Blog

The retail fish program at the Port

At Fisherman's Wharf commercial fishers sell whole fish and crab straight from their boats. Here is how the Port's program works and what is in season.

Behind the Jefferson Street restaurants at Fisherman's Wharf, out along a pier reached by Al Scoma Way, a commercial fisher can tie up, lift a hatch and sell the morning's catch to whoever is standing on the dock. This is no market stall and no restaurant. It is a boat, and the sale happens on the boat. The Port of San Francisco, which owns the waterfront and leases it to the fleet, calls it the retail fish sales program, and it is one of the few places in the city where the shopper meets the person who caught the fish.

What the Port allows

Under the Port's rules the sale has to take place from the fishing vessel. A selling table on the dock, a stand in a parking area or a counter on any wharf or other structure is out. Fish and crab are sold whole, uncooked and only gilled and gutted, and sales have to follow the city's Health Code. Fishers sell when the weather lets them go out and when they have fish, so there is no fixed schedule. The Port tells shoppers to check the program's Facebook group and Instagram account for updates, since vessels and availability change through the season.

The practical rules for buyers are few and sensible:

  • Go early. Lines are common, and fishers can sell out.
  • Bring your own container, such as a cooler or a bucket.
  • Expect to pay in cash. Some fishers accept electronic payment, but cash is preferred.
  • Do not drive onto the pier. No parking is allowed on Al Scoma Way. Off-street lots and metered parking are nearby, and the 19 and 49 buses and the F historic streetcar stop in the area.

The Port's administrative offices are in the Ferry Building area at Pier 1, on the Embarcadero, and its page for the program is the place to confirm which boats are selling that week. The department's wider role is described at Port of San Francisco.

How the program came to exist

For years the fishers asked for the right to sell directly to the public before the Port agreed. The route to a yes ran through the Port Commission, whose members are appointed by the mayor under rules that give the Board of Supervisors a say. In 2017 the commission authorized a pilot program for off-the-boat retail fish sales, meant to give the fleet more ways to make a living from its catch than selling to wholesalers and processors.

The next step came in the pandemic years. Fisherman's Wharf lost its visitors and its restaurant customers at once. In May 2020 a fire at Pier 45 Shed C hurt the working waterfront further. In 2021 the Port Commission, on November 9, authorized a one-year pilot to add Dungeness crab to the species that could be sold off boats. The first crab sales took place on December 29, 2021, at 3 p.m., the day the commercial crab season opened, and the Port said at the time that five fishers were taking part. Fishers announce when and where they will sell through the Fish Line app, and participating vessels were listed on the Port's crab page.

That crab season opened late for a reason that has become familiar on the West Coast. State and federal fisheries officials delay the start of the Dungeness season when whales and endangered species such as leatherback sea turtles are in the water in numbers that raise the risk of entanglement in crab gear. The pilot's first season was delayed for exactly that reason. So the dates of the crab season shift from year to year, even though the Port's page now describes Dungeness crab as available from December to June.

What is in season

The Port publishes an approximate calendar of what a visitor may find at the retail pier. It says to check NOAA Fisheries or the California Department of Fish and Wildlife for details, because seasons move:

Catch Approximate availability
Dungeness crab December to June
California halibut April to November
Chinook (king) salmon May to October
Coonstripe shrimp, sold live May to October
Albacore tuna August to October
Live anchovies and sardines Summer, from the bait receiver
Rock cod and lingcod Bycatch, no season listed

Two entries deserve a note. Rock cod and lingcod are listed as bycatch, meaning they are caught incidentally while fishers go after other species, and they show up when they show up. The live anchovies and sardines are sold as bait through a bait receiver, so they interest mostly people fishing from charter boats or the pier. For a shopper, the dependable list is crab in winter and spring, halibut from spring through autumn, and salmon and albacore in summer and early fall.

Why the program matters to the waterfront

The Port is a landlord first. It maintains the piers and seawalls along the waterfront, collects rent from tenants ranging from restaurants to ferry operators, runs cruise-ship terminals and parks, and also holds a lease on a harbor full of working boats. Retail fish sales tie together two parts of the Wharf: the restaurants and shops that draw visitors, and the fleet that gave the district its name.

