Blog

Gold Rush city, 1848 and 1849

San Francisco emptied in 1848 as men left for the goldfields, then filled with an estimated 25,000 people by 1849. Why population figures for those years vary.

First the town emptied. In the spring of 1848 San Francisco was shrinking, and a place that had held perhaps a thousand people at the start of the year watched its workers, clerks and sailors walk off toward the Sierra Nevada foothills. By late May the word was that the town stood half empty. Eighteen months later it was a crowded boom town of tents, wooden shacks and ships turned into buildings, with a population commonly put at 25,000. No other American city had grown so far so fast, and the numbers that describe the growth are as unreliable as they are dramatic.

A town of fewer than a thousand

Before the gold, San Francisco was a small port. The National Park Service notes that the town had fewer than 1,000 inhabitants before 1848, mostly sailors, fishermen, whalers and fur trappers. Other sources give lower counts for the years just before: the city's planning department puts the permanent population at about 500 when Yerba Buena was renamed in January 1847, and describes a harbor of about 400 inhabitants before the boom. A widely cited reference gives around 200 residents in 1846 and about 1,000 in 1848. The figures differ because they were estimates by observers at different moments, in a period when the town changed from week to week.

What the town had was a harbor. Before the rush it had only temporary wood-frame shacks along the waterfront, plus the Presidio and Mission Dolores, its only permanent buildings. From Yerba Buena to San Francisco, 1846 to 1847 tells how the settlement got its name and its first street plan, and The founding of Mission Dolores and the Presidio, 1776 covers the two Spanish buildings.

January to May 1848: the news and the exodus

Gold was discovered in January 1848 in the Sierra Nevada foothills, at the sawmill of John Sutter's operation at Coloma. For weeks the news moved slowly and was met with doubt. By March, a San Francisco merchant and newspaper publisher named Samuel Brannan was convinced. He opened a store selling prospecting supplies, bought up the available gear in the city and, in the story told in later accounts, walked the streets shouting that gold had been found on the American River. He resold the supplies at a profit as the rush began.

The effect on the town was immediate. People left for the mines, and the town lost its workforce. By late May 1848, as the state park service's account of the Marshall Gold Discovery puts it, San Francisco was reported half empty as men left for the mines. Businesses closed. Ships anchored in the harbor lost their crews. The town that had served as the gateway to a quiet province was about to become the gateway to the biggest migration in the American West, but its first reaction was to empty out.

Summer and fall 1848: the return

The merchants and the ships that stayed found that the people who left would need everything: tools, food, clothing, lodging and a way to turn dust and nuggets into spending money. The city's port was an obvious access point to inland California, the planning department notes, and businesses related to gold mining, banking, food processing and dry goods trading began to establish themselves. The town first became a ghost town of abandoned ships and businesses before merchants and new arrivals revived it.

The Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo had in 1848 transferred California to the United States, so the people who arrived in the following year landed in a territory with an American government, though California was not yet a state.

1849: the arrivals

The next year changed the scale. The National Park Service says the city's population grew to 25,000 in 1849 as gold fever spread across the country. Another account counts about 40,000 people arriving by ship at San Francisco Bay in 1849, among them about 700 women. They came from all over the world, in the park service's phrase, and the planning department describes a diverse, international population living in a town of tents, shacks and cabins.

Many of the newcomers were on their way to the goldfields, and others came back. That is one reason the population figures are hard to pin down: a city with 25,000 people on a given day may have held a very different number a month earlier and a month later.

Where everyone slept

The city's managers could not build shelter fast enough, according to the National Park Service. The boom produced makeshift tent houses, hotels, stores, saloons, gambling halls and shanties. Miners and newcomers lived in tents, in wooden shanties or in deck cabins removed from abandoned ships.

The ships tell the best story. Hundreds of vessels that had carried passengers and cargo into the bay were abandoned when their crews deserted for the goldfields. Many were hauled up on the mud and converted to warehouses, stores, taverns and hotels, and one became a jail. In later years, many were broken up or buried and used as landfill, as the shoreline was pushed out into the shallow cove. The old cove's edge, described in The Financial District and Montgomery Street, was filled with the debris of the rush.

The fires that followed, in the early 1850s, destroyed many of the early buildings, leaving, in the planning department's phrase, a very faint footprint of early residences. The planning department's survey has found no surviving houses from before 1848 within the city limits.

