| October 12 | Arbitration award: 95 cents an hour, a coastwide contract and a union hiring hall |
The arguments, fairly stated
As in any labor dispute, the two sides looked at the same events and saw different things. The strikers and the unions said the shape-up gave employers arbitrary power over workers' lives and that a hiring hall and a coastwide contract were fair demands. Employers and many city officials saw a strike that was closing the port, hurting trade and, with the general strike, spreading to the whole city. The raids of July 17 targeted radical organizations.
The record shows that the strike was settled by arbitration, and that the arbitration awarded the principal demands.
The waterfront today
The places of the strike are still there. The Embarcadero, where the fights of July 3 and 5 took place, is now a boulevard of ferry terminals, walkways and a ballpark, described in The Embarcadero from the Ferry Building to Oracle Park. The Port of San Francisco, which owns the waterfront, is described in Port of San Francisco, and the retail fish program at Fisherman's Wharf, a small piece of what remains of the working waterfront, is in The retail fish program at the Port. South Beach and Rincon Hill sits on the southern waterfront, and the broader story of unions in the city is part of labor contracts and the budget, which looks at how municipal labor agreements affect the city's finances.
The National Park Service's article on the strikes is at nps.gov.