Three effects are worth pulling apart.

Income for fishers. A commercial boat that sells to a wholesaler takes the wholesale price. A boat that sells a whole fish or crab to the person who will cook it takes the retail price. For a small boat in a year when the crab season starts late or the visitors stay away, a retail option can make a real difference.

Short supply chains for shoppers. A whole, gilled and gutted fish bought at the pier has not been through a distributor's cold chain. The buyer sees the species and the condition of the fish, and the fisher answers questions about how it was caught.

Visibility for the working waterfront. The retail pier is a visible argument that Fisherman's Wharf is still a fishing harbor. Sport fishing charters share the water: the Port notes that they berth at the Jefferson Street lagoon and Hyde Street Harbor, and visitors can join a bay expedition for small or large groups.

A working waterfront under pressure

The retail program is a small part of a large job, and the pressures on it are the ones bearing on the whole waterfront. The Port's own site describes a district with ferry service, cruises, bay excursions, commercial fishing, retail fish sales and parks. It also describes a Waterfront Resilience Program, which addresses sea level rise along the city's shoreline. A fishing fleet depends on piers, fuel docks and berths, and the structures that hold them up are exactly the ones the resilience work has to protect.

The fleet has also taken several shocks in a short time. The pandemic emptied the Wharf of visitors and restaurant customers. A fire at Pier 45 Shed C in May 2020 damaged the working waterfront. The Dungeness season was delayed in 2021 to protect whales and endangered turtles from entanglement. The retail program, begun as a pilot in 2017 and widened to crab in 2021, gives fishers another way to sell their catch. The same Wharf is home to the Aquatic Park Historic District and to the charter boats that carry visitors out on the bay, so the waterfront is a place where workers and tourists share one edge of the city. The Embarcadero from the Ferry Building to Oracle Park follows that edge along the whole bayfront.

What to ask the fisher

Because the seller is the person who caught the fish, the pier is a place to ask questions a store clerk could not answer:

  • What is it, and where was it caught? Species and area help a buyer judge freshness and compare a fish with what a store sells.
  • When was it caught? A boat that came in this morning has a different product from one that has been at sea for days.
  • How should it be cleaned? The program sells fish gilled and gutted only, so scales, fins and head are still on, and the buyer finishes the job. Many fishers are glad to explain how.
  • Is more coming? Selling depends on weather and catch, so the answer tells a buyer whether to come back the next day.

A morning at the pier, step by step

  1. Check the announcements. The program's Facebook group and Instagram account list who is selling and what they have.
  2. Plan to arrive early. Lines are common and fishers can sell out.
  3. Arrive by transit if you can. The 19 and 49 buses and the F streetcar all serve the Wharf, and parking in the area is hard to come by. Walkers can reach the pier from the Embarcadero.
  4. Bring a cooler with ice and a bucket, and some cash.
  5. Buy whole fish or crab. The program does not allow cooked food or cleaned fillets, so the fish will need preparing at home.

The same stretch of waterfront leads to other places a visitor may want to see. The area is covered in Fisherman's Wharf, and the story of the fishery that supplies the crab is in dungeness crab and the waterfront. For another kind of local stop that costs nothing to look at, the city's free-activities guide at Free things to do in San Francisco lists waterfront walks and viewpoints.

Questions the program raises

Not everything about the program is settled, and the debates are worth knowing.

  • Who can sell. Participation is limited to vessels that meet the Port's eligibility rules, which the Port sets and has adjusted since the 2017 pilot. Anyone interested in selling should read the current rules on the Port's page.
  • Health regulation. Because sales happen on a vessel, they fall under the Health Code in ways a farmers' market stall does not. That is why the sales are limited to whole fish that are gilled and gutted only.
  • Crowding. The retail pier is on Al Scoma Way, a working street behind the Jefferson Street businesses, which is why no parking is allowed there.

For the program's current rules, contact the Port at 415-274-0400 or read its pages at sfport.com.

Related city government

Related guides

Related neighborhoods

Latest on this topic