Why the population figures vary

Almost every figure in this period is an estimate, and each has a reason to differ. A table of the numbers used in the sources shows the spread:

Year Figure Where it comes from
1846 About 200 A general reference on the Gold Rush
1847 About 500 permanent residents City Planning Department
Before 1848 Fewer than 1,000 National Park Service
1848 About 1,000 A general reference on the Gold Rush
1849 About 25,000 National Park Service
1849 arrivals by ship About 40,000, including about 700 women A general reference on the Gold Rush
1850 About 25,000 full-time residents A general reference on the Gold Rush
1852 About 35,000 to 36,000 City Planning Department and a general reference

Several things produce the spread:

  1. No census. The count of 1849 is commonly cited but is an estimate, not an enumeration, and the people being counted were arriving, leaving and moving on.
  2. Different definitions. Some figures count "permanent" or "full-time" residents, and others count everyone present. In a tent city where people stayed for weeks, the difference is large.
  3. Different dates. A figure for the start of a year and one for the end of the same year can be five or ten times apart.
  4. Arrivals versus residents. Counts of arrivals by ship are a different thing from counts of residents. A ship brings people to a port that most of them leave.

The right way to use these numbers is as orders of magnitude: hundreds before the rush, tens of thousands within two years.

How fast was it? Some arithmetic

Using the National Park Service's figures, going from fewer than 1,000 residents before 1848 to about 25,000 in 1849 is roughly a 25-fold increase in about a year and a half. Measured from the 1846 figure of about 200, the 1849 estimate is more than a hundred times larger. The planning department's later figure, about 35,000 in 1852, shows that growth slowed sharply afterward: three more years added about 10,000 people, or 40 percent, to the 1849 estimate. The great leap, in other words, came in the first twelve to eighteen months.

Growth of that size in a few months leaves traces that last for decades. A town that must house 24,000 additional people in a year cannot plan streets, sewers or fire protection in advance. The unplanned, wooden character of the early city and the fires that repeatedly destroyed it follow from the arithmetic.

Where the new city put its people

The earliest districts of the boom were downtown and along the shore. The planning department's context statement describes the first wave of residential development at Rincon Hill and South Park, where early Gothic Revival and Italianate mansions of the well-to-do were built in the 1850s and 1860s, and at the foot of Rincon Hill, in working-class areas known as Happy Valley, Pleasant Valley and Tar Flat, where prefabricated cottages and simple wooden housing went up. The city built itself first on the shore, then pushed south and west.

By 1852 the city's footprint ran from the Marina southward along what is now Divisadero Street into the Castro and eastward through the Mission and Potrero Hill, though some lots were under water at the marshy fringes and sand dunes made settlement toward the west difficult. A plank toll road built in 1851 connected South of Market with Mission Dolores, which at the time was still a small settlement around the original mission. The Mission became one of the first outlying neighborhoods served by horse-drawn streetcars, but in the 1850s it served mainly as a recreation area, with pleasure gardens, beer rooms and roadhouses.

The earliest known surviving residences in the city date to 1852 and 1853, primarily in the Mission, Telegraph Hill and Pacific Heights. They survive in perimeter neighborhoods that avoided the wholesale destruction of fires and later changes closer to downtown. South of Market, where the most intense population growth took place, lost almost all of its early housing. The neighborhoods where that early growth is easiest to trace today include South of Market, Telegraph Hill and Mission District.

By the end of the 1850s the city had, in the planning department's words, undergone a staggering transformation. The discovery of Nevada's Comstock Lode in 1859 set off a silver rush that helped turn around an economic slump of the mid-1850s and brought more people, money and industry. The rush that began with gold in 1848 had made San Francisco a city. It took the next decade to learn how to run one.

What the years left behind

The Gold Rush created several things that still define the city. It created a port economy, with banking, shipping and supply businesses that served the mines. It created a diverse population from the beginning, which the planning department calls international. It created a landscape of filled land, with the old cove replaced by streets. And it created the pressure that produced the city's first formal government. incorporation and consolidation, 1850 and 1856 tells how the state legislature incorporated the city on April 15, 1850, and how, in 1856, the city and county became one.

The Financial District, where the cove, the ships and the first banks once stood, is described in Financial District, and the city's broader neighborhoods are mapped in A guide to San Francisco's neighborhoods. The National Park Service's pages on the Gold Rush and the city, at nps.gov, summarize the period.

Related city government

Related guides

Related neighborhoods

Latest on this topic