Blog

From Yerba Buena to San Francisco, 1846 to 1847

A timeline of how the trading cove of Yerba Buena became San Francisco: the 1846 flag-raising, the first American alcalde, the 1847 survey and the renaming.

Before it was San Francisco, it was a cove with a smell of wild mint and a handful of adobe houses, and it had a different name. For its first seventy years the place had two names and two centers. The Spanish fort and mission, founded in 1776, used the name of the saint. The small trading settlement that grew up between them, on an east-facing cove, used another: Yerba Buena, "good herb." A few miles of sand and scrub separated the two, and for decades most people in the settlement had little to do with either. It took a war, an appointed magistrate and a newspaper notice to merge the names, and the whole change took place in about five months, between the summer of 1846 and the winter of 1847.

Before the change: the trading cove

When Mexico won independence from Spain in 1821, trade that Spain had prohibited began to flourish. Yerba Buena became a popular trading spot on the cove at the northern end of the peninsula, where ships could anchor and take on hides, tallow and other goods. William Richardson is credited with the area's first dwelling, which, by some accounts, started as little more than a sail nailed to four posts, then became a rudimentary wooden shack and finally an adobe house like those of the established Californios. Jacob Leese, another trader, soon joined him. By 1839 a small road, the Calle de la Fundacion, had been hollowed through the settlement, roughly where Grant Avenue runs today.

Mexican authorities then asked Jean-Jacques Vioget to plat a town. Vioget's plat of 1839, known as the 50 Vara Survey, laid out a grid of twelve rectangular blocks around Portsmouth Square, aligned to the compass points. It was bounded by Kearny and Grant Streets, which run north and south, and by Sacramento, Clay, Washington, Jackson and Pacific Streets, which run east and west. A civilian port, the Pueblo of Yerba Buena, was established by 1835 in the area of present-day California and Montgomery Streets. That is why the Financial District's oldest streets and Chinatown's main streets begin where the first settlers drew them. Chinatown and Financial District sit on the old cove's shore.

July 1846: the flag goes up

The war between the United States and Mexico, which began in 1846, was fought mostly elsewhere, with its main conflict centered in Texas. San Francisco's part in it was brief. In July 1846 Captain John B. Montgomery sailed the U.S.S. Portsmouth into the bay and landed in Yerba Buena. By the city's planning department's account, the town was effectively taken over with little to no resistance from what it calls a sleepy trading settlement. The American flag went up over the plaza, and the square, later called Portsmouth Square, was named for the ship; Montgomery Street was named for the captain.

August 26, 1846: the first American alcalde

The settlement's civil government under Mexico had been headed by an alcalde, a municipal magistrate with both judicial and administrative powers. After the American takeover the office carried on under new management. On August 26, 1846, Washington Bartlett was named the first American alcalde of Yerba Buena. The office combined the duties its name implies, and in a village of a few hundred people the alcalde decided disputes, regulated land and issued the orders that made a small trading post resemble a town.

January 1847: a new name

On January 23, 1847, according to the Planning Department's historic context statement, Yerba Buena was officially renamed San Francisco. The notice appeared in the California Star newspaper on January 30, 1847, which is the date commonly given for the public announcement. The change came after a brief rivalry with the future city of Benicia, which had also been vying to be known as Francisca. Naming the town San Francisco, after the bay and the saint, is generally read as a way of securing the name for the cove settlement. Permanent residents at the time numbered about 500.

The new name tied the settlement to the bay, the mission and the fort, which already carried the saint's name.

1847: the survey that made Market Street

Soon after the renaming the alcalde faced a different problem: lots. Level land near the cove was scarce and in demand, and the 1839 grid left little room for a growing town. The alcalde asked a resident, Jasper O'Farrell, to expand the city grid through a new plan in 1847. O'Farrell's plan extended streets into the shallow waters of the bay, first by building wharves and later by filling the cove. It also created the 120-foot-wide Market Street corridor, running at an angle across the old grid, which would serve as a bridge between two different street patterns: perpendicular lots and straight streets to the north, and wider, angled streets to the southeast.

The surveyors then platted a second grid south of Market. In the city's own words, the 100 Vara Survey laid out the area south of Market on a street grid aligned to Market itself, with quadruple-sized lots, in conflict with the 50 Vara grid to the north. The two surveys still describe the city's streets today: blocks north of Market and blocks south of it meet at awkward angles, and the long diagonal of Market is where they come together.

