Blog
Incorporation and consolidation, 1850 and 1856
How San Francisco became a city in 1850 and a city and county in one in 1856: the dates, the Larkin and 9th Street line, and what changed on July 1, 1856.
Two dates from the 1850s explain nearly everything odd about how San Francisco is governed. On April 15, 1850, the California legislature incorporated San Francisco as a city, five months before California itself became a state. On April 19, 1856, the legislature passed the Consolidation Act and folded the city and its county into a single government. The first date turned a town into a municipality. The second turned that municipality into something with no real twin, and the basic design is still the one in use.
April 15, 1850: a city on paper
By 1850 the settlement called Yerba Buena only a few years earlier held, by the usual estimates, some 25,000 full-time residents. It needed a charter, a legal identity, and the power to tax, borrow and build. The legislature gave it all that on April 15, 1850. The first charter fixed the boundary at Larkin and 9th Streets. Past that line lay open sand, farms and the land of the former mission.
The government came together fast. The charter vote and the first election of the city's governing body took place on the same day, May 1, 1850, and the council took office on May 6. It was called the Common Council, and it had two chambers, a Board of Aldermen and a Board of Assistant Aldermen, each with one member from each of the city's eight wards, 16 members in all. It was the forerunner of the Board of Supervisors. The seventh and last Common Council served until July 1856.
California became a state on September 9, 1850. San Francisco County, which the state had organized, took in the city and a large area to the south. For the next six years the city and the county were two governments on overlapping ground, each with its own officers and its own budget.
Two governments, one population
Under the 1850 arrangement the city covered the built-up area, and the county covered that area plus the open land south of it. A resident of the city was a resident of the county too, and paid both. A job like running a hospital or keeping records could belong to either one, and two sets of officials had to agree on whose it was.
The line moved, too. A charter of 1851 pushed the city's western boundary out beyond Larkin Street, and in the summer of 1855 commissioners were appointed to lay out streets and blocks west of Larkin, out to the 1851 charter line. The edges of the city were being drawn on a map before anyone lived there.
1855: a new charter and the Van Ness Ordinance
The last year before consolidation was a burst of civic housekeeping. Voters approved a new city charter on May 5, 1855. Two days later the council passed an ordinance on the city's legal and equitable debt, creating a board of examiners and setting compensation and final redemption. In late May the supervisors, who by then sat for the county, authorized $24,000 to buy a county hospital on Greenwich Street near Jones. On July 1, James Van Ness was sworn in as the seventh mayor.
On September 27, 1855, the Common Council approved the Van Ness Ordinance, which tackled the muddle of land titles and reserved land for parks, hospitals, fire and police stations and schools. It is why the Western Addition has a number of old public blocks, among them the sites of today's Alamo Square, Duboce Park and Jefferson Square. The ordinance is the clearest sign that the city's leaders saw an institution with a permanent geography. From Yerba Buena to San Francisco, 1846 to 1847 describes the street surveys that came before.
Money was tight. In November 1855 the council cut 40 positions from the police department to hold down the cost of government. In February 1856 the city assessor reported taxable property within the city at $33,226,215.
April 19, 1856: the Consolidation Act
The act the legislature passed on April 19, 1856 had a title that said what it did: it repealed the several city charters, established the boundaries of the city and county, and consolidated the government. It reconstituted the city as the City and County of San Francisco and made the city and county boundaries the same. It also carved San Mateo County out of the southern part of the old San Francisco County. That is why the peninsula south of the present city line, including the ground where San Francisco International Airport later stood, belongs to another county. The act's boundaries took in the Farallon Islands in the Pacific and the islands in the bay known then as the Alcatraces and Yerba Buena.
The act was to take effect on July 1, 1856, and it did. Among the changes:
- The two governments merged into a single political entity.
- The Common Council was replaced by the first Board of Supervisors.
- The office of City Sexton was abolished.
- The Recorder's Court was replaced by the Police Court.
- The city's offices were reorganized so that one set of officers served both the city and the county.
On June 30, 1856, Mayor Van Ness's term ended. On July 8, George J. Whelan was elected president of the Board of Supervisors to serve as mayor. On November 4 of that year the office of Chief of Police was created, and James F. Curtis was elected to it. Consolidation had not fixed everything, but it had left the city one government to repair.
What was kept and what was lost
What changed was who governed and how many bodies there were. The Common Council had 16 members elected by ward. The Board of Supervisors that replaced it is the ancestor of today's eleven-member Board, which is elected by district and acts as both city council and county board. The sheriff, the assessor, the treasurer and other county officers survived, now serving one jurisdiction. The idea that a single government could handle both urban and county work was new in California and has stayed unusual.
What the act did not settle was how the pieces would fit together day to day. The city's boundaries were final from 1856, but legal disputes over land titles dragged on into the mid-1860s. The planning department's account says the city "officially became the City and County of San Francisco in 1856," and that street platting in undeveloped areas was often done by investors holding tracts of land, who submitted maps to the city for approval.
The same structure today
Most of what residents see of consolidation is invisible now. One mayor, one board, one budget, one sales tax rate and one 311 line serve a place that in 1855 had two governments. Why San Francisco is both a city and a county describes how the merged government works in practice, from the sheriff to the school district. the eleven districts and what a supervisor does shows how the Board of Supervisors, heir to the 1856 board, is organized now. The county side of City Hall is the record of the county side, and Board of Supervisors describes the Board.
The line the 1856 act drew has one more lasting effect. The city's total area includes water as well as land, because the act attached the Farallon Islands and the bay's islands to the city. The Census Bureau counts 46.91 square miles of land and 185.00 square miles of water, for a total of 231.91 square miles.
1850, 1856 and now
Set the three periods side by side and you can see how much of the original design survives.
| 1850 | After July 1856 | 2026 | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Governments | City and county, separate | One City and County | One City and County |
| Legislative body | Common Council, 16 members from 8 wards | Board of Supervisors | Board of Supervisors, 11 members elected by district |
| Western edge | Larkin and 9th Streets | The line of the 1851 charter | The Pacific Ocean, with the Farallon Islands attached |
| County to the south | Part of San Francisco County | San Mateo County | San Mateo County |
Public finance changed even more. The city assessor reported taxable property within the city at $33,226,215 in February 1856. The mayor's proposed budget for fiscal year 2026-27 is $16.9 billion. One figure is the value of taxable property and the other is a year of spending, so one cannot be divided into the other, but together they show what the same institution is now asked to carry.
Finding the 1850 line
The edge drawn in 1850 can still be found. Larkin Street is where the Main Library stands, at 100 Larkin Street, and the Asian Art Museum at 200 Larkin Street is on the same street, both at the edge of Civic Center. When the first charter set the city's boundary at Larkin and 9th Streets, it drew the line where the settled streets stopped and the sand began. A few years later the city's own commissioners were laying out blocks west of that line. A walk through Civic Center today crosses the old boundary, and City Hall itself, rebuilt in 1915 as described in City Hall rebuilt, 1915, stands just beyond it.
Why the date still matters
The 1856 act is why a San Franciscan has one set of local officers instead of two, and why "which county is that in?" has a single answer inside the city limits. It is also why the airport, owned by the city, sits outside it. Anyone trying to follow a modern fight over a sheriff's budget, a county hospital or the school district's dual role as a county office of education is looking at an arrangement set up in the summer of 1856 and adjusted ever since by charters, state law and the voters. The tools for adjusting it, charter amendments placed on the ballot by the Board of Supervisors or by petition, are described in how a charter amendment reaches the ballot.
The timeline
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| April 15, 1850 | The legislature incorporates the city, with a boundary at Larkin and 9th Streets |
| May 1, 1850 | The first charter vote and the first election of the Common Council; the council takes office May 6 |
| September 9, 1850 | California becomes a state |
| 1851 | A new charter moves the city's western line beyond Larkin |
| May 5, 1855 | Voters approve a new city charter |
| September 27, 1855 | The Van Ness Ordinance addresses land titles and reserves land for public uses |
| April 19, 1856 | The Consolidation Act passes and San Mateo County is created |
| July 1, 1856 | The Consolidation Act takes effect; the first Board of Supervisors replaces the Common Council |
| July 8, 1856 | George J. Whelan is elected president of the Board to serve as mayor |
| November 4, 1856 | The office of Chief of Police is created |
The Planning Department's historic context statements and the Board of Supervisors' history pages, at sf.gov, tell how the institutions of 1856 grew into the ones in City Hall today.