A vara was a Spanish unit of length. The 1776 Presidio enclosure was recorded as 92 varas, about 253 feet, on a side, which makes a vara about 2.75 feet. On that arithmetic, a 50 vara lot is about 137 feet on a side and a 100 vara lot about 275 feet, which is why the blocks south of Market run so much larger than the ones to the north.

What the timeline looks like

  • 1776: Presidio and mission founded. See The founding of Mission Dolores and the Presidio, 1776.
  • 1821: Mexico wins independence, and trade at the cove grows.
  • 1835: The Pueblo of Yerba Buena is established near California and Montgomery Streets.
  • 1839: Vioget's 50 Vara Survey lays out twelve blocks around Portsmouth Square.
  • July 1846: U.S. forces take Yerba Buena without resistance.
  • August 26, 1846: Washington Bartlett becomes the first American alcalde.
  • January 23 and 30, 1847: The renaming to San Francisco and its public announcement.
  • 1847: O'Farrell's survey creates Market Street and extends the grid into the bay.
  • 1848: Gold is discovered, and the Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo transfers California to the United States.
  • 1850: The state legislature incorporates the city, on April 15.

Reading the grid today

The two surveys explain a puzzle every visitor notices. Walk from the Financial District south across Market Street and the blocks change on you: the streets turn to run parallel to Market, at an angle to the ones you left, and the blocks get larger. That is the meeting of the 50 Vara grid, platted for the old cove and aligned to the points of the compass, and the 100 Vara grid, laid out for the land south of Market and aligned to Market itself, with lots four times the size.

A worked example makes the difference plain. A 50 vara block is about 137 feet on a side, so a city lot on it is small enough that a few dozen fit in a downtown neighborhood. A 100 vara block is about 275 feet on a side, twice as long in each direction and four times the area. The South of Market blocks still carry that scale. South of Market describes the district that grew on the larger grid.

Market Street itself, 120 feet wide, was designed to be the dividing line and the connector. It runs northeast to southwest from the old waterfront.

The land question

Platting streets was easy compared with settling who owned the land. Some disputes began in the Mexican period, when land grants were not always precisely recorded, and the legal battles among property owners, the city and the state continued until the mid-1860s. Investors who held tracts platted streets in undeveloped areas and submitted the maps to the city. The 1855 Van Ness Ordinances, an attempt to clear up the confusion over deeds to public land, set aside certain blocks as open space, among them the sites of today's Alamo Square, Duboce Park and Jefferson Square. The same ordinances extended the street grid west through the Western Addition as far as Divisadero Street.

The point for the 1846-1847 story is that a renaming and a survey were not the end of the matter. They set a pattern, one set of streets for the cove and another for the south, that the city spent the next two decades fitting its land titles to. The final boundaries of the city came with the Consolidation Act of 1856, which also joined the city and county governments and separated the city from San Mateo County. Why San Francisco is both a city and a county explains what that merger means now.

What came next

The quiet town did not stay quiet. The planning department notes that by 1852 San Francisco had gone from a harbor of about 400 inhabitants to a boom town of tents, shacks and cabins housing a diverse, international population of approximately 35,000. The renaming had barely dried when the rush began. Gold Rush city, 1848 and 1849 covers the first two years of that change, and incorporation and consolidation, 1850 and 1856 covers how the city became a government.

Population figures for these early years differ from account to account, because they are estimates, not censuses: 500 permanent residents in 1847 in one account, 400 in another, around 1,000 by 1848 in a third. The common thread is that the town was tiny before the gold and enormous within a few years.

Where to see the old cove

The shoreline of Yerba Buena Cove no longer exists as a shoreline. The cove was filled in during the Gold Rush and afterward, and its former edge lies under what are now the streets of the Financial District. A walker can still trace it: Montgomery Street, which ran along the old waterfront, is the place to start, and The Financial District and Montgomery Street follows it. Portsmouth Square, now a public park in Chinatown, is where the flag went up in 1846, and A walk up Grant Avenue through Chinatown runs along the old Calle de la Fundacion. The Planning Department's historic context statements, available on the department's website at sfplanning.org, contain the full account of these decades and of the survey that still shapes the street grid.

Related city government

Related guides

Related neighborhoods

Latest on this topic